Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Unfussy institution serving traditional Italian & American fare, including pasta, burgers & steak.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 7 W Main St, Middletown, NY 10940
Phone: (845) 344-3743
Website: http://eriegrille.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
DeStefano’s Olde Erie – Middletown
Saturday 2pm-9pm. Sunday & Monday – Restaurant Closed. Location. 7 West Main St. Middletown, NY 10940. DeStefano’s Olde Erie. 7 West Main St. Middletown, NY …
Destefano’s Olde Erie | Middletown NY – Facebook
We will be serving some Irish specialities Tuesday March 17th all day. Come and try our Irish quesadillas, Shepard pie potato skins, corned beef Reuben and of …
Destefano’s Olde Erie (@destefanosoldeerie) – Instagram
Tag us in your favorite dish! 7 West Main Street Middletown, NY Visit us online at http://eriegrille.com/Menu.html. Give us a call at (845)-344-3743 …
Reviews
Jason Lemke
Everything was delicious. Scallop with bacon and Bluepoint oysters to start. Beef Barley soup included with meal, Ravioli with meatballs were awesome. Carrot cake to go for dessert was perfect.
… moreTimothy Fenfert
Outstanding food and huge portions. Very fair prices considering all the food. We both brought home enough for another meal tomorrow. Service was terrific even on a very busy Saturday night. We will definitely be back.
… moreJessica terpstra
Gorgeous lights, delicious food, amazi.g actually! We love eating here and our server was super nice!
… moreD Guag
I had my wedding reception here on 11/22. The food was AMAZING, the loft looked gorgeous, the bar tenders and bus boys were so helpful and lovely. The bar tenders made sure my husband and I had plates of food so we remembered to eat. People kept complimenting the venue to me. Marie was amazing to deal with and I cannot think of a single thing that I would change or complain about. Thank you to the staff for a perfect evening.
… moreGina Boula
On 12/12/25, a Friday night, , my husband and I , visited DeStafano’s Olde Erie restaurant for dinner. The First thing we noticed when we arrived , was how welcoming and beautifully decorated for the season this place was ! I mean WOW, we felt like it was Christmas TONIGHT !!
The staff were all cheery and accommodating and they all HUSTLED their Butt’s OFF !! They were SO BUSY we were lucky to have been seated. We ordered appetizers and drinks. The special holiday drinks were DELICIOUS and I NEVER ORDER MORE THAN 2 DRINKS Ever, when I am out for the evening…. Well , I had 3 !!! Kalua, something and another, plus a vanilla rum and milk
The wings we ate were delicious and came out quick for the kitchen being BUSY. I also had a chicken salad sandwich with a very filling house salad ( also delicious)and generously portioned. My husband also enjoyed his veal parmigiana sandwich. Overall, I rate Destafano’s
Olde Erie, in
Middletown NY, 4 Stars
Thank you for the Lovely Experience, the Fantastic and Friendly Service, and Delicious Eats. We will go back again. Merry Christmas Season Y’ALL
… moreThe staff were all cheery and accommodating and they all HUSTLED their Butt’s OFF !! They were SO BUSY we were lucky to have been seated. We ordered appetizers and drinks. The special holiday drinks were DELICIOUS and I NEVER ORDER MORE THAN 2 DRINKS Ever, when I am out for the evening…. Well , I had 3 !!! Kalua, something and another, plus a vanilla rum and milk
The wings we ate were delicious and came out quick for the kitchen being BUSY. I also had a chicken salad sandwich with a very filling house salad ( also delicious)and generously portioned. My husband also enjoyed his veal parmigiana sandwich. Overall, I rate Destafano’s
Olde Erie, in
Middletown NY, 4 Stars
Thank you for the Lovely Experience, the Fantastic and Friendly Service, and Delicious Eats. We will go back again. Merry Christmas Season Y’ALL
Alyssa Sanchez
I’ve never left a Google review but I must say this restaurant was absolutely amazing! The drinks were fantastic, the food was amazing! The portions were huge and you can tell everything was made with love. The ambience was beautiful and our waitress (i think her name was Ellie?) was so sweet and friendly, thank you to everyone 🙂 This was an absolutely amazing date night with my boyfriend! 10/10 recommend
… moreEvelyn F
Can’t say enough about this place. From separate rooms for private parties, too an amazing attentive bar and then a fabulous dining room set with tons of lights! The food…always enough for two (except the sandwiches of course) and so so delectable! One of my top 5 in the area!!
… moreRaymond Suarez
Place is amazing ing high class location where the food and atmosphere is unlike anything I’ve ever had highly recommend does not feel like your in ny great service great location great environment
… moreStephanie Gesztesi
We had a large group and had dinner family style. Everything was delicious! We had penne ala vodka, chicken francaise, prime rib, salad, potatoes, and some vegetables.
The staff was super friendly and attentive. The room was decorated beautifully.
Highly recommend.
… moreThe staff was super friendly and attentive. The room was decorated beautifully.
Highly recommend.