Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Pizza Plus, we believe that best authentic Italian recipes using only the freshest ingredients. Our meals hand-prepared with fresh pastas and the freshest regional ingredients. Always comfortable, Pizza Plus delivers a welcoming and fun casual experience. Buon Appetito.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 15202 NW 147th Dr #100, Alachua, FL 32615
Phone: (386) 418-3857
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: newyorkpizzaplusfl.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
New York Pizza Plus Online Menu | Best Italian food in Alachua
New York Pizza Plus Online Menu. Save Money Ordering Directly Here. Healthy Options. Fast Service. Friendly Team. Top Rated.
Best Italian food in Alachua, FL | New York Pizza Plus | Italian food …
We serve the best lunch buffet in Alachua County. Hot pasta dishes, delicious pizza, and a massive salad bar with fresh fruit and homemade cream puffs and much …
New york pizza plus | Alachua FL – Facebook
At NY Pizza Plus, we believe that best authentic Italian recipes using only the freshest ingredients. Italian Restaurant · $$ · (386) 418-3857.
Reviews
B.J. Gober
The main dinning room is a little nicer than buffet side. The buffet has a variety of pizza and a nice salad bar. The salad bar is fresh even fresh sliced avocado. You should find some type of pizza you will like on the buffet. Expect to pay $17 per person for the buffet all in food drink and tax. I would say go give this place a try. Clean comfortable and friendly service.
… moreWilliam Lieblick (Billy)
We visited for dinner and the staff were extremely friendly and the food was good. We enjoyed the grandma pizza so much that we returned the next day for a whole pie. Definitely stopping by next time we’re in the area!
… moreRay Miller
Staff was friendly and helpful. Buffet (11am – 3pm) was delicious! Fish (tilapia?) was drenched in a delightful, light teriyaki sauce. Simple beef and mushrooms reminded me of an excellent bourguignon or cabernet sauvignon: tender, not overcooked and without all the extra vegetables. The chicken with sautéed rosemary potatoes practically fell off the bone and the potatoes were perfection, slight crust outside, tender on the inside. Pepperoni, ham and bacon had well balanced flavors. Made another trip to the buffet to try the stuffed zucchini (chicken, ham, minced onion, light bread, cheese? and white wine) well made, and the eggplant parmesan was also very good. Even the cucumber salad was just right – not too salty or sour. Kudos to the owner and his chefs – a delight to the pallette! Even the long-time patrons were quite congenial, giving high marks for the great quality freshness and variety of food.
… moreBrandi Trancynger
Wow! We had the Fettuccine Alfredo with Shrimp and NY style cheese pizza with fresh garlic rolls. It was amazing! We were traveling through and my son decided he wanted Pizza. Great choice and everything is fresh and tasted amazing and authentic. They even had jars of sauce and sauce things to purchase. Loved this little hidden gem. If you’re close by definitely go try it out!! Service was great as well.
… moreJanet Buol
Our second visit. We’ve had Aidan as our server both times. There are not enough good things to say about Aidan, the food, and the atmosphere. I didn’t take pictures like always because the food is so good, I dove right in. They bring some garlic knots out with your drinks. Dare you to try and save them for dinner. Someone’s grandma made those meatballs, I’m sure. And the marinara sauce is divine. Love the baked meat raviolis too. Everything we’ve ordered there has been a solid 14 our of 10. Just so darn good. Aidan, we’ll be back and hope you are the server again. You make the trip special. Thank you all!!!
… moreMelissa Soden
Oh myyy this place is amazing. All type of pizzas thick, thin, hand tossed and made to order. Lasagna was amazing. Service was great. They have a buffet for $15 and let me tell y’all it was so worth it. I got all kinds of different salads.
… moregregg pap
Well, it was a beautiful Sunday and we were planning on going. outhere to eat, was looking forward to it the last few days .as I saw that they had a nice salad bar buffet and a pizza buffet we got there early as to beat the crowd after church. We were sat down right away, and we hit the salad bar first as the pizza had not come out yet, was very impressed with the salad bar and the other hot foods and the pizzas when they came out.
We did not have to ask to have our water. refilled, once every five minutes or so, somebody was coming by taking an empty plate and refilling. our water, asking us if we enjoyed the food, I told them yes, i can only imagine how good there meals are, they are the same owners as o sole mio in jonesville. Look forward to coming back and trying it again. Maybe for dinner next time, the buffet only runs from 11-3pm every day. It’s not a bad drive from gainesville, and it’s so worth it!!! One of my top 3’s now!!
… moreWe did not have to ask to have our water. refilled, once every five minutes or so, somebody was coming by taking an empty plate and refilling. our water, asking us if we enjoyed the food, I told them yes, i can only imagine how good there meals are, they are the same owners as o sole mio in jonesville. Look forward to coming back and trying it again. Maybe for dinner next time, the buffet only runs from 11-3pm every day. It’s not a bad drive from gainesville, and it’s so worth it!!! One of my top 3’s now!!
Verna Saxon
This was our first time but not our last! The service here is top-notch!! Even when our waiter was waiting on other tables there were other servers checking our drinks and filling them for us. They even removed plates we were finished with. When it comes to top-notch Aiden our waiter gets the “prize”! Some things food wise we had questions about and he gave good answers! Even laughing with us when we made comments about being “such hard to get along with eaters”( our male friend with us 3 ladies). We loved the way he announced exactly what each one of us was getting served and “hope you enjoy it”! Not once but for each one of us!! I’m telling you IF I still managed convenience stores I would be trying to steal him away! Hopefully you have some way of showing him appreciation because he deserves to be applauded!! It was a great experience overall because of the atmosphere! Just the soft sounds of people enjoying being there and no loud tvs playing!! As I said at the beginning of this review we’re planning on coming back and bringing other friends with us!
… moreMatt B
Hands down the best and most authentic Italian food in North Florida.
An absolute hidden gem. Great customer service from waitstaff and the owner that greets customers table side making you feel welcomed and relaxed. An authentic family style Italian restaurant serving up great Sicilian classics.
We enjoyed the Clams appetizer, Veal Marsala, Chicken Gorgonzola, Fried Calamari, Seafood Bisque and the fresh baked hot rolls.
We can’t wait to go back to try more of the authentic Italian dishes.
… moreAn absolute hidden gem. Great customer service from waitstaff and the owner that greets customers table side making you feel welcomed and relaxed. An authentic family style Italian restaurant serving up great Sicilian classics.
We enjoyed the Clams appetizer, Veal Marsala, Chicken Gorgonzola, Fried Calamari, Seafood Bisque and the fresh baked hot rolls.
We can’t wait to go back to try more of the authentic Italian dishes.
Michael McDaniel
New York Pizza Plus absolutely nailed it. We went all-in on the Meat Lovers pizza, and good grief—these folks do not play around. Every bite was loaded, perfectly seasoned, and cooked exactly the way a proper pizza should be. No sad toppings, no soggy crust, no “well… it’s fine I guess” moments. Just legit, crave-worthy pizza done right.
The place has that classic New York style swagger without trying too hard. Fast, friendly, and the pizza shows up looking like it walked straight off a food commercial—except it actually tastes even better. We love everything about New York Pizza Plus. If you’re on the fence, quit reading reviews and just order. You’ll thank yourself halfway through the first slice.
… moreThe place has that classic New York style swagger without trying too hard. Fast, friendly, and the pizza shows up looking like it walked straight off a food commercial—except it actually tastes even better. We love everything about New York Pizza Plus. If you’re on the fence, quit reading reviews and just order. You’ll thank yourself halfway through the first slice.