Social Profile: 
… View more
If you like ice cream – you’ll absolutely love Siesta Key’s favorite Gelato! Made In Rome Organic Gelato takes organic milk, cream, sugar, fruits and nuts and combines them using traditional Italian gelato in small batches to create a unique product of unparalleled quality.
Small, casual counter-serve stop scooping handcrafted Italian gelato with creative toppings.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5204 Ocean Blvd, Siesta Key, FL 34242
Phone: (941) 867-7444
Website: http://www.madeinromegelato.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Siesta Key Gelato | Organic Ice Cream Made In Rome FL
Made In Rome Organic Gelato takes organic milk, cream, eggs, sugar, fruits and nuts and combines them using traditional Italian gelato in small batches.
Siesta Key Gelato Our Menu – Made In Rome
Organic Gelato · Croccante All’Amarena (Crunchy Cherry) · Vanilia Brownies (Vanilla Brownies) · Biscotto (Cookies and Cream) · Stracciatella (Vanilla and Chocolate …
Made In Rome Organic Gelato | Siesta Key FL – Facebook
Made In Rome Organic Gelato, Siesta Key. 1065 likes · 1846 were here. Family owned Made in Rome Organic Gelateria serves 100% organic gelato. Located…
Product
Reviews
Kunwei Lin
If you’re looking for an unforgettable gelato experience in Florida, this place is an absolute gem. Every scoop is made with organic ingredients, and you can truly taste the difference — rich, fresh, and bursting with real flavor. Their variety is incredible, from classic Italian staples to creative seasonal specials, so there’s always something new to fall in love with.
The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, and the staff couldn’t be friendlier. They’re always happy to offer recommendations and let you sample flavors until you find the perfect one. One scoop here and you’re instantly transported straight to Italy — it’s that authentic.
Highly recommend stopping by if you’re in the area. This is gelato done right!
… moreThe atmosphere is warm and welcoming, and the staff couldn’t be friendlier. They’re always happy to offer recommendations and let you sample flavors until you find the perfect one. One scoop here and you’re instantly transported straight to Italy — it’s that authentic.
Highly recommend stopping by if you’re in the area. This is gelato done right!
Ingolf Nitsch
What happened at Made in Rome?! For eight years I’ve rated the gelato at Made in Rome a 12 out of 10. The flavor and texture rivaled any gelato both domestically and internationally!
We were so disappointed with the gelato we had during our recent visit. We already knew the business had been sold, but we hoped the new owners would continue serving the same quality of product. Not even close.
The rich dense creamy mouthfeel was replaced with a product having a much coarser texture, and the intense natural hazelnut flavor in my hazelnut gelato was a shadow of what it used to be.
If the last mouthful tastes as good as the first, it’s an indicator of a great natural project. But if a “flavoring type” aftertaste shows up halfway through, it’s nowhere near the same enjoyment level or quality of product.
If you are going to buy a business that is known for outstanding product and you keep the original name, you should keep the product the same. Otherwise, change the name, so that there are no preconceived expectations. It’s only a 7 out 10 now, just like the gelateria in Venice and most others. A sad day for all of the past patrons of Made In Rome who enjoy amazing gelato!
… moreWe were so disappointed with the gelato we had during our recent visit. We already knew the business had been sold, but we hoped the new owners would continue serving the same quality of product. Not even close.
The rich dense creamy mouthfeel was replaced with a product having a much coarser texture, and the intense natural hazelnut flavor in my hazelnut gelato was a shadow of what it used to be.
If the last mouthful tastes as good as the first, it’s an indicator of a great natural project. But if a “flavoring type” aftertaste shows up halfway through, it’s nowhere near the same enjoyment level or quality of product.
If you are going to buy a business that is known for outstanding product and you keep the original name, you should keep the product the same. Otherwise, change the name, so that there are no preconceived expectations. It’s only a 7 out 10 now, just like the gelateria in Venice and most others. A sad day for all of the past patrons of Made In Rome who enjoy amazing gelato!
mia granados
AMAZING best gelato I have ever had the texture and taste is spot on and really tastes homemade I had the tiramisu and the almond cookie amaretto flavor will be back.
… moreMarylyn Neumann
Best organic Gelato in town. The owner is very sweet and hard working person. She welcome us with such a smile and we had a chance to try few flavors. The crew is amazing too. Great costumer service but mostly the quality of product is amazing. I really recommend it
… moreEdwin McGee
The gelato is outstanding! Others in our party had tried gelato in Italy and confirmed the authenticity! Several flavors to choose from and you can freely sample up to two flavors.
… moreMayi Barov
Delicious Italian gelato! The staff was incredibly friendly! we were warmly greeted by a charming Italian gentleman who enthusiastically explained the ingredients and flavors. The gelato did not disappoint, and they even offer sugar-free options! The ambiance is also super nice, I’ll definitely be back.
… moreMarisa Dragani
silky & smooth gelato! so tasty, they have diverse flavors & it’s a welcoming environment! my personal favorites are the pistachio & chocolate brownie. they offer 2 samples per customer which is generous in my opinion, considering they make it from scratch! 10/10 recommend if you’re in the siesta key area!
… moreYerddy Lanfranco
Best Gelato in Siesta Key. Let me start by saying that this is by far, and I mean it, the best gelato in all of the Florida area. I tried the Dulce de leche gelato and the pistachio, and I have to say that it melted in my mouth like butter. Wow. Such a tasty gelato, all made with natural ingredients from Italy itself. You can tell that the products are of the highest quality. I know there are other ice cream places around, but I can guarantee, that NONE are like this one. Worth every penny and worth the drive. I went straight there and don’t regret the amazing experience. I highly recommend.
… moreGina
This place is amazing! All natural, no food coloring and they have yummy vegan gelato!! Organic no less… this should become a chain! They are so helpful and the owner is amazing! She was making suggestions for my picky son. I love the fact that they use natural food to color the ice cream! If only all restaurants cared as much as I do about what goes into our body! Granted there is sugar but as a treat, this place is so good! We just move about 35 minutes from here and will be regulars! Thank you for serving quality food!
… moreHeather Gunnerson
Loved it! Authentic flavors with adorable atmosphere. Great gelato with amazing customer service. We really appreciate them! Small inside, so be prepared to sit outside on the covered patio.
… more