Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Looking for the best pizza restaurant and salad shop in Key West, FL? You’ve found it! Clemente’s Wood-Fired Trolley Pizzeria is the best Italian restaurant where you can get real, wood-fired pizza done right. Our restaurant has a relaxing atmosphere where you can enjoy hand-tossed pizza with friends and family. Our friendly staff will make sure that you have an amazing time and the best Italian food in your life. Our dishes get made with fresh and healthy ingredients. Whether you’re looking for lunch or dinner, at Clemente’s Wood-Fired Trolley Pizzeria you are guaranteed to have an unforgettable meal. For reservations or more information, give us a call today!
Classic & creative pizzas are served along with pasta & homestyle mains at this old-school venue.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Clemente’s Trolley Pizzeria | Key West FL – Facebook
Clemente’s Trolley Pizzeria ; . 516 Fleming St, Key West, FL, United States, 33040 ; . Key West, FL ; Contact info. . clementestrolleypizzeria.kw. . (305) 900- …
Order Clemente’s Trolley Pizzeria – Key West, FL Menu … – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Clemente’s Trolley Pizzeria at 516 Fleming Street in Key West. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your …
Clementes Trolley Pizzeria – New 516 Fleming Street – Coke
Come in and enjoy! Location. 516 Fleming Street, Key west, FL 33040. Directions. Similar restaurants in your area. scroll left scroll right. Duetto Pizza and …
Reviews
Local Guide Tests
Absolutely incredible pizza! I had the pepperoni pizza and it was pure perfection — honestly one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Paired with several ice-cold root beers, it was a dream combo.
The service was super friendly and impressively fast. Even though the place was lively and full of energy, we barely had to wait for a table, and the pizza came out in no time.
The pizza was MASSIVE — easily big enough to share — but it tasted so insanely good that I couldn’t stop eating. We took the leftovers with us, reheated them later, and they still tasted absolutely amazing.
Everything about this place was spot on. An absolute must-visit, and we will 100% be coming back!
… moreThe service was super friendly and impressively fast. Even though the place was lively and full of energy, we barely had to wait for a table, and the pizza came out in no time.
The pizza was MASSIVE — easily big enough to share — but it tasted so insanely good that I couldn’t stop eating. We took the leftovers with us, reheated them later, and they still tasted absolutely amazing.
Everything about this place was spot on. An absolute must-visit, and we will 100% be coming back!
Ross Lewis
This felt like a family run Italian restaurant. The caeser salad and caprese were great. We did the 12 in thin crust pizza. It a nice crispy crust and really good flavor. With the 2 salads it was enough pizza for 2 of us. We saw a different table had gotten a spaghetti and meat ball dish, and it looked very good. If you’re looking for some good Italian food and pizza, this is a great spot. Really fun little key lime cannoli for dessert!
There are a few small tables out front along the sidewalk, and the dining room has about 12 tables.
… moreThere are a few small tables out front along the sidewalk, and the dining room has about 12 tables.
Jen Zeigler
Doesn’t live up to prior recommendations. Service extremely slow, spicy chunky sauce, not enough cheese, not what I’m used to. I like New York style pizza. Doesn’t compare. Wouldn’t return. Cannolis are good.
… moreBrent Johnson
Lovely wood fired pizza place. Got the Margherita pizza. Perfectly crispy crust and proportion of sauce to cheese. Server had a rough night due to some awful patrons (my observation), but was still very attentive and kind to us.
4.7/5
… more4.7/5
Jose Colon
Cozy eatery with indoor and sidewalk seating. Inviting ambiance, comfortable seating, excellent oven cooked pizza. Perfect portioning. Lucy was fantastic!
Will definitely return next visit to KW.
… moreWill definitely return next visit to KW.
Mike Metcalf
I was looking for the best pizza in key West based on reviews and this place did not disappoint!! Service was fast and friendly. Pizza was fantastic. Their pizza sauce must have had some sort of olive oilgarlic blend to it that made it unique to anything I’ve ever had before. It was a light crust and the pepperoni had a great taste without being too spicy. I would 100% go back!
… moreGina Duck
Perspective from a visitor from Tennessee. We used Doordash. BIG MISTAKE. Delivery was slow and late. Pizza arrived Cold and crust hard. Flavor of pizza good. I am wondering if we had of got takeout or eaten there it would be different. Large pizza was small. 86 dollars for 2 pizza 1 cannoli a little pricey. Would not recommend and will never uses door dash here again
… moreLawrence Miller
This is an excellent pizzeria. Their wood-fired oven produces some of the best pizza crust that I have ever had. Nicely charred yest nicely chewy. We had the meatball pizza. The meat was excellent. The place is small but has a nice vibe.
… moreR. Matt LeMaster
We were looking for something less “tourist” and more authentic for our anniversary dinner in the keys. We had walked past the place a few times and it really called to me. While looking for a good steakhouse that didn’t drench everything in rich cream or something, my wife suggested pizza. I mentioned seeing Clemente’s on our walks.
First, service is amazing. We walked in and were greeted immediately by the friendliest people. Since we were staying in a small hotel room, we didn’t want to get a giant meal so my wife and I split the house salad which was far more impressive than a house salad could be imagined. It was fresh and had ample ingredients to showcase the flavors of the mild but perfectly seasoned dressing. We also ordered the Hot peppers and Soppressata pizza. Which was, hands down, the best meal I’ve had in the keys. This is the best pizza I’ve had in a very long time. It may be the best pizza I’ve had in my life and I’m a bit sorry to say that because my lifelong favorite (Giovanni’s Pizza in eastern Kentucky) may have just been beaten.
Plenty of locals clearly know this spot. They’d pop in and chat with the proprietors as if they have for decades. No touristy lines of people. Just true, authentic, local perfection in this place. I cannot say enough great things. Excellent food, perfect service, my most memorable meal in Key West. Highly recommended!
… moreFirst, service is amazing. We walked in and were greeted immediately by the friendliest people. Since we were staying in a small hotel room, we didn’t want to get a giant meal so my wife and I split the house salad which was far more impressive than a house salad could be imagined. It was fresh and had ample ingredients to showcase the flavors of the mild but perfectly seasoned dressing. We also ordered the Hot peppers and Soppressata pizza. Which was, hands down, the best meal I’ve had in the keys. This is the best pizza I’ve had in a very long time. It may be the best pizza I’ve had in my life and I’m a bit sorry to say that because my lifelong favorite (Giovanni’s Pizza in eastern Kentucky) may have just been beaten.
Plenty of locals clearly know this spot. They’d pop in and chat with the proprietors as if they have for decades. No touristy lines of people. Just true, authentic, local perfection in this place. I cannot say enough great things. Excellent food, perfect service, my most memorable meal in Key West. Highly recommended!
Adrian Guevara
We recently visited Clemente’s in Key West and overall, I’d give it about 3 out of 5 stars. The food was pretty underwhelming; we tried two pies and the meatballs, and unfortunately, they lacked flavor and weren’t cooked evenly. The pasta, especially the Alfredo sauce, was bland and needed seasoning. The service was a bit lacking as well, not very welcoming or attentive. Overall, if you have other options, you might want to consider them, but if you just need a quick bite, it’s okay.
… more