Red Faux
I’ve been coming here a few years now. Most visits are A+. Pauley’s is def the best pizza in town. I’ve had a few not so good experiences here but today, 12-29-25, Mon 2:15, it was incredible again. Perfect! Very reasonable prices. Quality ingredients.
… moreCarl Muhm
always good to try a new place when traveling or some form of celebration.
lunch time was busy while inside to place the order the acoustics was loud making it hard to hear.
was disappointed with inside seating as many tables taken up with one person made it hard to have a table inside for 6 people as the weather was on the hot side. we ended up outside in the heat.
the pizzas tasted very good. please stop by and give this place a thumbs up.
… morePatty Kraft
Wow never ate here before but will again. Great price and awesome food and the staff is amazing
… moreAlciel Beleren
Nice little pizzeria location with great food and a wide selection of options, something for just about everyone
… moreRay Irons
I got the Italian trio sub. I was born and raised outside Philly and my first job was in a deli making subs. These are pretty close. Some sandwich shops pocket the bread, others cut in half. Pauly’s is in the latter group. Personally, I prefer pocket cut. While my sandwiche was very tasty, I felt it could have benefited from a little more veggies.
… moreTaylor Miller
This place was wonderful. My husband and I got two 8 inch pizzas and they were so delicious, as well as reasonably priced. Highly recommend! We will most definitely be back!
… moreMichele Dunham
First of all, I ordered a French Dip sandwich from Pauly’s Pizzeria & Sub Co & it was the best one I have ever had! The meat just melts in your mouth & the bread & dipping sauce were fantastic. So delicious! We have also ordered pizza from them & it is phenomenal. Excellent place to eat. Highly recommend!!
… moreZac Clevenger
Awesome service and food. Wish the overall restaurant was a bit bigger but it’s still a great place to eat. We come here often for lunch and get pizzas to go for dinner some nights as well. Always a great place for a meal.
… moreCourtney Russell
Best pizza in Rapid City!!
It has an amazing flavor, and I love the texture of the corn mill on the crust, gives it extra crispiness and crunch. The pepperoni are small, which I feel like make some better. Somehow I always love the tiny pepperonis. Definitely recommend if you’re looking for some pizza. But they are NOT open on the weekends. So be sure to get your pizza fix taken care of during the week.
… moreShelbonzo
This pizza was out of this world. Everyone was friendly and the pizza was made quick and perfectly, even with me making changes. The attention to detail, kind customer service, and FANTASTIC pizza makes this a must.
… more