Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Homestyle Italian cooking, from pasta to pizza & Parmigiana, in a relaxed, family-friendly space.
Hours
| Friday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1425 Tuskawilla Rd, Winter Springs, FL 32708
Phone: (407) 659-0101
Website: http://www.stefanos-trattoria.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
STEFANOS TRATTORIA
An Italian restaurant serving homestyle comfort food. Here at Stefano’s Trattoria we offer Time, Quality, and Passion, the best ingredients for an exquisite …
Stefano’s Trattoria | Winter Springs FL – Facebook
Stefano’s Trattoria, Winter Springs. 7460 likes · 27 talking about this · 16804 were here. Operating Hours:Monday-Saturday 11:30am-9:00pm.
Stefano’s Trattoria – Scott Joseph Orlando Restaurant Guide
I’ll admit to having some trepidation about a Stefano’s Trattoria without Stefano. The LaCommares sold the popular Winter Springs restaurant …
Reviews
Nikeisha
We celebrated a friend’s birthday here. However, this was not our first time at this restaurant. I came here before when I was dating. We met friends for dinner. Now, the person I was dating is my husband. We met the same friends and celebrated a birthday. This was more than a casual night out. It was special to come back now as a married couple with our same family friends, continuing life together.
… moreJaideepak P
One of the best restaurants for ambience (not even considering the live piano music), service, attention, quality and taste of food.
Few places where the waiters have your best interests at heart and recommend i don’t order more food as I might not br able to finish them. But everything was so good I wanted to have more, if only, I had more space in my tummy
… moreFew places where the waiters have your best interests at heart and recommend i don’t order more food as I might not br able to finish them. But everything was so good I wanted to have more, if only, I had more space in my tummy
Fairooz Haque
My husband brought me here for a surprise birthday dinner and it was truly a wonderful experience. The food was incredible and everything we ordered was made to perfection. Our waitress was kind enough to help my friend and I pick a wine from the extensive selection. The menu is overwhelming (in a good way) with the amount of options so we got many items to share amongst ourselves. Everything we ordered was delicious. The live piano music also created a great atmosphere. The decorations on the inside were classic and timeless. We definitely plan to return.
… moreTheLiveforsurf
Alejandro continues to run a top notch business establishment and restaurant even when he is not on premises! Special shoutout to Jake tonight for getting my favorite salad in Orlando not only right but also such personable service above and beyond! This is the Antipasto Salad with like 18 ingredients or something lol l like blue cheese for the raw veggies and their house Italian for the rest. Thank you again for an amazing and delicious job even at closing!
… moreDean4IU
Stefano’s Trattoria: unforgettable stuffed mushrooms, authentic lasagna, and piano music that transports you back to Italy.
First Impressions
A strip mall authentic Italian restaurant. Is it possible? We’re new to town and dont know all the popular local go-to restaurants. We stopped into the ‘Play it Again Sports’ next door and thought, what the heck, lets do it. So we walked in, and immediately Stefano’s Trattoria set the tone for an unforgettable evening. The owner himself greeted us warmly at the door, even sending over a complimentary caprese salad as a gesture of appreciation for being first-time guests. That kind of hospitality is rare and immediately made us feel at home.
Service Excellence
The highlight of the night was undoubtedly Ben, the bartender. Personable, knowledgeable, and genuinely passionate about the restaurant, he walked us through the menu and even shared stories from his tenure at Stefano’s. His enthusiasm for the food was contagious—a true testament to the quality and consistency of the restaurant.
Starters
– Caprese Salad – not very visually appealing but fresh and flavorful.
– Pasta e Fagioli – hearty and comforting, a classic done with lentils and a bit different than your probably used to from the local Olive Garden.
– Garden Salad – basic house salad, crisp, fresh, with chunky tomatoes and cucumbers. The house vinaigrette was such a tangy concoction of perfection.
– Stuffed Mushrooms – the showstopper of the starters. Risotto and bacon stuffed inside mushrooms, topped with melted mozzarella. A creative twist that was rich, savory, and unforgettable. I’ll be ordering these every visit.
Main Course
Naturally, I had to try the lasagna. The marinara sauce was the star—robust, flavorful, and authentically Italian. The lasagna itself leaned toward a softer, more blended style, almost soup-like in texture. While my wife prefers a denser version, I found this preparation unique and delicious. Regardless of style, the flavors were spot-on and showcased the chef’s mastery.
Atmosphere
Stefano’s isn’t just about food—it’s about experience. The calm, family-like atmosphere was elevated by the pianist, whose music transported us straight to Italy. Whether Bologna’s rich food scene or Naples’ pizza culture, the melodies created a sense of place that made the evening magical.
Final Thoughts
Stefano’s Trattoria is the rare “hole-in-the-wall” that lives up to the myth. Exceptional food, heartfelt service, and a warm, inviting atmosphere combine to make this restaurant a gem worth revisiting. From Ben’s hospitality to the unforgettable stuffed mushrooms and the pianist’s enchanting performance, Stefano’s delivers on every front.
Don’t miss out—this is Italian dining at its finest!
… moreFirst Impressions
A strip mall authentic Italian restaurant. Is it possible? We’re new to town and dont know all the popular local go-to restaurants. We stopped into the ‘Play it Again Sports’ next door and thought, what the heck, lets do it. So we walked in, and immediately Stefano’s Trattoria set the tone for an unforgettable evening. The owner himself greeted us warmly at the door, even sending over a complimentary caprese salad as a gesture of appreciation for being first-time guests. That kind of hospitality is rare and immediately made us feel at home.
Service Excellence
The highlight of the night was undoubtedly Ben, the bartender. Personable, knowledgeable, and genuinely passionate about the restaurant, he walked us through the menu and even shared stories from his tenure at Stefano’s. His enthusiasm for the food was contagious—a true testament to the quality and consistency of the restaurant.
Starters
– Caprese Salad – not very visually appealing but fresh and flavorful.
– Pasta e Fagioli – hearty and comforting, a classic done with lentils and a bit different than your probably used to from the local Olive Garden.
– Garden Salad – basic house salad, crisp, fresh, with chunky tomatoes and cucumbers. The house vinaigrette was such a tangy concoction of perfection.
– Stuffed Mushrooms – the showstopper of the starters. Risotto and bacon stuffed inside mushrooms, topped with melted mozzarella. A creative twist that was rich, savory, and unforgettable. I’ll be ordering these every visit.
Main Course
Naturally, I had to try the lasagna. The marinara sauce was the star—robust, flavorful, and authentically Italian. The lasagna itself leaned toward a softer, more blended style, almost soup-like in texture. While my wife prefers a denser version, I found this preparation unique and delicious. Regardless of style, the flavors were spot-on and showcased the chef’s mastery.
Atmosphere
Stefano’s isn’t just about food—it’s about experience. The calm, family-like atmosphere was elevated by the pianist, whose music transported us straight to Italy. Whether Bologna’s rich food scene or Naples’ pizza culture, the melodies created a sense of place that made the evening magical.
Final Thoughts
Stefano’s Trattoria is the rare “hole-in-the-wall” that lives up to the myth. Exceptional food, heartfelt service, and a warm, inviting atmosphere combine to make this restaurant a gem worth revisiting. From Ben’s hospitality to the unforgettable stuffed mushrooms and the pianist’s enchanting performance, Stefano’s delivers on every front.
Don’t miss out—this is Italian dining at its finest!
jade a
My friend and I came here for the first time and it was absolutely amazing. Our waitress, Hannah, provided the best service ever. The atmosphere inside was incredibly perfect. The lights were perfectly dim and the music was gentle and not overwhelming in any way. The food was amazing. I recommend ordered the penne alla vodka! It was so delish. Also their tiramisu is everything.
… moreLeann Parkinson
what an absolutely glorious find! We love Italian food and we’re always looking for a new restaurant that we haven’t been to, and we happen to fall upon Stefanos Trattoria. Everything from the romantic atmosphere to the friendly staff to the over the moon food is outstanding! Noah was our waiter and he was awesome. Make sure you ask for him. If you go you won’t be disappointed. Can hardly wait to go back!!
… moreJoAnn Straub
Went dinner and the wait was like 10 minutes, food was very very good, I had Gamberi Portofino,husband had zuppa di Mare. Large portions. The only issue, your salad is not included with dinner, but overall was very very good. Atmosphere was nice, with soft lights and a gentleman playing piano and singing. Sounded great.
Overall enjoyed dinner !
… moreOverall enjoyed dinner !
Sara Ann
We came here as a group of about 15 and oh my goodness! The owner was so sweet and accommodating and showered us with love and made sure we felt appreciated!
I personally had the sampler with different pastas and the dulce de Leche cheesecake and yum!! So good!
The service was wonderful and it was such a homey feel dining here. The waitresses were attentative and sweet and from the feedback everyone enjoyed their food as well!
… moreI personally had the sampler with different pastas and the dulce de Leche cheesecake and yum!! So good!
The service was wonderful and it was such a homey feel dining here. The waitresses were attentative and sweet and from the feedback everyone enjoyed their food as well!
sjcyankee
Trust me, you will not go wrong, if you dine, here.
Just fabulous, all the way around.
… moreJust fabulous, all the way around.