Social Profile: 
… View more
Branch of a local bar chain serving American comfort food & signature battered fish ’n’ chips.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 24 N State St 26 # 26, Westerville, OH 43081
Phone: (614) 794-6900
Website: http://www.oldbagofnails.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Westerville, OH – Old Bag of Nails
get craic in columbus’s largest suburb. 24 North State Street # 26, Westerville, OH 43081. PHONE. (614) 794-6900. HOURS. MON – THURS 11AM — 9PM.
Old Bag of Nails
We have nearly twenty restaurants across Ohio and Michigan, serving up the best fish & chips and pub fare in your town.
Old Bag of Nails – Westerville, OH on OpenTable
Old Bag of Nails is a bustling pub that serves up contemporary comfort grub and drinks in a relaxed space.
Reviews
Daniel Vergara
Their Seasonal Menu is PERFECTION but that Country Fried Chicken with gravy and butter corn is a masterpiece! I’ve lived in The South and this is probably the best Country Fried Chicken I’ve ever had. I’ll be coming back for the lobster roll & Open Faced Meatloaf Sandwich! Our Server was super sweet and knew her stuff! Great place to eat when you wanna come with the family. Thank you guys! Really warmed by heart and tummy!
… moreT Y
We like to visit this restaurant whenever we are in town. It’s conveniently located with easy parking. The restaurant is clean, service is always good, and they have good food that is reasonably priced.
We live in Florida, so we don’t get their seafood but we hear it is very tasty. The French onion soup and buffalo wings hit the spot on the cold night we were there.
We will be back the next time we are on town.
… moreWe live in Florida, so we don’t get their seafood but we hear it is very tasty. The French onion soup and buffalo wings hit the spot on the cold night we were there.
We will be back the next time we are on town.
Chelsea Starkey
The food was pitiful, $28 for a spoonful of lobster on the lobster rolls and Kraft Mac and cheese which is what I believe children should eat At Applebees. Not as a side with a $28 lobster roll. The bartender I was also not very pleasant and no one in the restaurant tried to assist me in getting my Togo order except for a waitress that appeared to be off the clock and having a drink at the bar, I appreciated her acknowledging me. The fish tacos said they came with sour cream which I also did not receive.
… moreSavannah Bartholomew
Everything was really good! We had the espresso martini, though we were told it didn’t have the orange in it, it totally did. Tasted more like a mix. Disappointed with that but it was really pretty! Fried pot stickers for an appetizer, would highly recommend!! Wings & fries were absolutely delicious! Overall was a great place!
… moreJoe Riffe
Great if you like:
1. Sifting through layers of plain tortilla chips to find a few shreds of unmelted cheese before you’re halfway through the plate
2. Onions ring batter as pale and uncooked as the mushy onions inside
3. A single small ramekin of ketchup to camouflage the grease while you debate whether it’s worth trying to flag down the bartender for another
4. An Old Fashioned that competes with a Shirley temple for nauseating sweetness
The bartender wasn’t hostile, though
… more1. Sifting through layers of plain tortilla chips to find a few shreds of unmelted cheese before you’re halfway through the plate
2. Onions ring batter as pale and uncooked as the mushy onions inside
3. A single small ramekin of ketchup to camouflage the grease while you debate whether it’s worth trying to flag down the bartender for another
4. An Old Fashioned that competes with a Shirley temple for nauseating sweetness
The bartender wasn’t hostile, though
Noah Yinger
Great per usual. We were surprised because it is usually packed but given it was a Thursday, tonight was nice. Got right in and seated. We enjoyed the potato skins and I had the lobster rolls for an entree (paired with a Guinness obviously). Friendly staff and great service
… moreTrisha Mennifield
The worst experience ever. It was around 2pm on Sunday February 22, 2026 when we went to the Westerville location, the restaurant was pretty much empty unless you were at the bar which is why I was so confused to why we barely got checked on. The waitress maybe checked on us once or twice. She didn’t listen at all, she got my drink wrong, my boyfriend got Modelo and I asked for a double shot of Henny with a coke on the side, which i thought meant a drink separated from the coke. She brought it to me mixed together. I didn’t say anything I let it go.Our chicken nachos were extremely dry, chicken was super dry, I had to ask for sour cream which I thought came with nachos but I guess not. My philly cheese steak was dry no sauce on it at all. I had to ask for some mayonnaise which by then my food was so cold when I seen her to ask for it since she was in the back talking with her coworkers not checking on us at all. While trying to enjoy our drinks she brought us the bill when we didn’t ask for it and wasn’t done ordering, but since she brought the bill that helped us be done. When my boyfriend paid for our meal he handed her his card, she put it in the machine made the transaction and tossed the card on the table which was extremely rude seeing how he handed it to her and she didn’t return the same treatment. I asked her if she could hand him his card back and she acted like she didn’t hear me and he just grabbed it off the table and said it was ok. We are much older than her and I would’ve thought she would’ve had better respect for her elders but she didn’t care at all and walked away. Which is the only thing she was good at, walking away from us to do nothing seeing how it wasn’t much going on around that time. We will not be going back ever. $100 wasted.
… moreCourtney Jarrett
Just walked out. We were seated at once as it wasn’t busy. Had time to look at the menu and see other people being sat. After waiting about 10 minutes with no service, a couple was seated behind us and they were immediately greated, given water, and had their order taken. When we walked out we told the hostess that no one ever came to the table. She smiled and said “have a good night” as we walked out the door. This is very disappointing as we’ve always enjoyed this location.
… moreMelissa S Snyder
The mussels and shrimp are amazing. A repeat dish for me at this restaurant. I don’t eat chocolate, but it had a nice presentation, and it was mentioned it was very good. I like a good Bloody Mary and their’s were on point.
Very nice atmosphere. Went during the week, not crowded.
The service was amazing. Didn’t need to ask for anything.
Totally recommend this place for a nice, casual dining experience.
… moreVery nice atmosphere. Went during the week, not crowded.
The service was amazing. Didn’t need to ask for anything.
Totally recommend this place for a nice, casual dining experience.
Princeton Watts
Im African American and this is a very white place to go to but I didn’t feel uncomfortable being there no one was staring at me everybody minding their own business having fun eating drinking. The food was amazing I tried the Black Salmon and the Boneless wings the black salmon was rushed and not too flavorful but the boneless wings were amazing. 5/5 stars
… more