Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
Hands down, the BEST New York-style pizza I’ve had in a long time!
“Made in New York Pizza” delivers everything you’d want in an authentic NYC slice—crispy, thin crust with that perfect fold, rich and flavorful sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. The dough tastes fresh, the toppings are top quality, and you can tell they take real pride in every pie they make.
The atmosphere has that classic, no-frills NYC pizzeria vibe—quick, friendly service, clean space, and the smell alone is enough to make your mouth water the second you walk in. I grabbed a pepperoni and a white slice, and both were absolutely .
Whether you’re a tourist wanting the real NYC pizza experience or a local looking for your go-to spot, this place is a must-visit. Trust me, one slice won’t be enough. Can’t wait to come back!
As someone who runs a creative agency focused on photography, videography, and marketing, I can say this spot is photogenic and flavorful.
If you’re a restaurant looking to level up your online presence, highlight your menu with mouth-watering visuals, or capture the soul of your brand on video — I’d love to collaborate! DM me or visit my page to see how we can make your food and business stand out in a crowded digital world.… more… View more
Craving authentic New York pizza? We are your go-to destination for the best pizza in town. Our expertly crafted pies are made with the freshest natural ingredients & our dough made with famous NYC water, captures the true essence of New York style pizza. From classic cheese to gourmet toppings, each slice offers a taste of the Big Apple. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, come savor the flavor at one of the top pizza places around. Experience the bustling ambiance and friendly service that make us a fan favorite. Join us and discover why our customers say we serve the best pizza in the Upper West Side!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 421 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
Phone: (646) 484-6200
Website: https://www.madeinnewyorkpizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Made in New York Pizza
Made in New York Pizza is built on a foundation of fresh, natural ingredients, high-quality cheeses, and that legendary NYC water that gives our dough its …
Made In New York Pizza – Facebook
Made In New York Pizza · Classic Margherita · New Margherita · Vodka · Street Fair · Pepperoni · Yo Paulie · Chicken Bacon Ranch.
Made In New York Pizza – 271 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023
Order online at one of the best restaurants in New York, NY! Made In New York Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …
Last Updates
Reviews
Diego Sanz Martínez
We stopped by for some pizza slices one night as we were arriving back at the hotel, and it turned out to be a great choice. The staff is bilingual, speaking both English and Spanish, which makes ordering very easy and comfortable.
They offer a wide variety of slices and full pizzas with different flavors, catering to both vegetarians and meat lovers. Most people seem to go for take-away, but they also have a few tables if you prefer to eat there on the spot.
Another big plus is their very wide opening hours. They’re usually open until late at night, after a movie or similar, which makes it a perfect option if you arrive late and feel like having something warm, quick, and satisfying for dinner.
Overall, a solid and reliable spot for classic New York–style pizza. If you’re craving a good slice late at night, Made in New York Pizza is definitely a good option.
… moreThey offer a wide variety of slices and full pizzas with different flavors, catering to both vegetarians and meat lovers. Most people seem to go for take-away, but they also have a few tables if you prefer to eat there on the spot.
Another big plus is their very wide opening hours. They’re usually open until late at night, after a movie or similar, which makes it a perfect option if you arrive late and feel like having something warm, quick, and satisfying for dinner.
Overall, a solid and reliable spot for classic New York–style pizza. If you’re craving a good slice late at night, Made in New York Pizza is definitely a good option.
Aram Lecis
Nice slice, pepperoni and sausage was on point. Lots and lots of options, I didn’t get the square pie with the cupping pepperoni but it looked delish.
Prices are good, place is clean, lots of pizza options in town but can’t go wrong here.
… morePrices are good, place is clean, lots of pizza options in town but can’t go wrong here.
jordano leal
Was excited and eager to come and taste a slice or 2 of NYC style pizza. Lets just say, this exceeded my expectations. I do have to mention, the chicken nugget one isn’t my fave but the veggie one and cheese were definitely good.
… moreYazmin Infante Peña
Had the vodka and Margherita pizzas and they were delicious, I especially loved the crust – thinner but a little chewy and crispy. The outside dining area is a nice bonus. Definitely will be back!
… moreUrban Lyphstyle
Hands down, the BEST New York-style pizza I’ve had in a long time!
“Made in New York Pizza” delivers everything you’d want in an authentic NYC slice—crispy, thin crust with that perfect fold, rich and flavorful sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. The dough tastes fresh, the toppings are top quality, and you can tell they take real pride in every pie they make.
The atmosphere has that classic, no-frills NYC pizzeria vibe—quick, friendly service, clean space, and the smell alone is enough to make your mouth water the second you walk in. I grabbed a pepperoni and a white slice, and both were absolutely .
Whether you’re a tourist wanting the real NYC pizza experience or a local looking for your go-to spot, this place is a must-visit. Trust me, one slice won’t be enough. Can’t wait to come back!
As someone who runs a creative agency focused on photography, videography, and marketing, I can say this spot is photogenic and flavorful.
If you’re a restaurant looking to level up your online presence, highlight your menu with mouth-watering visuals, or capture the soul of your brand on video — I’d love to collaborate! DM me or visit my page to see how we can make your food and business stand out in a crowded digital world.
Rohan Payal
Made In New York Pizza has a great team behind the counter — service is fast, friendly, and exactly what you want from a New York slice shop. The atmosphere is casual and functional, typical of a city pizza spot without much frills. The pizza itself is decent but doesn’t quite live up to the bold promise of the name — good enough for a satisfying slice but not the kind that stops you in your tracks. With a little more attention to the dough and toppings, this place could truly earn its New York badge.
… morevatsal shah
Another hidden gem. Not a tourist trap.
Randomly came here while waiting for the bus. So glad we came to this unassuming place. Somehow we’ll have to make the trip uptown again just for this.
Really amazing slice of buratta and margherita grandma.
… moreRandomly came here while waiting for the bus. So glad we came to this unassuming place. Somehow we’ll have to make the trip uptown again just for this.
Really amazing slice of buratta and margherita grandma.
Chase E
So many great options for pizza slices and they all were very delicious! Staff is kind and very quick and efficient and the outdoor seating on the streets of Manhattan is great for any visitor, this is definitely my recommendation for pizza slices in NYC.
… moreGeorge Koshy
Quick and fast service and yet fresh and as amazing as it can get. The perfect place to experience as the name itself suggests the perfect new York pizza. An amazing variety of things crust and deep dish, veg and non veg options here to pair with a whole bunch of sodas in stock. Loads of internal seating and the outside ones come alive with the weather too!
… moreKevin Tapia
Great Pizza! Small dining space but shouldn’t be too overcrowded.
They offer slices of pizza that are on display for you to choose and they also offer pies if you would like.
My wife and I got a normal cheese pizza slice and a buffalo chicken pizza slice. Both were very tasty and we had no regrets. We also got a bottle of coke.
They offer glass bottles and plastic bottles. They also have beer in the fridge if wanted.
Place has a nice aesthetic and we enjoyed eating in. Can get crowded in there if busy though.
Staff were friendly, not super friendly lol, but I mean it’s a small pizza joint so.
I would definitely recommend going here for a quick meal. Took about 5-10 minutes to have our pizza slices heated in the oven again. Delicious!
… moreThey offer slices of pizza that are on display for you to choose and they also offer pies if you would like.
My wife and I got a normal cheese pizza slice and a buffalo chicken pizza slice. Both were very tasty and we had no regrets. We also got a bottle of coke.
They offer glass bottles and plastic bottles. They also have beer in the fridge if wanted.
Place has a nice aesthetic and we enjoyed eating in. Can get crowded in there if busy though.
Staff were friendly, not super friendly lol, but I mean it’s a small pizza joint so.
I would definitely recommend going here for a quick meal. Took about 5-10 minutes to have our pizza slices heated in the oven again. Delicious!