Jennifer Billings
Love love love!! My go to is the Sicilian chicken bacon ranch or recently there’s been a delicious hot honey pepperoni Sicilian! No matter what flavor you pick, everything is delicious and everybody’s always so friendly!
Edited: 2/20/26
Got a Sicilian CBR and steak and mushrooms! Delicious
… moreChris Dennis
I tried this place on a first date. It was a good meeting place halfway between us. I looked up the reviews, and saw 4.5 stars with over 1100 reviews. We’ll, I was not disappointed one bit. Such a variety of food, and staff was AWESOME! We had Madison, and she was fantastic! We started with the Buffalo chicken potato skins. Weird you say? It was an interesting combination of chicken, buffalo, bacon, cheeses, and potato (and sour cream), and it was so good! Next was the BBQ steak pizza. Again, you may say “What???”, but after tasting it, the combination of steak, BBQ sauce, onions, cheeses etc were insanely tasty! If there was an option for more than 5 stars I would put that instead. It is a little distant from me, but I will definitely be back!
… moreJames Zabik
Best slices around, huge selection of toppings, fast and friendly staff. Just as good as the Amherst location if not better!
… moreMoney bags
This is by far one of the best Antonio’s Pizza joints I have visited! I didn’t get pizza but instead ordered a calzone that was SO good. This location is ideal for dining in, especially if you are with a group of people. Birthday parties and special events are great here! #Pizza #Calzone #Restaurant #Antoniospizza #Food #Party #Dining #Group
… moreMichael Parent
Great staff, Tyler (I believe) is always getting the slices just right in the oven and fast service. Can’t go wrong with the buffalo chicken or honey mustard chicken pizzas either (but they’re all good!). Been going for over 2 decades to the Amherst location, the Belchertown spot is the closest to Amherst out of any of the locations for quality of the ‘zza.
… moreJon Poulin
Best pizza in the area. Lots of great and unique options. The Sicilian style crust is awesome. Wish they could offer it in a smaller option other than a full sheet or whatevers available at the slice counter. They’ve fumbled a few times over the years but they’ve more than made up for it. Great pizza, wings, and for the love of God, get the meatball sliders. Thank me later
… moreStefany T. De
Every time I work near, I get my favorite white cheese slice. Walked in today and someone got the last slice and I was so sad but they made me happy so fast by making my own white cheese pie! It was PERFECT!!! Thank you guys so much! The best!
… moreKrystal Carroll (Kriddle)
This pizza is unmatched! I always do a little dancey dance when my food is great and dancey dance I did!!! The gentleman that waited on me was super sweet and friendly, also very helpful! I will 100% be back! The Sicilian pizza is amazeballs!!!!
… morePaul diBuono
We sat at the bar and ordered a beer each and a pizza. The place was slow to moderately busy. After 40 minutes we still did not have our pizza so we asked the bartender. She was gone for 5 minutes or so. When she returned she had out pizza. It was luke warm at best and clearly had been sitting for sometime. If I wasn’t starving I would have sent it back. Thankfully it was tasty. None the less it will be a while before I go back.
… moreLiam & Gidget (DvnRexMom)
First off, slices are not easily viewed if your not 6 feet tall. They are not labeled. There’s no list of what’s available in slices. This prompted me to buy a whole pie. That’s fine. At least I have leftovers that I can have later and at the correct temperature, as my pie was served cold, not hot!
Service left us with a little something to be desired…she was less than pleased when she heard our answer to HER QUESTION…”how was everything?” Listen, I was just being honest. She said we should’ve told her sooner that the pizza was cold but she did not check in on us once. I’ve eaten here before, alot. This is the worst experience I’ve had here.
… more