Julia Reviews
This is my favorite neighborhood pizza spot. My roommates and I love to grab dinner from here or end our nights out here. The pizza is always crispy and the sauce is very flavorful. I love the thicker crust with has many great options for toppings. My favorites are the eggplant or the spicy pepperoni. The people who work here are very welcoming when we come in and you get your pizza very quickly. Always a great experience.
… moreAmber Davila
The pizza here is delicious and reasonably priced. My go-to is always the Spicy Pepperoni Square Slice. It’s perfectly oily, not too spicy, and the crust is perfectly crispy. A great NYC spot. The staff is always friendly and welcoming. A repeat spot.
… moreQuiteño1969
Small place and great food! I especially liked the sausage thin crust. The sauce was amazing! For a quick bite or whole pie I highly recommemd.
… moreRobin Kendrick
I got a veggie slice (basil and mushrooms) for $5.99. You know that authentic slice that just bends down all thin and saucy and cheesy and ingredientsy? THIS. Two guys working the place were so friendly and inviting. Big smiles, accommodating, awesome. Love it. Had 5 chairs for my 4 friendies and me. Love it!
… moreMATTHEW SODIKOFF
Great pizza, had a slice of cheese. Put in oven and came out piping hot. Had Parmesan cheese and hot peppers. Crust was chewy and crisp but still crunchy. I would get another slice from here. Had many options but went simple. I’d give it an 8.3.
… moreJohn Doe
It was alright. I’m not really used to deep-dish pizza, let alone authentic New York deep dish pizza. I wouldn’t necessarily say that my experience here was bad, but it didn’t “wow” me either. I wish he would’ve cooked the slice of pizza a little bit more, as it came out kind of lukewarm. Oh well, it was only one slice, so it’s not a huge deal.
… moreGraham Pelham
Quick, friendly, easy small place not too busy this pizza slapped better then the New Haven pizza (Apizza) I had in Stamford, CT def worth the trip I took to get here don’t sleep on the square spicy Roni cup pizza
… moreNick Sonderup
Great square slice. Had the vodka and upside down. Sauce is unique and had the right amount of grease. The owner was super nice and friendly. He gave me a free soda too.
… moreThomas Gulbin
Uncle Sam’s Pizza absolutely delivers when it comes to a great slice. The first bite says it all—the crust has that ideal crunch, firm and crisp on the outside while still light enough to let the toppings shine. It’s the kind of crunch that makes you pause for a second, just to appreciate how perfectly it’s done.
The flavor is spot on from start to finish. The sauce is balanced and rich without overpowering, the cheese melts just right, and every component works together in a way that feels classic but elevated. Nothing is overdone, nothing is missing—it’s simply a perfectly executed slice.
… morepooky pk
It’s the most delicious pizza I’ve ever had. The pizza crust is thin and crispy.
… more