4.2 – 1,588 reviews • Pizza restaurant
Family-friendly chain restaurant featuring Italian entrees along with a wide beer selection.
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Old Chicago | Gillette WY – Facebook
Old Chicago, Gillette. 3085 likes · 563 talking about this · 16938 were here. Best pizza in Gillette! Delicious bar + grill menu, craft cocktails &…
Menu – Old Chicago
Taproom Starters · Sicilian Pepperoni Rolls™ · Buffalo Chicken Rolls · Italian Nachos · Bavarian Pretzel Sticks · Cheesy Dippin’ Strips · Twisted Tenders · Spinach …
Last Updates
Reviews
paul simmons
Pizza was good, but the salad was fantastic!!
The top and edges of the pan pizza were absolutely perfect.But the bottom or the underbelly was still a little doughy and oily.
I’ll definitely go back and ask them toleave it in a little bit longer, but like I said that salad was great.
I imagine you make those croutons in-house. They really made the salad.
Look forward to round 2.
I might even try its in crust. Thank you folks very much.
… moreP Michael
We just got into town after a full days drive… about 14 hrs. Needed a good, quick meal before calling it a day. Seating was easy, as we sat in the bar. Same ol same ol, as we’ve visited other Old Chicago restaurants before. Our server, Victoria, has a great attitude. She was very personable and attentive. Our drinks came quick, as did the food. Everything was great. If we ever stop at this location again, we hope ‘Tori’ is our liason. Thanks a bunch!!
… moreBishop Hahn
Was good place to eat and wasn’t bad at all just wish we got our napkins when we asked for first coming in but they were busy and we aren’t holding it over their head about because it still was the best!!
… moreMichael Strike
Place is awesome. I brought 8 of my work crew guys here and we had a blast. Food is delicious. Waitress Victoria was absolutely awesome. She knew how to handle 8 oil rig guys with no problems. Will definitely come back here to watch the football games. Alcoholic beverages are the best. My new favorite place.
… moreBen s
Pizza was spot on, nothing really stands out as a negative. Lots of tvs, decor, and seemed kinda lively when we went. The jalapeño pretzel with the beer cheese was actually really really good. Id get a bunch of those over the pizza they were so good.
… moreLynn Kannier
Sitting at the bar , watching the 2 bartenders Brin and Madison, doing the job of 5 is amazing! The main bartender, Brin, is running the place she is absolutely spot on. Food was fantastic, service was amazing. Great job, Old Chicago!
… moreMckaylee Thomas
I can’t even put my experience into words. Our server was extremely kind and had a good sense of humor, the food was delicious, and the atmosphere was perfect (nice music, lights not too bright, the usual.) I even got a small thing of extra cherries + lemon slices after expressing my love for them! I definitely recommend this place. :]
… moreBrennan Faubion
Our server Kayla absolutely made this experience for us! We had a table of six and she was phenomenal when it came to taking our order and refilling our drinks. She was extremely friendly and kind. I will be asking for her as our server in the future.
… moreJuan from San Juan
Good food, but just not the best. Maybe it’s personal preference, but I just don’t like it that much. Its like high quality airplane food. There’s better pizza and food elsewhere. FANTASTIC atmosphere and plenty of parking. Sometimes service is a little slow, but not terrible.
… moreMacKenna Schabron
We made a team reservation and got seated 20 mins after that time it was made for. We were patient and waited for food for 2h 30 mins. They handed 10 of us our food with a to go box because they forgot about our orders. Then we paid and they charged us an extra 4000$. So we were charged on our card. When the receipt only said the original charge. Then we went back to talk about this issue and it was not resolved. This left many people in tears. What a horrible long awful place. DO NOT GO HERE!
… more … View more