Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–12 AM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1 Genesee St, New Hartford, NY 13413
Phone: (315) 724-3669
Website: https://www.onegenny.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
One Genny | Exceptional Pizza, Pasta & Cocktails in Style
New Hartford NY, 13413. hours. Sun – Tue: 11am – 10pm. Wed & Thu: 11am – 11pm. Fri & Sat: 11am – 12am. social media. Facebook · Instagram · logo fo One Genny.
One Genny (@onegenny) · New Hartford, NY – Instagram
One Genny Pizzeria•Restaurant•Cocktails Catering for Every Occasion Sun–Tuesday 11-10pm. Wednesday-Thursday 11-11pm. Friday – Saturday 11-Midnight.
One Genny – New Hartford, NY Restaurant | Menu + Delivery
Specialty Sandwiches · Ribeye Steak Sandwich · $17.33 · Buffalo Chicken Wrap · $16.00 · Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich · $17.50 · French Dip Sandwich · $19.50 …
Reviews
Smarter Life
**What a turnaround — we’ll definitely be back!**
A few months ago I left a less-than-great review of One Jenny, but after returning last night, I felt it was important to share just how much things have changed — **because this visit was fantastic.**
From the moment we walked in, the vibe was completely different. We were greeted at the door with laughter from the bouncer and awesome 90s tunes from my favorite local band, **Showtime**, setting the tone right away. Service was on point all night. We were seated in our favorite booth — far enough from the live music to comfortably hold a conversation, but still close enough to see, hear, and even dance in our seats (lol).
We started with a small cheese pizza as an appetizer, and it was great — perfectly cooked with that ideal stretchy cheese. For dinner, one of us had the steak, which was cooked to perfection, and I had the bacon beer cheese burger, also cooked exactly right.
On a wicked cold and snowy night, this was the perfect place to escape the weather and enjoy great food and atmosphere. It capped off a fun night after watching the **U.C. Pioneers kick butt in hockey**, and honestly reminded us why we loved this place in the first place.
Huge credit to the staff and management — this was a night-and-day difference, and we’re really glad we gave it another shot.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… moreA few months ago I left a less-than-great review of One Jenny, but after returning last night, I felt it was important to share just how much things have changed — **because this visit was fantastic.**
From the moment we walked in, the vibe was completely different. We were greeted at the door with laughter from the bouncer and awesome 90s tunes from my favorite local band, **Showtime**, setting the tone right away. Service was on point all night. We were seated in our favorite booth — far enough from the live music to comfortably hold a conversation, but still close enough to see, hear, and even dance in our seats (lol).
We started with a small cheese pizza as an appetizer, and it was great — perfectly cooked with that ideal stretchy cheese. For dinner, one of us had the steak, which was cooked to perfection, and I had the bacon beer cheese burger, also cooked exactly right.
On a wicked cold and snowy night, this was the perfect place to escape the weather and enjoy great food and atmosphere. It capped off a fun night after watching the **U.C. Pioneers kick butt in hockey**, and honestly reminded us why we loved this place in the first place.
Huge credit to the staff and management — this was a night-and-day difference, and we’re really glad we gave it another shot.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Megan M
Forgot to take a picture before I started housing this but I got the cheese tortellini with garden vegetables and added grilled chicken to it. It doesn’t look like there’s a sauce but it’s this incredible light delicious garlic sauce and honestly the chicken complements it perfectly. Definitely the best thing I’ve ever gotten here. ❤️
… moreMohsin Syed
Large and lively ambiance with great service. Extensive menu with lots of vegetarian options. Our all time favorite Veg Inbloom Burger!
… moreKyle Wilson
Genuinly impressed with this place! Such a huge menu, yet everything we got was absolutley fantastic. HIGHLY recomend the spinach artichoke dip and the fig and Brie burger! Service was fantastic and there is plenty of seating to accommodate large groups if needed.
My only piece of feedback is that I wish there were half portions or smaller portions. The cost is worth it for what you get but its so so so much food no matter what you order!
… moreMy only piece of feedback is that I wish there were half portions or smaller portions. The cost is worth it for what you get but its so so so much food no matter what you order!
Tricia Pugliese
One Genny catered for my wedding in Oriskany Falls. The owner followed up with us as much as possible and had the best communication from the year before the wedding until the week leading up to the wedding. The bartenders are on top of their game. The bar manager made a drink testing appointment with us and catered to everything that we wanted. They were our least problematic vendor. The food is amazing. Many people told us that this is the best food they’ve ever had at a wedding. They were very organized, professional and friendly. I could not recommend them more.
… moreMary
We had my daughters baby shower upstairs. It’s really a very nice large space. The bathrooms are upstairs. They’re large and clean. Very nice.
It was decorated with beautiful Christmas decorations. The baby shower decor went well with it!
Our hostess Rahea was extremely helpful and beyond efficient. She made the whole process, from buffet service to gift opening and clean up seamless. We all appreciated her so much!
The food was fresh and delicious and hot.
I’d recommend this venue for your event. Felicia was the coordinator. She was very helpful and was responsive to my questions. They are very busy, so call in at least 2 months in advance.
… moreIt was decorated with beautiful Christmas decorations. The baby shower decor went well with it!
Our hostess Rahea was extremely helpful and beyond efficient. She made the whole process, from buffet service to gift opening and clean up seamless. We all appreciated her so much!
The food was fresh and delicious and hot.
I’d recommend this venue for your event. Felicia was the coordinator. She was very helpful and was responsive to my questions. They are very busy, so call in at least 2 months in advance.
Johnny LeHane
Nice atmosphere and great service.
Nachos are huge and solid.
Unfortunately the wings were a miss with the sauce too oily and not sticking to the wings.
Nashville hot chicken was big not dry, and no sauce.
Poutine was ok, but salty.
We will be back and try other options because the menu is huge. Hope to find items that will up our rating.
… moreNachos are huge and solid.
Unfortunately the wings were a miss with the sauce too oily and not sticking to the wings.
Nashville hot chicken was big not dry, and no sauce.
Poutine was ok, but salty.
We will be back and try other options because the menu is huge. Hope to find items that will up our rating.
Mandee F
As someone new to the area, One Genny was recommended by a local, but our first experience was incredibly disappointing.
Our small group ordered pizza, fries, and a calzone, amongst other things. The calzone arrived undercooked and cold inside (still frozen?!) and all the fries were soggy and barely warm. I could do better in my air fryer at home.
One person in our party ordered a non-alcoholic drink, which was incorrectly made with alcohol the first time and then took a long time to remake. When it finally arrived, it tasted terrible and went untouched, yet we were still charged $15 for it. We understand the concept of paying for something we ordered, but $15 for a beverage with NO ALCOHOL? You’ve got to be kidding me.
Overall, both the food and drinks missed the mark for everyone at our table. We won’t be returning.
… moreOur small group ordered pizza, fries, and a calzone, amongst other things. The calzone arrived undercooked and cold inside (still frozen?!) and all the fries were soggy and barely warm. I could do better in my air fryer at home.
One person in our party ordered a non-alcoholic drink, which was incorrectly made with alcohol the first time and then took a long time to remake. When it finally arrived, it tasted terrible and went untouched, yet we were still charged $15 for it. We understand the concept of paying for something we ordered, but $15 for a beverage with NO ALCOHOL? You’ve got to be kidding me.
Overall, both the food and drinks missed the mark for everyone at our table. We won’t be returning.
It’s Me
Guys the food was amazing. I wanted to try the greens but the waiter said they did not serve them without meat. There was an excellent jazz band who engaged well with the audience. The blackberry margarita was a first and again great. The waiter was not the best at all. She was in a hurry, slamming our plates in the table and didn’t return to refill our drinks. The atmosphere and food outweighed the poor service from the waiter. I had the fried haddock as a carry-out a few weeks back and decided to dine in for pasta and wings. I will be returning.
… moreTheresa marie
12/22/23, lowered to 1 star, deserves zero. ordered pickup, small og nachos, the cheese was so overcooked that the nachos were uneatable. Just a solid burnt cheese mess, see pics. Called & spoke to someone claiming to be a manager who advised since order placed online they would credit nachos & call me back once completed. No call back received, this is now 3rd time recently I received unsatisfactory food & was promised a partial credit which is never given!!!. This order was $90. Every order has been close $100. The quality of food here is now just completely unsatisfactory when ordering delivery or pickup. Probably in restaurant possibly better since you can address immediately. Stop lying to customers & credit when unsatisfactory food is given one genny!! SMH in disgust
11/10/23 update delivery via grubhub was prompt.
Ordered Prime rib poutine, this should be served very hot, with cheese & gravy both hot & bubly, cheese curds were hard, cold, not soft, gooey & melted. Prime rib cold & very little this time. fries seemed somewhat warm, not hot. A long black hair was found on top of it, ugh gross & Absolutely ZERO GRAVY ON POUTINE! See pics.
Im basically Paying $16 for fries with dabs of cheese & few bits of prime rib. No gravy anywhere…. no thanks!
One genny are you no longer putting gravy on your poutine? This is like 4th time zero gravy.
Asked for extra gravy on side, what i received was not gravy, it was a solid mass / clump of cold gravy. Why?? Sadly it’s become obvious if I actually want gravy on my poutine I need to be prepared & buy my own.. or maybe start making my own..
Fish fry used to be delicious but last several have been very flat, not meaty & not worth $16, will no longer order fish fry. Upside down pizza is very good, so far just cheese ordered.
Their food can be delicious. But the last 4 times I’ve ordered its been just awful considering how expensive it is. New cook maybe? Or perhaps they just don’t care anymore. It’s a shame they don’t strive to be better or care what they are sending out to people. I’m not sure if I should just give up at this point. Tired of spending hard earned money on food made half fast & without care. Do better One Genny!!!!!
… more11/10/23 update delivery via grubhub was prompt.
Ordered Prime rib poutine, this should be served very hot, with cheese & gravy both hot & bubly, cheese curds were hard, cold, not soft, gooey & melted. Prime rib cold & very little this time. fries seemed somewhat warm, not hot. A long black hair was found on top of it, ugh gross & Absolutely ZERO GRAVY ON POUTINE! See pics.
Im basically Paying $16 for fries with dabs of cheese & few bits of prime rib. No gravy anywhere…. no thanks!
One genny are you no longer putting gravy on your poutine? This is like 4th time zero gravy.
Asked for extra gravy on side, what i received was not gravy, it was a solid mass / clump of cold gravy. Why?? Sadly it’s become obvious if I actually want gravy on my poutine I need to be prepared & buy my own.. or maybe start making my own..
Fish fry used to be delicious but last several have been very flat, not meaty & not worth $16, will no longer order fish fry. Upside down pizza is very good, so far just cheese ordered.
Their food can be delicious. But the last 4 times I’ve ordered its been just awful considering how expensive it is. New cook maybe? Or perhaps they just don’t care anymore. It’s a shame they don’t strive to be better or care what they are sending out to people. I’m not sure if I should just give up at this point. Tired of spending hard earned money on food made half fast & without care. Do better One Genny!!!!!