Social Profile: 
![]()
![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Airy, exposed-brick space serving a variety of meatballs & sauces, with a full bar & live music.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 54 W Main St, Patchogue, NY 11772
Phone: (631) 569-5888
Website: https://www.thatmeetballplaceli.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
That Meetball Place Patchogue – Facebook
54 W Main Street, Patchogue · May be an image of text that says ‘Amsterdam n ρση or the sash honoring.
Patchogue’s Meetball Place reborn as Amsterdam and Millie’s …
Patchogue’s Meetball Place reborn as Amsterdam and Millie’s Smash Bar … That Meetball Place opened in Patchogue in 2014. It was billed as a …
Menus for That Meetball Place – Patchogue – SinglePlatform
Between the Bun · That Meetball Sub · Lobster Grilled Cheese · BBQ Beef · Grilled Chicken Smasher · Super Saucy Secret Special Burger Madness Thing* · Meatball Slider …
Reviews
Alexandra Santiago
Went for their Halloween Pop up it was so amazing the sisters were so talented and the environment was so great. My husband got the vodka pasta and it was delicious. I will say we got the sangria for two and it tasted like water which was not great. I also got the pear and fig flatbread and was extremely disappointed. First the prosciutto was fried and tasted like bacon the delicious prosciutto flavor was not present. I had 2 bites as that was all I could force myself to eat. It tasted spoiled with an aftertaste of sugar. I mentioned to the bartender as we were sitting at the bar that I didn’t like it because it tasted off and was not what was advertised. She responded that’s too bad and asked if I just wanted her to take it out of my way so I didn’t see it or if I wanted to take it home for someone else to eat. She was pushing me to take it home so I did but she did not offer me any type of solution so I could enjoy my food at the restaurant. This was very disappointing as I have never been to a restaurant where they do not try and find a solution for the customers especially after they have made it clear that they have not eaten anything and that was their first meal of the day especially when the food the customer is eating was because of their recommendation. Afterwards she proceeded to offer us dessert and try to push us to order some after we told her he’s full and I still haven’t had dinner. It was disappointing but the atmosphere was fantastic and the Sanderson sisters were extremely nice and made our night extra magical.
… moreNuK3 Worldz
Went here for a hocus pocus show, 33 dollars to walk in the door for a 10 minute performance literally 3 songs! Our waitress never came to check on us food was ok but no drinks replenished I did have an espresso martini it was pretty good. The bill came and for 3 people one adult meal, one kid meal and an app….there was a 20 percent gratuity…as the Sanders sisters made their way around the room for a 2 min photo opp they also had a tip bucket! If I could give zero stars I would have! I have done many pop ups over the years and by far this was awful. Even the decor was unimpressive
… moreDaniel Tusso
One of the best places to come into in the heart of Patchogue! Their brunch, lunch, appetizer, and dinner menu have gotten better these days! It’s definitely been a while since I was here, but their pretzel is phenomenal! I would come back as soon as possible for brunch, and a hangout spot for appetizers and dinner.
… moreMikail Morshed
i went there with my fiancé to celebrate her friend’s birthday and as we all were dancing three bouncers came and pushed and said me and her have to leave the premises and we asked for what reason because we paid for the drinks and we were just dancing so we quietly left and got into our car and came back in front to ask why that happened and some other bouncer started yelling at my fiancé while cursing at her that we don’t belong there because i’m brown and she’s hispanic and that’s racially profiling us and said that as me and my fiancé are holding our hands and having our drinks and vibing with the song isn’t appropriate because they thought we met in the club and the way were talking to each other lovingly isn’t right while we both entered the bar together so this isn’t how a customer should be treated we were there as a couple and apparently that’s not right for them while there’s people dancing on each other drunk and doing inappropriate behavior that is okay while us being polite and decent isn’t okay so i would like someone to get to the bottom of this because they said they don’t care about laws or anything and they can do whatever to us apparently so we are not a person to fight so we just left without causing a scene. if no one gets back to me about this then my law is to speak to my lawyers who i have on retainer. I WILL NOT RECOMMEND NO ONE TO GO TO A PLACE WHERE YOU ARE NOT WELCOMED BECAUSE YOU WILL DEFINITELY BE HARASSED AT THIS PLACE!! thank you
… moreSarah Montero
We got so lucky coming into this place it was empty we had the place to ourselves( memorial day). The Meatball Place is always super crowded, so to see it empty was awesome. We eat like Royalty . Everything we ordered was excellent delicious . The shrimp Scampi meatball over pasta amazing, the salsa shrimp skillet had authentic Mexican flavors and the shrimp was cooked to perfection. We also had the Crispy Burrata, crispy on the outside in a pool delicious marinara sauce with a toasted Christi, for dipping, the cheese was a little cold on the inside which was a little disappointing but it was still delicious. And the truffle fries, but who could go wrong with truffle fries!
Love the experience and will surely come back! They have drag Bingo once a month on the last Tues of the month! So I’ll be back for sure !!!
… moreLove the experience and will surely come back! They have drag Bingo once a month on the last Tues of the month! So I’ll be back for sure !!!
David Crane
Now the Amsterdam in Patchogue. Put our name on the wait list at 7:20pm. By 9:15 still hadn’t been seated even though there were many open tables throughout the evening. Can’t rate the food because we never got to eat. No place to put your coat or put down a drink unless you happen to get a spot at the bar. They took a $20 cover charge for the band when we came in but after a little while I noticed they stopped charging people when they came in. Service was awful and management was totally absent. Stay away! Plenty of other places to go in Patchogue for music and food.
… moreLij T
RIP OFF ALERT!
This restaurant padds their bills (put a higher price on the bill than their menu)
I was here for brunch and ordered two items from the menu. 1 Veggi Lovers Scramle listed on the menu for $15 and 1 Lobster Benedict listed on the menu for $20. When the bill arrived, the itmes were charged $16 and $24 instead. A mark up of 13%, then you are charged taxes and are expected to tip and pay credit card fees on padded bills.
If this is what this restaurant does in the daytime for brunch, imagine what they do at night after patrons have a few drinks in them.
What bothered me the most was that the waitress did not apologize as if she knew this is common practice. She went back and corrected the bill twice (it appears on the bill as a discount , but it is the price on the menu) and returned as if nothing had happened! I have attached the photos of jacked up bills, corrected bills, and menu prices so anyone can see and verify them.
… moreThis restaurant padds their bills (put a higher price on the bill than their menu)
I was here for brunch and ordered two items from the menu. 1 Veggi Lovers Scramle listed on the menu for $15 and 1 Lobster Benedict listed on the menu for $20. When the bill arrived, the itmes were charged $16 and $24 instead. A mark up of 13%, then you are charged taxes and are expected to tip and pay credit card fees on padded bills.
If this is what this restaurant does in the daytime for brunch, imagine what they do at night after patrons have a few drinks in them.
What bothered me the most was that the waitress did not apologize as if she knew this is common practice. She went back and corrected the bill twice (it appears on the bill as a discount , but it is the price on the menu) and returned as if nothing had happened! I have attached the photos of jacked up bills, corrected bills, and menu prices so anyone can see and verify them.
Blackout The Rebel
Sometimes, I do rideshare, and recently, I have been dropping a lot of people off to this place. So naturally, I became curious about what the big deal was. Finally, I had time this past weekend, so my girlfriend and I tried it out, and we were thoroughly pleased. The food is big portioned, so be careful ordering for yourself. Sometimes, you might be okay with just sharing a meal unless you’re prepared to pack it up to go. I tried the Buffalo meatball, and it was extremely good. I believe the drink I tried was something called the gingerbread man. Whatever it was, it tasted really good, and I recommend that if you’re into dark drinks that have a little cinnamon kick. Food is half the battle, the other half is the customer service, and they also have that on lock as well. Our waitress Emily was really friendly and helpful. She also has great taste in music. I wasn’t expecting the chef to come out and check on us, but Tom certainly did, and I appreciate the attention because it showed pride in his work, which was reflected in the rich taste of everything. Overall, I can’t wait to come back and see what else there is to try.
… moreSamantha Telesca
I cannot express how amazing The Meetball Place is. Between the FANTASTIC brunch and the amazing night vibe, nothing compares. Allie and Kayla are absolutely PHENOMENAL. They are so sweet, efficient, and accommodating. If I could tell everyone on Long Island to go here, I would scream it from the rooftops. And if you needed a reason or a sign, GO TO MEETBALL PLACE.
… moreTatyana Fox
The place have good happy hour, the section in thd back is awesome. Its looks like a retro burger joint. Very cool. Delicious food and decent coctails!
… more