Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 22741 Three Notch Rd, California, MD 20619
Phone: (301) 863-2233
Website: http://www.nicollettis.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Home – Nicolleti’s Pizza
At Nicolletti’s Pizza – we take pride in crafting nearly all our dishes … 22741 Three Notch Road, California, MD 20619, USA. © 2025 Nicollettis – All …
Nicollettis Pizza | California MD – Facebook
Nicollettis Pizza, California. 10514 likes · 1542 talking about this · 6169 were here. Family oriented with sit-down dining. Serves pizza and italian…
Nicolletti’s Pizza – Order Online
Sign in for a faster ordering experience. Banner image. Nicolletti’s Pizza. 22741 Three Notch Road, California, MD.
Reviews
Alberto Zamorano
My very 1st time at this very casual restaurant as I’ve decided to check out their pizza, not wanting to order a whole pie, I’ve decided to try their buffet for lunch as I was hoping to get just 2 slices of pizza for lunch. There’s a good a la carte menu which I’ll try next time.
The pizza is good and well prepared with an abundance of ingredients. The only reason I didn’t rated 5 stars it’s that I’ve had better pizzas in the past. The salads options were also good, it’s a large capacity restaurant good for parties with plenty of seat boosters for toddlers and older kids, also it’s a good value for the money.
… moreThe pizza is good and well prepared with an abundance of ingredients. The only reason I didn’t rated 5 stars it’s that I’ve had better pizzas in the past. The salads options were also good, it’s a large capacity restaurant good for parties with plenty of seat boosters for toddlers and older kids, also it’s a good value for the money.
Jeff K.
Recently dined here for the first time. Ordering at the counter was pretty straightforward. They had no slices, so we opted for a medium cheese pizza.
When we were served, we didn’t receive any plates, which was a bit strange.
The pizza was baked well. The crust was good, the sauce could use some work, but the amount of cheese used was the highlight. If this was my local pizza spot, I wouldn’t be mad about it.
… moreWhen we were served, we didn’t receive any plates, which was a bit strange.
The pizza was baked well. The crust was good, the sauce could use some work, but the amount of cheese used was the highlight. If this was my local pizza spot, I wouldn’t be mad about it.
Wayne “Diesel” Eldridge
Probably the singular dumbest ordering experience I’ve ever had for my pizza place.
I attempted to order a Philly steak pizza, Hawaiian pizza and garlic bread.
For some reason the Hawaiian pizza didn’t get added to the order, when I contacted the restaurant attempting to have the pizza added to the order, I was informed that they can’t take payment over the phones, so they can’t make it right…
THEY CAN’T TAKE PHONE PAYMENTS AT A PIZZA PLACE. I CAN’T MAKE THIS STUFF UP.
So, since we’re too incompetent to make it right, I’ll simply never be ordering there again. This was my first impression of you.
Also, the food is middle of the road. Nothing to write home about.
Response to owner reply: you were still given a chance to make it right, you still had the capability of doing so, you still chose not to. Third party or not delivery, this is your reputation on the line. I called you well before the driver picked up the order to try to just pay for a pizza to make it right. Did not try to get one over on you, this is on you, take accountability and move on.
… moreI attempted to order a Philly steak pizza, Hawaiian pizza and garlic bread.
For some reason the Hawaiian pizza didn’t get added to the order, when I contacted the restaurant attempting to have the pizza added to the order, I was informed that they can’t take payment over the phones, so they can’t make it right…
THEY CAN’T TAKE PHONE PAYMENTS AT A PIZZA PLACE. I CAN’T MAKE THIS STUFF UP.
So, since we’re too incompetent to make it right, I’ll simply never be ordering there again. This was my first impression of you.
Also, the food is middle of the road. Nothing to write home about.
Response to owner reply: you were still given a chance to make it right, you still had the capability of doing so, you still chose not to. Third party or not delivery, this is your reputation on the line. I called you well before the driver picked up the order to try to just pay for a pizza to make it right. Did not try to get one over on you, this is on you, take accountability and move on.
B Dubbya
I rarely go under 4 stars with reviews as you can see. This place was nice; had a really really quaint homey small town vibe. Service was fine; person was polite enough (I was entertained by the three-four people having a meeting, while one of them looked severely perplexed. That was more comical.) The food itself tasted great and looked the part too. It was certainly showroom quality and can be posted on a menu. It’s why I’m giving it two stars. But one slice in and I had a very very bad reaction. One I have not had from pizza in a very very long time. My stomach had a shooting pain and I had to seek a restroom, IMMEDIATELY. Normally I think it could have been something else in my daily diet mixing with it but this was the only thing I had eaten all day. The stomach pain persisted throughout my entire day from three onward up to when I woke up the following morning. I don’t know if it was one of the ingridients in my white pizza, but Jesus. It was my first and last pizza experience in southern MD.
… moreK Daniel
Let me start by saying I am not a huge pizza fan. My husband and I went in today for lunch to try something new. He’s an avid pizza guy.
I was absolutely blown away when I walked in. The menu looked fantastic, but we went for the buffet. They have a really great salad and pasta bar! My heart was happy and so was his. I did try some of the pizza and it was delicious. My only gripe was watching them mix together different slices of pizza into a single tray to maximize space. This doesn’t seem ideal for those with allergies. A section of my pizza had a jalapeño bite to it but no visible peppers. They must have had jalapeños on the pizza tray before it was laid on it.
Salad bar had plenty of great toppings and different types of lettuce. Various types of pasta salad, canned fruit, chocolate pudding, gold fish, marshmallow fruit salad, and french bread with butter.
Loved the cup of cards to play a game while you eat!
Total price: $32.98 for 2 adult buffets and 2 drinks.
We’ll b back to try some menu items!
… moreI was absolutely blown away when I walked in. The menu looked fantastic, but we went for the buffet. They have a really great salad and pasta bar! My heart was happy and so was his. I did try some of the pizza and it was delicious. My only gripe was watching them mix together different slices of pizza into a single tray to maximize space. This doesn’t seem ideal for those with allergies. A section of my pizza had a jalapeño bite to it but no visible peppers. They must have had jalapeños on the pizza tray before it was laid on it.
Salad bar had plenty of great toppings and different types of lettuce. Various types of pasta salad, canned fruit, chocolate pudding, gold fish, marshmallow fruit salad, and french bread with butter.
Loved the cup of cards to play a game while you eat!
Total price: $32.98 for 2 adult buffets and 2 drinks.
We’ll b back to try some menu items!
Andrew H
Nicolletti’s Pizza is a wonderful hole in the wall pizza joint. The dough is thin and has a good chew to it. I ordered a small sausage and mushroom pizza to go and it takes about 15 minutes. The sausage is a mix between spicy and normal and is on the fiber side of grounding. The flavor is really good with the cheese and sauce. There looked to be a good amount of seating inside and the staff was friendly. I would eat here again and try some of the other items as well. A solid five star pizza place.
… moreAdam Farmer
This is our go to Pizza spot. Our normal pie is a garlic, pepperoni and extra cheese pizza. Now I will say this is not the cheapest pizza place in town but you do get what you pay for. The other thing to make mention is the Nicolletti’s piles on the topping, which can make eating a pizza with more than 2 or 3 toppings difficult to manage. I love a Supreme pizza but never order here because you can’t really pick it up and eat it.
… moreBrian Brown
ALL YOU CAN EAT LUNCH BUFFET MONDAY THRU FRIDAY 11a-2p Great service as always. The food is great… we really like thier pizza rolls and the pizza bread. The lunch buffet is great. If you don’t see something you like just ask and they will be happy to make it for you.
… moreKaren Myers
I went to the Artfest at Anne Marie Garden recently. I was so excited to see Nicollettis pizza there because I love their pizza. I ordered a pepperoni pizza slice. I received I slice with two slices of pepperoni. I asked if I could get more since two is ridiculous. The OWNER proceed to yell at me from the truck telling me I needed to take what they give me. What is wrong with this man?
… moreMichael Fleetwood
Simply awesome. Thick crust just the way I like it. Might as well be Chicago deep dish!
… more