Bodhi Jones
Been going to Pizza Port for years. Long Before Tim bought the place. Fun to sit in a pizza pub and watch Surf movies. However, after the last few visits I am disappointed. The quality of the Ingredients are okay. The issue is value. For the cost and how few toppings they use. It feels like a tourist trap where it’s just about location not quality or value. Come on Tim, for a nearly $40 Large pie put some more toppings and sauce. Or not….and just bank on location.
… moreVee Hub
First time there, so yummy!!!! Best pizza I’ve had in a long time!! Definitely a must stop, it’s a local small business. Staff was nice and restrooms clean. My new fave place to grab a pizza in morro bay!!
… moreBobby MF Dobbs
We absolutely love the amazing hand tossed pizza and a the outdoor patio is awesome . This place is very family friendly with lots of games for kids / the family to enjoy while waiting for your pie. The staff was and has been great with each vist
… moreLeslie Iacono
Ordered online for pick up. It was super easy. They have pizza and sandwiches and sell beer and stuff. Not the best pizza but it’s good enough. It’s like a good bad pizza. The dough was kind of soft and soggy. Loaded with toppings. Some would say it was a bit too heavy/ the crust for sure couldn’t support the weight. Great service. Easy interaction.
… moreKarl Clintsman
We stopped by Pizza Port for lunch and ordered takeout—a 16-inch pepperoni pizza, mozzarella sticks, and a salad. While the service was quick and efficient (credit to the team at the counter for doing their job well), the food itself was a mixed bag.
Starting with the mozzarella sticks: they were disappointingly thick, yet hollow, with barely any cheese inside. The batter lacked seasoning, and no effort seemed to be made to enhance the flavor after cooking. To make matters worse, the marinara sauce was ice cold, which didn’t help the overall experience.
The pizza was where the real letdown happened. While the presentation was solid—the pizza looked inviting—the execution fell short. The cheese was piled on so thick it became overwhelming, while the sauce was barely noticeable. What little sauce there was lacked seasoning, leaving the overall flavor flat. As someone who grew up in New York and knows what a great slice should taste like, this just didn’t measure up. It’s better than some of the generic options we get back home in California, but it doesn’t hold a candle to authentic NY-style pizza.
On a positive note, the salad was fresh, and its presentation was well done. It was clear that some effort went into making the dishes visually appealing.
That said, the service was fast and friendly, which was a bright spot in the experience. With better ingredients and a more balanced approach to seasoning and preparation, I’d gladly give Pizza Port another try.
Food: ⭐⭐½
Presentation: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Service: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Value: ⭐⭐⭐
Would I return? Only if they improve their ingredients and flavors. There’s potential here, but it’s not being fully realized yet.
… moreTami Donner
Always the same awesome pizza!! Our NY guests loved how it was very fresh tasting and that it has limp and chewy, thin crust. We ordered the Roma. We took it straight to Morro Rock and ate on a bench at sunset. Had fun watching the otters and talking about how much all loved the pizza! The restaurant has a TON of outdoor seating in back.
… moreScotty Shakers
Great place for a quick bite with chill vibes. Food is pretty solid, staff is super friendly and accommodating. Its a quaint little spot with an outdoor patio aswell. My daughter and I split a pepperoni pizza and a meatball sub. I feel like these are two staples to every pizza joint and a good standard to judge quality. The dough was nice and thin with a little flop (could’ve cooked a few min longer in my opinion) and the sub was toasted to perfection on a delicious garlic loaf. 4.6 out of 5 shakers I will definitely stop by again when in the area.
… moreMarilyn Besasie
We were all pizza’d out, so at the end of a long day of sightseeing, we saw Veggie Sandwiches on their menu and were thrilled. Get up to the counter and order the Veggie Sandwiches to be told they’re only available at lunchtime. So disappointed! But there was nothing else really open this time of night, so we had to get pizza. Luckily, they had vegan crust and vegan cheese, so winner winner chick’n dinner! They were actually very, very good, so no big loss at all. We had to ask for napkins when the pizza arrived (this is the second time in California a restaurant brought our food to our table with no napkins anywhere in sight; is this a California thing?) and when we asked for some, we were told they were all out of napkins. Okaaay. Then after a couple of minutes, napkins arrived…with another restaurant’s logo on them. Did they run next door and swipe the competition’s napkins? Don’t know, but California, you’ve got an interesting way of doing business.
… moreLaura W.
A real treasure! Excellent place! Memorable atmosphere, fresh, tasty, delicious food! We had pizza, salad and meatball sandwich. Frosty cold draft beer. A new favorite place! Love all the surfboards decorating the place. Indoor and outdoor seating. Right on the corner. Easy to find! Already planning to go back to try the calzones! ❤ She even double cut our pizza for us! So nice! Highly recommended! 5 starry eyes
… more