Jay
Highly recommend by friends for pizza and foods, but didn’t quite live up to the higher expectations. I can see why the locals love it though. Server was prompt and polite. Beer is served in Ball jar glasses, which is tacky and shouldn’t be a thing imo. The stout was served in a propper glass. The whipped feta was decent, with halved cherry tomatoes and basic toast. The bruschetta pesto pizza was just OK. I added artichokes and tomatos and there were barely any tomato or bruschetta on it. Prices are decent for food, beer is a little expensive. Overall impression was its a place for fancy bar food and locals.
… moreAlice Asman
It’s a very nice restaurant. The waitress was not very observant to our table. But in her defense she was busy in our section. The food was OK. We ordered the arancini and the whipped feta. That was really good. I ordered the reuben sandwich with chips. Let’s just say the chips were good.
… moreKeith Mallory
absolutely amazing food it’s a local staple that everyone recommends. The pizzas are legendary they have other great Italian specials too like the mozzarella tower or lasagna roll also really great drinks. it’s kinda loud on weekends but a mix between upscale and casual dining. staff is friendly and really helpful and attentive.
… moreCraig Hierholzer
The pizza was very good. Nice thin crust, crispy on the edges, real Italian sausage and pepperoni, the right amount of cheese, and great pesto sauce!
… moreSandy Oates
Got 2 pizzas, with taste like flavorless cardboard crust with cheap ingredtents. The gound chicken meatballs should be considered toxic,gross.
… moreBrooke S.
Family friendly, warm lighting, friendly and accommodating staff. The food was great and the overall price point was very good in my opinion!
… moreJoLaine Lehan
This is a great place for a casual business lunch. We met for a holiday lunch, without reservations. We had a seat for our large group in a timely manner. The food was absolutely amazing. We had brussel sprouts and feta dip and some mozarells bite things for appetizers. The meals were all large portions and super delicious. Our table had a salad a few burgers and some pizzas. I eat gluten free and they were able to make reasonable accomodations, no bun, extra lettuce leaf and a salad instead of fries. The burger was made with quality ingredients, juicy, flavorful and the bacon was to die for. Our server was great and even tho she super busy (everyone was so busy). We never had an empty drink or a table of empty plates.
This was my 1st time here for a work event, and we will be back.
… moreMissy
My family has been coming to 5th Street Pub for nearly ten years, always sitting at the bar. For most of that time, the experience has been consistently positive — especially thanks to the longtime male bartender who has always been kind, attentive, and welcoming. After my dad entered a nursing home, it’s usually just been my mom and me, and this place became a small tradition for us during happy hour.
Unfortunately, tonight was the first time we’ve ever felt uncomfortable, disrespected, and genuinely unsafe here.
Our to‑go order was delayed, so we stayed a bit longer than usual. While waiting, we asked a female bartender who was cleaning glasses if we could order a bottle of wine. It took quite a while, but that wasn’t the real issue.
While we were still waiting, an extremely intoxicated woman came up behind us, put her arms around both me and my mom, and said, “Babes, can we come to a decision?” We told her not to touch us and that we would be leaving soon. Instead of stepping in, the staff member behind the bar — who clearly knew this group — opened our wine, laughed with them, and carried on as if nothing inappropriate had happened.
I was left trying to pull the cork out from an awkward position, spilled a little, and when I tried to express how uncomfortable the situation was, the bartender laughed from the corner and said, “I hope you have a better night.”
After a decade of being loyal, respectful customers — often some of the first people in and the first to leave — it was incredibly disappointing to be treated this way. It felt like our comfort and safety were dismissed so that the bartender’s friends could take our seats and behave however they wanted.
I truly hope management takes this seriously. No customer should be touched by strangers, ignored by staff, or made to feel like an inconvenience so that employees can prioritize their friends over paying guests.
… moreAmber Frain-Curtis
Not a single complaint about the food. We door dashed so I can’t comment on the restaurant itself. The tomato sauce and meatballs are delicious. Meatballs taste like my grandma actually made them. My only complaint is I wish the meatball appetizer had more than 3 but said 3 meatballs are delicious, as is the risotto.
… moreJohn T
Fun place to stop for a meal. Pizza is delicious, and the Reuben is good too. Excellent homemade chips. Casual crowd, great for conversation too. Clean, and friendly staff.
… more