Robert Keeton
I have lived in this area for the last 25 years of my life, and I even worked at Bains Deli (which was right next to Antony’s Pizza (now Mall Pizza) when I was 18 years old and met my now wife. Antony’s and Mall Pizza have always been among my top favorite pizzas ever. The only better Pizza that I’ve had in my life was Pizza Dude, but only when they were across from Geneva College. Mike is a really nice guy, and he has always treated me like an old friend, along with his sons. This is a family owned Pizza restaurant, and believe me, they aren’t about to change their proven recipes for anyone or anything. They serve the best pies that they possibly can, and they NEVER miss. I don’t care what it costs, it’s worth it. Go to Boardwalk, or Sal’s in Chippewa (same owner), their pizza is great too, and similarly priced, but Mall Pizza will always be my favorite. I wasn’t even hungry the other day, but I was close by, so I HAD to get a pie, and it’s always great to reconnect with old friends and reminisce on the old days. Thank you for sticking around guys, and I hope you’re around for many years to come. A great pizza is just too good to deny to future generations!
… moreMichelle Main
This is probably my favorite local pizza shop! I was so happy when it came back to the Beaver Valley Mall. Reasonably priced, fantastic pizza, & friendly service. Their new taco pizza is great! Definitely a bright spot in a mall that has lost a lot of tenants.
… moreJames Morrison
This is my new favorite pizza in beaver county. The crust is super crispy around the edges, perfect sauce with the right amount of cheese. I now crave this pizza once the weekend comes. Amazing.
… moreJakob
We drive out of the way to get this pizza ever few weeks because it’s the best around! 9/10 times it’s perfect and when it’s not they work with you to fix it. I highly recommend it!
… moreJessica Diaddigo
I don’t understand how people can still eat dominoes or papa John’s after eating Mall Pizza. Even just the plain cheese pizza is insanely flavorful. My favorite is the vegetable pizza and Stromboli
The staff is super friendly too!
… moreCara Niderstros
This pizza is so delicious! The staff is so friendly, I got there right before they closed and they were still happy to serve me! I love love that you can get it by slice or get a box to go! For sure the best in this area!
… moreRobin Sloppy
I can only give 5 stars, but they deserve 5,000 stars I have never found a better spinach pizza. I buy the large & wrap each piece in tin foil & freeze. I love their spinach rolls. & if I only want a slice I get 2 pieces of veggie pizza. I’m so glad he came back. He only left because the mall rent was to high. He left for a long while, but added a partner & came back. SO GLAD HE DID.
… moreSylvia Rodriguez
Best pizza in Beaver county… reminds me of New York pizza. And the employees are amazing
… moreShane Kasunich
Can’t believe I didn’t know about this place, this is the best pizza I have had in a long time, I got 2 pieces of delicious pepperoni pizza and a medium drink for $7.49 wow What a deal. The pizza was hand tossed and very fresh. The cheese was not greasy and the sauce was very good. What I loved most was how crisp the pizza was. I will definitely look into ordering it ahead and picking it up on my way home, it was very busy but there were a lot of people working and everyone was super friendly. It was a very clean place.
… more