David Repko
. One of the worst margarita pizzas i have. The sauce was super bland, it tastes like he poured crushed tomatoes out of a can on the pizza and called it a day. The dough tasted like Hannafords store bought dough. I was really disappointed. To top it all off this young man folded the pizza box inside out so the box didn’t close and Pizza was cold within 5 minutes. Amateur!!!
… moreTedd Gras
A small quaint spot in the middle of a small sleepy town… But, the food ain’t small in size or taste… fresh ingredients… Great staff… and a great selection of other vendor items in there… if you are ever passing by, swing on in… Was on my way back home to Latham and swung by… 10 min out of the way, but worth every minute of the diversion… Kinderhook being a Sleepy town, but worth it fully… the Pizza and the stromboli was great… was hoping they had the burnt butter rice crispy treats again… unfortunately not… will have to see them again… Maybe next time, I will try their Slingerlands location…
… moreCatherine Boehme
Can’t explain enough why this should be named Columbia County’s best pizzeria. Come here and you won’t be disappointed.
… moreMartin Tomczyk
I lived in Brookyn over 20 yrs. This pizza does not compare! Your name is misleading. Pizza Quality is subpar – the crust is chewy, it’s too thick and it’s cooked on screens which changes the flavor/quality. Go to NYC to the top three 5 star rated pizza shops and see how they do it!!! If money is a motivator then do some foody research and improve your product.
Also, the guy that served me was rude, like he did me a Big favor for heating up a slice and taking my money
… moreRaelene Pitt
Loved the pizza best I’ve had in the area in a while the wings I didnt like too much but the pizza was delicious
… moreJohn Wenz
OG NY Pizza pie! Solid crust with a great tear from adequate kneading. Holds up well to the plentiful toppings.
… moreSaadia Santos
Stopped in for a slice while biking through town on the Electric Trail. They have a bike rack out front, lovely feature. The pizza was delicious, rich flavorful sauce and reheated to perfection.
… moreGlen Browning
We’ve eaten here twice, by recommendation. Thin crust pizza. Martin Van Buren House is nearby (free tour by Park Ranger). Just north of Kinderhook in Valatie is Golden Harvest Farm
Which is an apple orchard, distillery and has a bbq stand. Well worth a visit.
… moreEmerson Bostick
Served by Tim who was amazing the service was exceptional and the pizza was incredible. I get the pepperoni Stromboli all the time its perfect. I only wish they had a buffalo chicken Stromboli I would get it every week.
… moreRusty Pro
They say service goes a long way when it comes to earning and retaining custom. The Brooklyn Pizzeria has itself a Secret Service Star in Riley!! Riley greeted my son and I with a Smile as we entered and provided friendly, helpful information. Riley handed us to go menu on our way out as we continued our search for what we wanted to eat. Upon arrival home and after some deliberation it was decided due to Riley’s helpful friendly service, The Brooklyn Pizzeria was the way to go. Thanks, Riley !! You get 5 Stars from Max and Rusty !!
… more