Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Welcome to INItaly Pizzeria Bar, where we bring the taste of Naples to Indiana! Enjoy authentic Neapolitan pizza made with fresh, in-house mozzarella and dough that rises for 24 hours-light, airy, and unforgettable. Pair your pizza with Italian wines, craft beers, and refreshing cocktails in a warm, family-friendly setting. We’re also the only spot in Indiana serving traditional fried pizza-a must-try! Dine in, order takeout, or enjoy fast delivery. Ready to experience true Neapolitan flavor? Visit us today or call for delivery. One bite, and you’ll be hooked! Un po’ più lungo Here’s a slightly
Hours
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 2–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–2 PM, 5–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–2 PM, 5–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–2 PM, 5–9 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 107 E State St, Pendleton, IN 46064
Phone: (765) 221-1049
Website: http://initalypizzeria.com/
Order and Reservations
Reservations: toasttab.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
INItaly Pizzeria&Bar
INItaly Pizzeria&Bar. “Authentic Neapolitan Pizza in the Heart of … Pendleton IN. 46064. Contact. (765) 221 1049. [email protected]. Facebook …
INItaly Pizzeria & Bar | Pendleton IN – Facebook
OUTSIDE PATIO LIVE MUSIC Reservations are recommended! Call : 765-221-1049 Or visit : www.initalypizzeria&bar.com 107 E State St. Pendleton (IN) # …
INItaly Pizzeria&Bar (@initalypizzeriabar) · Pendleton, IN – Instagram
1.3K+ followers · 67 posts · Authentic Neapolitan Pizza 107 E State St. Pendleton (IN) Pizza by @nicolaricciardi_123 Family member of @initaly_indy …
Reviews
Andrew McDonald
My father-in-law introduced me to this restaurant a couple of months after it opened. I have had the extreme pleasure of dining here over a half a dozen times since in groups ranging in size from 1-12. The atmosphere is lovely, service impeccable and the food is divine.
Appetizers are hit or miss, but the pizza is consistently excellent. My personal favorite is the INItaly, which manages to pack a wide variety of subtle flavors that all complement each other very well. All ingredients are extremely fresh and of particularly high quality. Many pizzerias make their own dough in house. Few produce their own mozzarella! The pizza dough is perfectly prepared. The end result is slightly chewy, yet soft crust that warms you from the inside out.
Espressos, cappuccinos and desserts are all quite nice if you have room left for them.
Restrooms are clean and well-maintained with no shortage of hot water.
Notably, every man, woman and child who I have personally introduced to this restaurant has had similar raving reviews. INItaly is a great date night choice, but is equally well suited to a family gathering or an organizational meeting. Reservations are often unnecessary. However, calling ahead to confirm is highly recommended in case it happens to be a busy day. This is true for parties of all sizes. Buon appetito!
… moreAppetizers are hit or miss, but the pizza is consistently excellent. My personal favorite is the INItaly, which manages to pack a wide variety of subtle flavors that all complement each other very well. All ingredients are extremely fresh and of particularly high quality. Many pizzerias make their own dough in house. Few produce their own mozzarella! The pizza dough is perfectly prepared. The end result is slightly chewy, yet soft crust that warms you from the inside out.
Espressos, cappuccinos and desserts are all quite nice if you have room left for them.
Restrooms are clean and well-maintained with no shortage of hot water.
Notably, every man, woman and child who I have personally introduced to this restaurant has had similar raving reviews. INItaly is a great date night choice, but is equally well suited to a family gathering or an organizational meeting. Reservations are often unnecessary. However, calling ahead to confirm is highly recommended in case it happens to be a busy day. This is true for parties of all sizes. Buon appetito!
Sie Phanna (Sieways6)
Had to give this place a second try. Good spot for a pizza but just wasn’t impressed with the pies. Something about the dough was off to me. Could use maybe a little more salt and butter, or more time proofing, IDK, it might just be the water here. Everything else was great, the service was excellent, the atmosphere was amazing. We had burgers, pies, and a few drinks. Not a bad time.
… moreSivani Kuruvada
Delicious wood fired pizzas in a small cozy nook in Pendleton, Indiana. Beautiful ambience with spacious outdoor seating. They make their own fresh mozzarella and it was lovely. Hidden gem in East Indiana!
… moresda seven
$75 (incl tip & credit card surcharge) got us two mediocre personal pizzas, bruschetta that just was not very good, and an excellent salad. No drinks. One of the pizzas was the margarita which we added the mixed olives option. The mix olive option got us 6 green olive halves (not sure what happened to the “mix”), that was all. Admittedly, sauce is subjective, but we just did not like it. Had a smoky flavor. Crust is typical for a “wood” oven – dry and thin and a slight well done flavor. Lastly, I believe this restaurant would do better in the long term if they looked to provide more value for what they charge. Glad others love the place as the restaurant is very clean, serving staff is good, and the atmosphere is fun.
… moreKirby Purciful
Truly legitimate Italian pizza. Dough is light and flavorful. We had traditional flavor pizzas and they were all amazing. You definitely start eating with your eyes and these pizza looks as good as it eats. The decor of the restaurant is very nice and feels like a small cafe in Naples. My wife and we felt like we were celebrating our first anniversary all over again. Thank you for the walk down memory lane. We will definitely be back.
… moreIsrrael Gonzalez
The ambiance at INItaly is truly remarkable, with lighting that creates a warm and inviting atmosphere. From the moment you walk in, you feel welcomed and comfortable. The service is outstanding—attentive and friendly, making the dining experience even more enjoyable.
The pizzas are absolutely fantastic. They offer a unique twist on traditional Italian recipes, delivering flavors that are both authentic and innovative. Each bite takes you on a journey to Italy, but with a creative touch that makes them stand out. The appetizers are equally impressive—beautifully presented, imaginative, and bursting with flavor. You can tell that a lot of thought and care go into each dish.
Everything tastes incredibly fresh, from the starters to the main courses. The quality of the ingredients is evident, and it’s clear that they prioritize serving the best. The drink menu is diverse, catering to different tastes. I tried the Aperol Spritz, and it was perfectly balanced and refreshing—ideal for complementing the meal.
I genuinely believe that INItaly is destined to become a popular spot, not just in Pendleton but throughout Indiana. The only suggestion I have is that they consider expanding the space because once people discover this gem, it’s going to be packed!
I highly recommend INItaly to anyone looking for an exceptional dining experience with a creative take on Italian cuisine. I wish them great success and am excited to see them grow!
… moreThe pizzas are absolutely fantastic. They offer a unique twist on traditional Italian recipes, delivering flavors that are both authentic and innovative. Each bite takes you on a journey to Italy, but with a creative touch that makes them stand out. The appetizers are equally impressive—beautifully presented, imaginative, and bursting with flavor. You can tell that a lot of thought and care go into each dish.
Everything tastes incredibly fresh, from the starters to the main courses. The quality of the ingredients is evident, and it’s clear that they prioritize serving the best. The drink menu is diverse, catering to different tastes. I tried the Aperol Spritz, and it was perfectly balanced and refreshing—ideal for complementing the meal.
I genuinely believe that INItaly is destined to become a popular spot, not just in Pendleton but throughout Indiana. The only suggestion I have is that they consider expanding the space because once people discover this gem, it’s going to be packed!
I highly recommend INItaly to anyone looking for an exceptional dining experience with a creative take on Italian cuisine. I wish them great success and am excited to see them grow!
Barbara Whitlock
This is the most authentic Napolese pizza we’ve had in the greater Indy area. We’ve been searching for pizza that tastes most like the pizza we’ve eaten in Italy, and finally found it!! Absolutely delicious, fresh ingredients, true to what Napolese pizza should be. The service was phenomenal our server was so sweet and helpful, and the atmosphere was perfect. I only wish we could have tried everything on the menu! We will be back again and again for this delicious food and perfect service. What a gem of a restaurant- I feel so fortunate that we read an amazing article in Indianapolis Monthly about this place and decided to give it a try. Bravo, In Italy! You’ve got customers for life!
… moreLaura Mills
My favorite place in Pendleton! To be honest I don’t know if it is the pizza or the meatballs that keep me coming back! The service was great each and every time! The INItaly is my go to pizza, so different, so delicious! I could eat there every week if my husband would let me. Also the leftovers heat up great!
… moreemily johnson
This place is absolutely beautiful, with so much attention to detail to create a warm and authentic Italian pizzeria atmosphere. The pizza is amazing—the crust is light and perfectly made with top-quality ingredients. I tried the Indiana pizza, and it was simply fantastic!To finish on a sweet note, the tiramisu was an absolute delight—so creamy and full of flavor.
Definitely a must-try. Highly recommended!!!!
… moreDefinitely a must-try. Highly recommended!!!!
Gianina Schettini
**5 out of 5 stars – A True Taste of Naples!**
We had an unforgettable date night at **INItaly** in Pendleton, IN—and it was nothing short of spectacular. From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere was warm and inviting, but the food absolutely stole the show.
We ordered the **INItaly pizza**, and WOW. Homemade mozzarella, mortadella, burrata, pistachio grains, pistachio pesto, parmesan flakes, EVOO, and fresh basil—it was a flavor explosion that instantly transported me back to Naples, Italy. This might be the best pizza I’ve had outside of Italy, hands down.
We also tried the **Panzarotto** and **Patatine Cacio e Pepe**, and both were out-of-this-world delicious. The Patatine were perfectly crispy and seasoned, and the Panzarotto was a cheesy, comforting dream.
If you’re anywhere near Pendleton, do yourself a favor and eat here. You *won’t* regret it. Authentic Italian flavors, top-tier ingredients, and a cozy atmosphere. We’ll definitely be back!
… moreWe had an unforgettable date night at **INItaly** in Pendleton, IN—and it was nothing short of spectacular. From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere was warm and inviting, but the food absolutely stole the show.
We ordered the **INItaly pizza**, and WOW. Homemade mozzarella, mortadella, burrata, pistachio grains, pistachio pesto, parmesan flakes, EVOO, and fresh basil—it was a flavor explosion that instantly transported me back to Naples, Italy. This might be the best pizza I’ve had outside of Italy, hands down.
We also tried the **Panzarotto** and **Patatine Cacio e Pepe**, and both were out-of-this-world delicious. The Patatine were perfectly crispy and seasoned, and the Panzarotto was a cheesy, comforting dream.
If you’re anywhere near Pendleton, do yourself a favor and eat here. You *won’t* regret it. Authentic Italian flavors, top-tier ingredients, and a cozy atmosphere. We’ll definitely be back!