3.8 – 123 reviews • Pizza restaurant
Welcome to Belisimo’s Pizza, your ultimate destination for authentic Italian cuisine in New Windsor at 105 Church Street. We pride ourselves on serving the finest classic pizza dishes and a variety of traditional Italian fare that will transport your taste buds to Italy. Whether you’re searching for Pizza Near Me, craving delectable Cheesesteak Sandwiches, or in need of Pizza Delivery, we’ve got you covered. As a beloved local Pizza Restaurant and Italian Restaurant, our inviting atmosphere offers more than just great food. Enjoy live music events and pool access for a unique dining experience. Visit us for a memorable culinary journey!
Local Italian chain featuring a menu of classic dishes, pool & live music in casual surroundings.
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
belisimos.com
Related Web Results
Last Updates
Reviews
Andrew “Andy” Garcia IV
We came into town to see our friends and they recommended this spot. Both my wife and her friend chipped their teeth on the gluten free pizza which resembled fossilized disc. Regular pizza was fare but for the price of a 10 inch frisbee we have to see a dentist over, much less sub par atmosphere they need to up their game or New Windsor needs another option.
… moreJean Anderson
This location is the reason I stopped getting Belisimo’s. Until I moved to Westminster. The difference is notably remarkable… I couldn’t get enough of everything they have on the menu at the Pennsylvania ave, Westminster store… New Windsor should train thier employees at the Westminster location
… moreUp To Par Fishing
We ordered wings, cheesesteak and pizza and it was all really good! Pizza was great! Wings were awesome and the cheesesteak was overstuffed and super good!
… moreAleko Kontos
You absolutely have to respect the complete and utter lack of care, it feels authentically Italian. If they had an espresso machine and some peroni or moretti I might actually believe I stepped into the old country. Or at least until the food came.
This truly was an experience to remember. I had never eaten a steak and cheese with unmelted cheese before. Now the abysmal sandwich isn’t entirely their fault, I take full responsibility for not checking what type of cheese they use.
Belisimos, I will remember you fondly. Thanks for the laughs.
… morejessie shaffer
Customer service sucks over there. Sherry is not a nice person and whoever that guy is I’m thinking it’s her boyfriend. He’s very disrespectful and they when I was in there eating they decided to go in the back and not come out to see how I was doing if I needed anything else, and I was waiting out front to order something else and I could see them in the back the corner of my eye making out
… moreLisa Lewis
Best Cheesesteaks ever. The workers are very friendly. Parking was easy.
… moreBrad Shaffp
The manager tall blonde woman was very nasty when I approached the counter on a Saturday very rude to the employees even arguing at one point doesn’t seem to know what she’s doing and the drivers work hard for very little pay get rid of her the place would feel much more relaxed and pleasant
… moreAllyson Washington
My family just moved to the area, and Belisimos has kept us fed on multiple occasions when I didn’t have the energy to cook. I wanted to leave a review because not only is the food good and the value excellent, but the customer service is wonderful. I just placed an order, and the gentleman I spoke to on the phone was incredibly kind. Then I realized that every time we have had an interaction with someone at Belisimos, it has been pleasant, so I might as well leave a review.
… moreStacy Mehaffie
Usually have great reviews about New Windsor location but the last few (3) deliveries were not good. Food has been cold (hot subs and pizza) or luke warm. I understand things can get busy…but every delivery. Unfortunately this is the closest for delivery for us. Not always able to pick up
… moresteve saia
Have ordered from here for the last 6 years. Today I ordered a sandwich and found shards of metal in the bun. Will never order from here again. Thank god it wasn’t a sandwich for my 7 year old daughter. Check your food
… more … View more