Kristen Girard
We stumbled upon this place and I’m so happy we did. The pizza is comparable to new York city pizza. It’s so good, fresh, perfectly thin crust. We tried the garlic knots and teds special. Absolutely delicious. If you are in the area you have to try it! Great place. good people. Make sure to bring cash. They don’t take cards but they do have an atm.
… moreMuneerh M.
They have two kinds of pizza thick and thin, we ordered them thin one, but it’s not really thin and crust ( as Italian pizza’s), but the taste is average. The pasta is yummy, it’s a pink sauce. The garlic bread is good, and portions are big.
They serve a complementary bread and butter.
What I like here that you can customize the pasta and pizza.
I rated the service three stars because the waiter wasn’t helpful, and didn’t tell that they serve a complementary dish, because I ordered the garlic bread later, then they served the complementary dish, also the portions are big they didn’t give any recommendations, so the food was too much for two.
… moreNoelle Saladin
Great pizza, great view of the lake. Would have been even better sitting outside but it was a bit chilly. Would definitely come back for pizza again and want to try the garlic knots next time.
*Update 8/2024: Ordered the Philly cheese steak sub, would not recommend. The roll was fresh but the meat was pretty dry and other than salt it didn’t have much flavor. My husband ordered the lobster ravioli special which was delicious, he was nice enough to share!
… moreRosa Nardo
Food was fantastic! The garlic knots are a must! The sauce for the tortellini was delicious. Calzone was big and very cheesy! The atmosphere was quaint and service was prompt and polite. They only accept cash but have an atm on site.
… moreBrad Paradis
We need a quick bite to eat, so we swung into Nonna Fina’s for a pizza. The staff was fast and attentive. Pizza was actually pretty decent too.
A person in our party got the garlic knots as well and they were happy with those.
My only tip that you need to know is that they do not accept credit cards. It’s a cash only business.
… moreDana A. Higgins
We stopped here during Winter Carnival before going to hear some music. We were seated right away, as there were only a few other tables occupied. A few minutes later the waitress took our drink order and said she’d be back shortly. When the drinks arrived, we weren’t given the opportunity to order, but waited at least 20 minutes to order our meal. We ordered garlic knots which came 5-10 minutes later. They were tasty. no doubt. However about 30 minutes later, the waitress came back by and asked us what we ordered….not realizing whether or not she had submitted the order to the kitchen. She came back k and said “two minute warning “, which we took to mean our food was almost ready. However 5 minutes later she came back and apologized that they had a huge take-out order that was backing the kitchen up. We asked if it would be faster to just get some pizza at that point. She assured us our meals were almost ready. I was getting annoyed because at this point we were missing the music we planned on attending. After 10 more minutes, we got up, approached the bar where the waitress and, we assumed one of the kitchen staff were sitting. We asked what we owed them for the garlic knots. The waitress jumped up and said they were ready to bring our plates. At this point it had been well over an hour and we were done. She offered to box it and when we declined, the kitchen staff person gruffly said that the ticket just got put in 15 minutes ago…to which we replied “we’ve been here over an hour and we have other things to do”. He continued to argue the time frame with us as we walked out the door. They definitely will not get another chance with us!
… moreJoel Cummings
Excellent pizza. Cooked perfectly. Very fresh tasting sauce and other ingredients. Service was very friendly and attentive.
… moreAngelo Guercio
Steer Clear!! Chef Boyardee is better!!
They actually forgot the pepperoni on our pizza!! They charge for the marinara sauce to go with the garlic knots. We asked for glasses of water and the brought bottles of Aquafina at $2.85/bottle without telling us first. Steer Clear!!
… morePriscilla Wheeler
We ordered take out pizza and wings from here over Columbus Day weekend so can’t comment on the atmosphere. The drive to pick up the food was 20 minutes but given that the food tasted good even with that long a car ride. The issue is that we ordered a vegetarian pizza and another with chicken and when we got back to our rental discovered instead of the vegetable lovers pizza we had gotten a meat lovers pizza. I heard my daughter order it over the phone so I know she placed the correct order. Kind of an issue not to have a vegetarian option when we needed one and driving back down was really not an option at that time- they would be closing before it could be cooked and picked up. I will also say their prices for pizza are pretty high but more astounding was the chicken wings at ” fair market value” AND the blue cheese dressing is an extra $1.25! When did chicken wings start to get priced like fresh seafood?? We ordered 2 pizzas (large) which were 29.25 each, 2- 10 wing orders and a roast beef antipasto salad to the tune of $120!!!. It was good but it wasn’t that good and we didn’t have our needed vegetarian option.
… moreDayanah Cheikh
If you’re around lake placid… this place is worth the drive… pizzas are delicious… such a shame it was raining when we went cauz there is a lovely view on the lake
… more