Gretchen Langkawel
Pizza was really good! It’s a NY style pizza and one of the best meals we ate on the island. They were out of a couple toppings and drinks but that didn’t bother us. They only do calzones on certain days. There is limited seating but we found a table ok. They don’t do take out, just dine in. Highly recommended for good pizza!
… moreJon Lynch
Roadside pizzas with a great view just outside of the main Coral Bay strip.
Casual atmosphere with a nice simple cocktail menu and unique pizza options. Owned by a Boston Transplant who has been running this wonderful spot for 17 years.
Don’t get there too late, they can run out of pizza dough later in the evening, because they make them everyday.
… moreAndrew Hayman
Very yummy pizza. Great crust. One pie is good for 2-3 people. The view is phenomenal, but they could stand to have another table or two. Worth the short drive south from Coral Bay.
… moreEric Brammer
The night we went the owner and her son were both there working. We got there near closing so we got the opportunity to spend some time chatting with them. They’re both super friendly and great people!
They’re originally from Massachusetts and now they’re here in paradise making some amazingly delicious pizza! This might have been one of the cheapest places we ate in St. John and a contender for best tasting as well!
I will be dreaming of an amazing slice of pizza looking out at palm trees until I can get back and experience it again for myself!
… moreCharlie Mierzwa
Pizzabar was easily the best pizza on the island! Nice and crispy. I wouldn’t waste money on the salad as it’s just a lettuce with a little bit of cheese on top. Before coming here we read the reviews and noticed that the owner was called rude and racist, which is not true. We had a great conversation with her. It’s just that Boston aggression. Also don’t ask to take the pizza to go. It clearly says it everywhere, just have some awareness. Definitely worth coming from all around the island. Great atmosphere too!
… moreMichael Fuller
Great pizza place. Flavorful, lots of toppings to choose from. The view is also pretty tough to beat.
Pizza Adventures: Destination #125
… moreJohn Georgallas
The best pizza I’ve ever had.
You could put this place is North Dakota and I’d still say that – then you add the location and it’s hard to believe this place is real.
I’d fly all the way back just for this.
… moreScott Merrick
Arrived just after 5PM and was informed no take out allowed despite watching a guy walking out with 2 boxed Pizzas on his own. We usually have a larger group of ~10 people and the limited outdoor seating makes eating at the restaurant impractical at best. (We’ve struggled to get seating for 4-5 in past years) Food might be very good (it was the last time. we managed to visit ~4 years ago) , but if you have more than 4 or 5 people in your group, the odds are against you.
… moreMatthew Dawson
Wicked good pizza and solid cocktails! Our second trip here yielded the same great experience and I’ll add to my first review that the service was also friendly and very good. We had a pepperoni pizza this time with a painkiller and a margarita … all were outstanding!
… moreisabel ostrowski
A great little place with a cute, quaint atmosphere. The staff was great and the calzone was amazing.
It is cash only (or online payment)! So just a heads up there, and take out is a slight up charge! But it was worth it!
… more