Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 514 E Lucas St, Castalia, OH 44824
Phone: (419) 357-0838
Website: https://order.online/business/five-fourteen-pizza–treats-12812128
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Five Fourteen Pizza and Treats | Castalia OH – Facebook
Open till 9 PM. Give us a call at 419-357-0838! We have a daily special 2 large 1 topping, large cheesy bread, and 1 LB of boneless wings 39.99 2 pastas and a …
Five Fourteen Pizza & Treats 514 Lucas St E – Order Online
Five Fourteen Pizza & Treats. 514 Lucas St E, Castalia OH 44824-9600, United StatesOnline ordering hours: 11:00 AM – 8:55 …
Five Fourteen Pizza & Treats – Castalia – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Five Fourteen Pizza & Treats at 514 Lucas St E in Castalia. Order online and track your order live.
Reviews
Matthew Weaver
My wife and I decided to try this small pizza spot because they have vegan cheese and a gluten free crust option, and we were blown away by how good it was. The pizza came out perfectly cooked with plenty of toppings and amazing flavor. The owner stopped by our table to make sure everything was great and couldn’t have been more friendly. Easily a 10 out of 10 experience and we will absolutely be back!
… moreShannon Ott
I would like to make the best review. The gentleman Dalton so kindly handled a small hiccup with door dash. He went literally beyond what he should have. He was polite and on point. Attentive and spot on. The food is is hands down one of our newer truer favorites. The quality of the boneless are excellent! The pizza is amazing. Toppings-spot on. The subs are huge and loaded. The Alfredo is one of my favs.Thanks 514 you rock!!!
… moreNicole C
Recently ordered a pizza, garlic bread, and two slushies. Staff was friendly, pickup was easy through the drive through. Held the items on my lap for the drive home. When I lifted up the pizza box, I saw that it was soaked in grease and my lap was completely covered. While the food was average, the taste of the slushies were awful. We ordered blue razz & grape. We ended up tossing them after a few sips.
… moreTrevor E
We enjoyed Five Fourteen! A cute little ice cream and pizza shop.
There are some good family games on the mantle while you wait for your pizza. Put down the phone and play a game together!
We enjoyed the Hawaiian and the Chicken Bacon ranch pizza. We also ordered the garlic cheese bread, which had a good garlic salt hit!
Solid place, would come back!
… moreThere are some good family games on the mantle while you wait for your pizza. Put down the phone and play a game together!
We enjoyed the Hawaiian and the Chicken Bacon ranch pizza. We also ordered the garlic cheese bread, which had a good garlic salt hit!
Solid place, would come back!
Ignacio Fonte
The four pizzas we ordered were honestly some of the best we’ve had, especially the Chicken Club Pizza. The flavors were amazing, the crust was just right, and everyone enjoyed every slice. Definitely worth it
… moreBeyond Foodiee
Very unimpressive, Otto’s at least took the care to get the orders right. If you want to make a staple in this town I’ll humbly tell you that the workers you have now are very inconsistent and the pizza and subs are far from what you advertise. Half the time they don’t ever put the ingredients in. Please do better because in this town your business won’t last long with inconsistencies. Very appreciative village pizza is still right next door…
… moreJennifer Salsbury
What a wonderful and refreshing restaurant! Tony, who delivered our pizza was great. Even brought us paper plates! Would recommend!!!
… moreShelley Bias
I’m not sure what happened or if the changed cooks. I ordered a pizza tonight and it was HORRIBLE. It was not edible I hope they make some changes soon. I guess I will have to get pizza somewhere else. There cheese bread is still wonderful
… moreCassie Yoakum
I had placed an order pretty late not knowing they closed 10 minutes later, was told my food was being prepared and then got a call from DoorDash saying they were closed . I thought I was out $25 until one of the drivers that works there PERSONALLY delivered my pizza he delivers my moms pizza all the time now as well, 172837 stars for him !! I hope he sees this
… moreJazmine Bennett
What a great surprise to be able to enjoy non-dairy cheese on our pizza! Hard to find vegan options in this area and 514 was awesome! Thank you for having options! Also love the bubble tea!
… more