Robert Schuppert-McDonald
This was my second visit to this Italian cafe/restaurant for pizza. It was so tasty that I had to bring a friend with me second time around.
We ordered a medium pepperoni that was served piping hot with lots of fresh bubbling mozzarella! They make the sauce, pizza dough, etc. in house. Also, salads, wings, pasta, and sandwiches are on the menu. A 1/2 caesar is adequate when ordering other menu items, and full could be a dinner by itself or shared.
If you are a beer or wine drinker they serve both for alcohol beverages. Soft drinks are available.
… moreRicardo Ochoa
Food was good but not great! Buffalo wings are not the traditional wings, they are a mixture of sweet BBQ and hot sauce. This felt like a fast food pizza place, everything was served in to-go containers and we ate from paper plates (thin paper plates).
… moreRobyn Keith
Pizza Peel is great! They’re hand-tossed pizza crust is probably one of the best I’ve ever had! The toppings were generous and of great quality. The service and friendliness of the folks there is amazing. I will definitely be returning very soon! Thanks for such a great experience.
… moreShannon
I really wanted to love this place but it was definitely below average. First off, the X Large pizza was not very extra large and it was dry and lacked flavor. It reminded me of Chuck e Cheese or a rollerskating rink pizza. We also ordered a Calzone and it was lukewarm, mostly dough and the marinara paste they provided as a Dipping sauce was completely underwhelming. I would not return, nor would I recommend!
… moreCharlene Araújo Jones
Just had their pizza yesterday for the first time: DELICIOUS! One of the best crusts I have ever had. Very light and crunchy. I felt like eating the whole pizza on my own. It was that good. I had a pepperoni pizza. I’ll definitely come back for more.
… moreBlake Browning
This place is amazing! The new ownership has completely fixed the problems of the owners before. It is so nice to see hardworking and compassionate owners, who understand how to make a good pizza. The flavor is so rich and the crust is some of the best I’ve ever had! Come visit and support your local businesses during these harsh times.
… moreJohn Spratley
I have never had an issue with this great pizza until tonight. The owner or manager Chad was rude cussing at me because I wanted to cancel an order. Saying he is losing money. Well after ordering from them and having approximately 15 time in the past never having an issue until tonight. This guy needs to grow up if he is the owner or manager this is not someone I will be taking my business to again. Never order from pizza peel if you want respect and your food. If i could I would give this a zero
… moreLisset Acoeda
I ordered the family special, was disappointed at how small the pizza was for an extra large. It was at best a large/medium. It also was insanely chewy, it hurt my jaw from chewing so much. I used to like this pizza place but don’t think we’ll be ordering from here again soon. Didn’t seem worth the prize for the size and quality.
… moreKevin Bauer
Pizza was close to naked. Toppings were seriously lacking! Ordered sausage, olive and onion pizza and there was almost not evidence of any of the toppings. The pizza was hot but seemed like there has been a real effort to use fewer ingredients. This is disappointing as the quality has diminished! Will I try again? Jury is out on that!
… moreMarissa Woodard
I’ve had take out here several times during the pandemic and am always pleased! Such a great value for such great food! The owner is always very kind and helpful! Food is always hot upon pickup and my orders have always been accurate! Thanks Pizza Peel!!!!
… more