Jo Jo
Went for the first time today after seen all the photos and reviews of this place. The reason I went and tried this place was knowing it was 100% Italian owners and coming from New York my self I had to try it. I was expecting the pizza display to be full of all different pizzas like one of the photos I saw but they were not. Maybe is slow on Sundays . The guy that served me was really nice, the place was really clean. I order 2 plain slices because I wanted to taste the sauce on this pizza, I think is the only way you can tasted then order one with toppings next time. Everyone sauce is different here in Vineland. Some have more garlic some are sweeter but this one you can taste the tomato tomato in it. It was delicious. I’m a garlic lover maybe that’s why I thought it need it a little bit more garlic but the flavor was there. I ask for blue cheese on the side but they didn’t have blue cheese they only had ranch. It was odd but then I realized after seen the menu they don’t sell wings so it was understandable. I had wings at home so disregard the photo with the wings. . ALSO I do Uber Eats sometimes and can see how the restaurants are inside. This one is definitely clean not like some I’ve been. Overall I’m definitely will go back and try other things.
… moreTina Tierno
Beautifully redone building. It’s clean and spacious.
If you like a crispy well done crust, like I do, then this place is for you! Crispy down to the last bite
However, the sauce wasn’t the best. Lacked flavor, needed more garlic and basil.
Overall, I would revisit this establishment, possibly order a different variation pizza.
… moreKyle Encarnacion
Ive had a lot of pizza in my time and this place has some good sauce! 90% of the building is the kitchen so id hope there’s good pizza and it was. They had all the condiments that were necessary and it’s in a great location. The outside seating is great and shaded. Overall, good pizza and this place deserves to thrive.
… moreJodi Cook
Ron and Ryan took very good care of us. They made a special order grandma-style pie (chicken, long hots, pub sauce) for us and it was amazing! Wait was only 15 mins and they walked the pie out to my car for me. Ingredients were so fresh and the dough was light and fluffy. One of the best pizza joints in town. Can’t wait for my next get together with friends to try something new!
… moreRich Fresella
1st time ordering a full party tray!!!! It was amazing! The food was delicious and fresh and a big hit!! All my guests loved it. We will definitely be ordering again! We had many compliments and they all went to you!
… moreAero Smith
Absolutely Effin good pizza. We are from Delaware always looking for a good pizza spot. This place is a must visit. The sauce is amazing. Crust has a great crunch. The owner is a really cool guy.
… moreJosh
The New York Slice was fascinating! Tastes great and they have all natural ingredients. My only problem is: on our first visit they did a half margarita and half new york style pie for us and it was amazing! On our second visit they told us that they could not do a half and half. I know of other local pizza places that can do more than 1 topping choice on a large pie so it may be a deciding factor for us if we continue here or not. We love more than 1 topping choice in this house hold for 1 large pizza. That is the only reason I removed a star.
… moreGianna Caine
Tried their pizza for the first time today with my family. Got the party tray. AMAZING pizza. I love the sauce with the sweet flavor, and the crust has that great crisp factor! This place is to die for , and I will be coming back!!!
… moreNadia Warner
walking home on cold night from work, saw a sign for this spot in the cut. Very good service, sweet as well. since it was late at night he offered me extra at no price. Which was very appreciated after a long day of work.
… moreElizabeth Espinal (Lipstick Liz)
This is an Effin Good Pizza. Got the Porkie Pie with cherry peppers best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Will definitely be back. Thank You
… more