Address and Contact Information
Address: 55 Surrey Cir, Shirley, NY 11967
Phone: (631) 772-4394
Website: https://www.jcpizzeriany.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
M&M Pizzeria – Shirley, NY Restaurant | Menu + Delivery | Seamless
Order with Seamless to support your local restaurants! View menu and reviews for M&M Pizzeria in Shirley, plus popular items & reviews. Delivery or takeout!
M&M Pizzeria supports officer’s family fundraiser | Shirley, NY
PIZZA WITH A PURPOSE! At M&M Pizzeria, we are honored to participate in the Long Island Pizza Strong fundraising event on February 25th, …
#superbowlsunday #foodiegram #shirley #mastic #masticbeach
Photo by Pizza M&M on February 02, 2026. May be a … Pizzeria is now… … Shirley, NY Alipricesubjectappicabletve pricessubjecta applicable Follow Us: @MMPizeria.
Reviews
Gio Lopez
Everything was wonderful. The pizza was flawlessly prepared, and you could really tell the ingredients were fresh. Truly delicious.
… moreM. Murran
Food was mediocre. Girl on the phone could barely complete a sentence. Tried to order a special advertised and they over charged me $4 and forgot my soda. The guy brought my order out to me and when I got home I realized we didn’t have the soda. Called and asked them to put a credit on my account, they told me this wasn’t Marshall’s. But clearly had an account based on my phone number with a stored address.
UPDATE: now this guy is telling me to call lol I did that already you had an opportunity to make it right, you didn’t. You’re talking about an online special that says 6 chicken wings and when you click it the special changes to 6 zeppoles, so it’s impossible to order online lol. I referenced all this in the initial call and said the price, if something was different then that was time to let me know. And idk how ur talking about something for free when you forgot my soda lol. A joke. Get a grip and just do better.
… moreUPDATE: now this guy is telling me to call lol I did that already you had an opportunity to make it right, you didn’t. You’re talking about an online special that says 6 chicken wings and when you click it the special changes to 6 zeppoles, so it’s impossible to order online lol. I referenced all this in the initial call and said the price, if something was different then that was time to let me know. And idk how ur talking about something for free when you forgot my soda lol. A joke. Get a grip and just do better.
brittany heckman
Latley the pizzas have been amazing. Today.. a $15 chicken CAESAR salad… lettuce was barley cut, chicken wasn’t cut at all & I was given Italian dressing and honey mustard … I just don’t get it. Also have no clue what the red crap is
… moreGloria Castillo
This was my first time coming to NY and I had heard so many comments about this pizza joint and I definitely had to give it a try. The pizza was beyond delicious. I tried their Hawaiian Pizza and the Pepperoni with Chesse and the crust was perfect and crunchy and I can’t leave behind their Cesar Salad and wings . The service was amazing . If you are visiting NY or are in town please stop by and taste their food and you won’t be disappointed as they also have other options on their menu.
… moreKelly Dilluvio
This was my first time ordering and I won’t go back. I ordered an Eggplant Parm hero. The eggplant was breaded but inside was similar to soft pliable plastic strips of the same size and they were not chewable. As an eggplant lover I can say, I’ve never seen eggplant look like or taste like this.
… moreLucy R.
My partner has lived in the area for over 15 years and said the new owner definitely does pizza better. She was not lying. I believe the young man who helped us was the owner. He have owner vibes lol. Best pizza in Mastic hands down!
… moreEric Soto
This was one of the worst pizzas I’ve ever had. $50 for bread that barely had any sauce, or cheese, or the sausage that I ordered.
… moreCesar Rivas
The best pizza I’ve ever eaten! Perfectly cooked dough, fresh ingredients, not at all oily like some I’ve tried. The service is excellent, friendly, and if you have any questions about the products, they’re happy to help. I’ll be back soon!
… moreFrancis Reynolds
Every time we order from here it’s amazing. The MOST consistently AMAZING pizza place around here. I usually get the chicken all’s vodka pizza and it’s incredible. Tonight I got chicken parm with vodka sauce and it was incredible.
… moreTim Gagnon
Made a delivery in the area. I wanted pizza. Tasty pizza and conversation with i think the owner.
… more