Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Regional, family-friendly chain with a big menu of pizza, sandwiches & more, ordered at the counter.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4 Colfax Ave, Pompton Lakes, NJ 07442
Phone: (973) 616-8212
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Nicky G’s Pizzeria & Restaurant – Pompton Lakes, NJ – 4 Colfax Ave …
Get 5% off your pizza delivery order – View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Nicky G’s Pizzeria & Restaurant in Pompton Lakes, NJ.
Nicky G’s Pizzeria | Pompton Lakes NJ – Facebook
Nicky G’s Pizzeria, Pompton Lakes. 693 likes · 143 were here. OPEN 6 DAYS A WEEK FOR FAST PICK-UP CALL DINE-IN , TAKE OUT, DELIVERY, CATERING CORPORATE…
Nicky G’s Pizzeria & Restaurant – View Menu & Order Online – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Pompton Lakes, NJ! Nicky G’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive …
Reviews
Veronica Wright
Amazing Owner!!! I don’t order pizza anywhere else!! Also, he catered my Mom’s Memorial and did such an amazing job….I cannot say enough good things about Nicky G’s
… moreCal Delano
Nicky G’s has the best garlic knots around. If you like soft chewy seasoned garlic knots in a garlic olive oil buttery sauce you will love these. Knot for those who like the hard stuff dry type
Portions are always great and price is reasonable. Great local place to get take out. Enjoy!
… morePortions are always great and price is reasonable. Great local place to get take out. Enjoy!
Kristen
Buffalo wings, tuna wrap on whole wheat, plain pie (asked for it well done)
Everything was perfect!
My boyfriend and his friends wanted wings and a pie, I wanted to eat something a little more substantial, I’m happy the tuna wrap was an option!
The tuna wrap was delicious and flavorful.
The wings were nice and spicy.
The pizza was definitely impressive, asking for it cooked well done made the bottom crusty perfectly crunchy.
Yummy!
… moreEverything was perfect!
My boyfriend and his friends wanted wings and a pie, I wanted to eat something a little more substantial, I’m happy the tuna wrap was an option!
The tuna wrap was delicious and flavorful.
The wings were nice and spicy.
The pizza was definitely impressive, asking for it cooked well done made the bottom crusty perfectly crunchy.
Yummy!
Y C
This place is located in downtown and its small restaurant with big taste. I’ve gotten some hot wings and pizza and it was good. The hot wings where hot idk if they have different levels. But tasty and pizza was full of flavor and nice crispy crust.
… moremc070182 Mcnulty
Ordered a sicilian pie. This is what i received. I called to complain and the guy said they will come pick up this pie and i can wait again. Then he said i ordered pepperoni. Pepperoni didnt even come into the conversation. And i gave a $10 tip cause the driver said he didnt carry cash. Terrible service. I did not want it for free but my friend had taken a slice when we called you. You said i wanted something different and thats not what happened
… moreNelson Mercado
Great local pizza spot, and they have beef patties as well, which were delicious!
… moreRichard S
Search and ye shall find!
Ever since moving to Pompton Lakes I’ve been searching for the best pizza around me and I’ve tried a bunch to much disappointment. Either the sauce isn’t right, the crust is too soft/hard or the cheese is just right. But Nicky’s hits the nail on the head and knocks it out of the park.
I ordered a large extra cheese and it came to only $16.65 and I gotta say I eat almost the whole pie to myself every time I order. The balance of everything is just perfect and if you love pizza then this is the place for you!
… moreEver since moving to Pompton Lakes I’ve been searching for the best pizza around me and I’ve tried a bunch to much disappointment. Either the sauce isn’t right, the crust is too soft/hard or the cheese is just right. But Nicky’s hits the nail on the head and knocks it out of the park.
I ordered a large extra cheese and it came to only $16.65 and I gotta say I eat almost the whole pie to myself every time I order. The balance of everything is just perfect and if you love pizza then this is the place for you!
Arber B
Nicky G’s is an absolute gem! From the moment you walk in, the inviting atmosphere sets the perfect tone for a great meal. The pizza is outstanding—crispy crust, fresh ingredients, and a perfect balance of flavors. The grandma is a must-try, bursting with basil and mozzarella goodness. The staff is friendly and attentive, making you feel right at home. Plus, their unique toppings and daily specials keep me coming back for more. If you’re looking for delicious pizza and a warm vibe, Nicky G’s is the place to be! Highly recommend!
… moreRennie Jacob
Unfortunately due to getting a fire call on the way home with all this food wife and I ended up eating it cold which was still very good! Will definitely try again and hope to get it home hot!!!
… moreNick Grivas
As a Nick G myself I feel I cannot give an unbiased review of such a wonderfully named place. The pizza was good and quick and manacotti made me happy.
… more