Social Profile: 
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1136 New Castle Rd, Prospect, PA 16052
Phone: (724) 865-9713
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Shmily’s | Prospect PA – Facebook
Shmily’s, Prospect. 1608 likes · 2 talking about this · 386 were here. Great food and the best ice cream in Butler!!
Shmily’s, 1136 New Castle Rd, Prospect, PA 16052, US – MapQuest
Get more information for Shmily’s in Prospect, PA. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Shmily’s | Prospect PA – Facebook
Shmily’s, Prospect. 1597 likes · 386 were here. Great food and the best ice cream in Butler!!
Reviews
Dawn Testa
Always great service and great ice cream too. They need a garbage can outside though. I included better close up of menu items for ice cream selections
… moreLisa Ball
Bought a pistachio soft serve, medium. Same size as a small. Then walking out the door the entire ice cream plopped on the floor because it was half melted as soon as I got it. Not happy.
… moreColleen Deems
Says ur open today til 8 come from grove city area and u are not open!!get it right!!
… moreAlida Billings (Melo)
Ice cream is always good and I love their soft serve in a chocolate sprinkle dipped waffle cone . The employees are always very friendly and efficient, and I stop at this place every time I drive by it. 10/10 would highly recommend
… moreDavid Frederick
A haven for the weary traveler, get a foot long dog and an ice cream wash it down with. Folks were really nice there!
… moreSharon Savage
We enjoyed yummy burgers and fries. They were perfect after our hike. The milk shakes were perfection, especially the hot fudge My daughter said her banana shake was delicious. Our order was prepared quickly and everything exceeded our expectations. The staff were kind and courteous.
… moreMat M
Celiac disease people beware… NOT GLUTEN FRIENDLY AT ALL.. Watched a young lady put ice cream out of a cone back in a hard ice cream container. When I questioned her about it. Got a major attitude from her and was told what does it matter. Told her wife has gluten allergy. Well, eat something else then. With her attitude, definitely not gonna trust that hasn’t happened before. Sorry can’t risk being severely sick. More then likely won’t be returning.
… moreChris Trimble
They have changed their ice cream recipe this year. It is not near the quality of the past years. Have gone twice hoping the first time was a fluke but sadly was not. The second time the soft serve was so soft only made it out the door when it fell to the ground. Mine was the third one to fall while we were there. They need to return to the great ice cream they have had the past years.
… moreIrelynd M
It was great, they had both hard and soft ice cream, which I very much appreciated and everything tasted great. They even had dairy free options. All in all a great place to stop. The only reason I put four stars was because of the location, but that’s it
… morecrazy rabbit lady
The ice cream was good. The turkey club was good. The rest of the food was lacking. The chicken tender meal was 3 pieces the size of chicken nuggets. The hot dog was black, and the person taking the order over charged us. Came to our table and admitted she over charged us but then didn’t offer a refund . Will stop again for ice cream if we are passing through but probably won’t eat here again.
… more