Rosanne Cross
Never was ever here and will be my first and last time. Walking into pizza place I first see all the plants they have displayed are dead. Tables were not clean. Garbage near the door. We did order because we were very tired and hungry. Food took a bit to get to us. But surprisingly was good. We stayed because of the foot traffic of people coming in for takeout. So I would think people should just stick to take out.
… moreBrenda Buckley
Wow just wow!! If you haven’t tried them yet, you really should. We ordered on a Monday night 8 pm and 20 mins later got some delicious hot pizza. So hot, it burns your tongue and so fresh, it’s like right out of the oven. It’s a thicker crust pizza and the crust kinda reminds me of subway bread.
Delivery was quick, less time than estimated, Their prices are fair and they’re friendly. Delivery driver wasn’t sure which unit was mine and called right away and I met her outside. 5 stars great place. Will order from again without a doubt.
… moreMike Dotson
Wow I glad I stop the young woman and the young man who made the pie me and my niece got was out of the world good the owner should be proud to have these to younger people working there the sausage pizza was made just rite both employees should be proud and the owner should be even prouder that both these people work as they do thank you both for your kindness
… moretony hanscom
I placed an online order Saturday November 1 2025. Your GoEat24 company that collects your payments took my money. I went to pick up my food and you were closed for renovations? How does that happen? Think you should notify them that your not even open. I’m pissed drove all there to get my food, so disappointed in you!
… moreSean Moran
If this place is gonna be anything like their Waterbury location, they’ll probably be out of business in a year!! Lots of other good pizza places around!! Just from the Waterbury reviews, I would never eat here!!
… moreKevin Deninger
The owner was smoking a cigarette while making the food. I like the char on pizza, but I don’t want it to be from cigarette ash.
… moreTobias Smith
Good pie to say the least. The new owners are a great fit for the pizza house. I fought a pizza war who has the best pizza in Wallingford. Greek style of course is my favorite
… morePerry
Just ask him to make you something special!!!
He does it at next LEVEL!!!!
Regrettably they have closed
New owners and looking forward to see how they turnout
… moreZues Goose
Terrible place to visit first time there I order an extra large pizza and got only 8 slices. Walked out very confused. When I called in to let them know what I paid for they were very rude. Then when I walked In to get a full refund I had all my food there I only ate one slice and my son ate one slice and we threw the rest of our slice out because we didn’t like it. They started to refuse an 80$ refund. Yelling and trying to give me a gift card instead of a refund. Very sketchy and unprofessional place. I will never go back and I warn anyone to never go there. The owners brother was on the register.
… moreStefa Rose
So disappointed!! We have been ordering Oakdale Pizza for years and did not know they had sold the restaurant. When placing the order we were a little confused as it wasn’t a familiar voice who answered the phone, but thought maybe they hired some extra help. It was quite the surprise when I walked in and picked up my order.
It is not the same. Not even close. The prices have increased and the quality has decreased. The sauce tastes completely different. They put so much sauce on the pizza that globs of it were coming out of every bite. They barely put any toppings on the small pizza and every slice was floppy and soggy.
I wish I could have gotten the chance to say goodbye to the previous owners and order their pizza one last time before they sold it.
I do NOT recommend the New Oakdale Pizza.
… more