Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Classic Italian & American eats, plus homestyle breakfasts, served in a casual cafe with a lounge.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 113 N Chicago Ave, South Milwaukee, WI 53172
Phone: (414) 856-9020
Website: http://orderpaisanos.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Paisano’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria – South Milwaukee, WI
113 North Chicago Avenue, South Milwaukee, WI 53172 Order Online Take us to go! Your favorite food is just a click away. Order delivery and takeout.
PAISANO’S ITALIAN RESTAURANT – SOUTH MILWAUKEE, WI …
Online ordering menu for PAISANO’S ITALIAN RESTAURANT. Paisano’s Italian Restaurant offers a diverse menu that goes beyond traditional Italian fare, …
Paisano’s | South Milwaukee WI – Facebook
Paisano’s, South Milwaukee. 3730 likes · 43 talking about this · 3345 were here. We’re a family owned Italian restaurant and lounge.
Reviews
M K
It was okay (3.5 stars if that were possible). There was no wait and we got dat right away.
Food looked really good. Soup (clam chowder and chicken noodle) were pretty good. Garlic bread that came with our dinners was really good. We ordered chicken parm with pasta, the red sauce had a funky dark taste to it. Maybe it just isn’t what I’m used to. Chicken was good. We also got a fish fry (cod) and French dip (we added cheese….doesn’tcome with). Both were okay. Fries were good but ranch was not good. Not homemade. Maybe a large batch generic. So if you care about that skip it.
Huge portions. Lots of leftovers.
Service was okay but the waitresses seemed to be fighting amongst themselves and there points of confusion. Whose tables were whose and stuff like that.
However, we seemed to be the newbies there. Most everyone who came in seemed to know someone working or even know other guests. Local and family run vibe which we appreciate.
All in all okay. Just wasn’t something i would crave or be memorable to try agin. I am not sure if we will be back but worth a try.
… moreFood looked really good. Soup (clam chowder and chicken noodle) were pretty good. Garlic bread that came with our dinners was really good. We ordered chicken parm with pasta, the red sauce had a funky dark taste to it. Maybe it just isn’t what I’m used to. Chicken was good. We also got a fish fry (cod) and French dip (we added cheese….doesn’tcome with). Both were okay. Fries were good but ranch was not good. Not homemade. Maybe a large batch generic. So if you care about that skip it.
Huge portions. Lots of leftovers.
Service was okay but the waitresses seemed to be fighting amongst themselves and there points of confusion. Whose tables were whose and stuff like that.
However, we seemed to be the newbies there. Most everyone who came in seemed to know someone working or even know other guests. Local and family run vibe which we appreciate.
All in all okay. Just wasn’t something i would crave or be memorable to try agin. I am not sure if we will be back but worth a try.
David Mawyin
Went here over the summer. Sat down and had the chicken parm. Pasta was cooked perfectly, and the chicken was nice and crispy. There was a little too much sauce but it tasted great so not too bad to have. Garlic bread helped sop it up!
Recommend as a stop if you’re arriving at the airport, it’s close by.
… moreRecommend as a stop if you’re arriving at the airport, it’s close by.
Donte Gillespie
I don’t live in Milwaukee, but I frequent the area often for work, and I happened to be on that side of town and had a taste for pizza. Never saw the place before, never heard of it, but looked at the reviews which looked pretty good so I thought I’d take a chance. Once my wife and I looked at the menu, we got distracted by the meals because they looked really good. Decided on a couple of platters and spicy garlic buffalo wings, and everything was fantastic! Some of the best soups we’ve had in a long time, and our waitress Lilith was a sweetheart.
Then we got back home to Illinois and realized that my wife left her purse! Of course she called and they held it for her.
I guess we’ll have to come back for for that Pizza (and more wings)
… moreThen we got back home to Illinois and realized that my wife left her purse! Of course she called and they held it for her.
I guess we’ll have to come back for for that Pizza (and more wings)
Benjamin Khachaturian
What an amazing local restaurant with HUGE portions that will leave you with lunch for the next week! I’ve driven by Paisano’s 1000x times and finally decided to go. THIS is your sign to do the same! We had the beef pasta and baked mastaccioli. We loved the included salad and pudding for dessert too. The only thing friendlier than Josse, Fred and the entire staff is their friendly pricing. This is a local gem. We can’t wait to come back and bring our friends. We’re sure glad we decided to give Paisano’s a try. Now it’s one of our favorite spots in Milwaukee. ☺️
… moreYulie Guerrero
We stopped in on a Sunday afternoon and I was surprised that it was not busy at all. This place is so cute and the service from the start was on point!! Josie was our server and she was so nice and attentive. We ordered lasagna, garlic parm wings and their cheesy garlic bread and it was sooo good! I will definitely be coming here more often and highly recommend it!
… moreEric Michalski
Came here for lunch and thought the food was pretty good! I’ve ordered takeout pizza from here which I’ve always enjoyed, but it was my first time eating inside. I got the chicken parm sandwich and it met my expectation.
The three stars is due to the vibe inside, I just wasn’t a fan. I think that the whole place could use a major upgrade. Overall, I’ll probably continue to order takeout from time to time, but won’t be back inside.
… moreThe three stars is due to the vibe inside, I just wasn’t a fan. I think that the whole place could use a major upgrade. Overall, I’ll probably continue to order takeout from time to time, but won’t be back inside.
Tamia Spitaletto
Pizza is great!!! The salad that comes with dinners wouldn’t feed a mouse it’s so small. The Alfredo sauce is terrible, water on the plate from not draining the pasta. The shrimp that is for the shrimp and crab ravioli is literally from a bag and is not even cooked just put on your plate and heated. The chicken is like cardboard and dry with the fettuccine Alfredo. Went there for the first time to celebrate a birthday and they have no dessert!!!!!. They do serve pudding with every meal. The pudding is from a can we were told by our server. When we asked the server what meal she would pick when we were trying to choose between two meals, the server told us “neither!” She said she doesn’t eat the food at the restaurant. When we told them we were there celebrating a birthday and were hoping for a dessert after dinner the server never said a word. Not sorry not happy birthday.
We were a little taken back when the server said the pudding was from a can and she doesn’t eat the food at restaurant. We told the waitress that it was our first time here and hope the rest of the food was homemade and not from a can. She told us their mashed potatoes were from a box but most of the other food was homemade. We should have walked out then but we were starving. We ordered A glass of Shiraz wine which tasted like vinegar and the glass we were served was cracked and had to ask for a new glass.
The portions are big. I had the bake lemon pepper fish with a baked potato (didn’t want box mashed potatoes) and my dinner was good. I have been told by a few people to try this place and was very excited to try a new Italian restaurant but I don’t think I would come back even though the pizza and baked fish were good. Due to the fact of the weird service and so much left to be desired we wouldn’t recommend this place. Sad cause we were hoping for much better experience ! I love to leave great responses and tell others how amazing places are but I can’t here.
… moreWe were a little taken back when the server said the pudding was from a can and she doesn’t eat the food at restaurant. We told the waitress that it was our first time here and hope the rest of the food was homemade and not from a can. She told us their mashed potatoes were from a box but most of the other food was homemade. We should have walked out then but we were starving. We ordered A glass of Shiraz wine which tasted like vinegar and the glass we were served was cracked and had to ask for a new glass.
The portions are big. I had the bake lemon pepper fish with a baked potato (didn’t want box mashed potatoes) and my dinner was good. I have been told by a few people to try this place and was very excited to try a new Italian restaurant but I don’t think I would come back even though the pizza and baked fish were good. Due to the fact of the weird service and so much left to be desired we wouldn’t recommend this place. Sad cause we were hoping for much better experience ! I love to leave great responses and tell others how amazing places are but I can’t here.
Grace A
Somewhere you can walk to – where its open like it says on Google and you can be messy walking in…and walking out.
Chicken noodle soup amd pan pizza … sausage onion garlic and giardineria.
Thanks guys
… moreChicken noodle soup amd pan pizza … sausage onion garlic and giardineria.
Thanks guys
Mary Weber
Pizza is amazing, I’ve ordered for takeout for some time, but recently visited with a group of friends including one individual who is disabled and I was so impressed by how the staff went out of their way to accommodate his special needs. Our meals were hot, fresh and delicious. The baked cheese garlic bread is addicting. Our experience was so good that a few weeks later the same group of friends insisted we go back and, one again it was a great experience.
… moreSarah Zarling
I’m an Uber driver around Milwaukee and I love trying new places on my breaks. I thought it was great! The manager made it a point to come out and talk to me and see how I’m doing. Food is good. Inside is nice. And the garlic bread is as serious as it looks.
… more