Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Main Street Pizzeria | Youngstown NY – Facebook
New Special!! Order 3 Large subs and get a FREE French Fry! Call today! 716-745-1130 · No photo description available. Tom Keefer …
Main Street Pizzeria: Your Go-To Spot for Delicious Pizza in …
Main Street Pizzeria is a delightful gem located at 311 Main St, Youngstown, NY, just a stone’s throw from the historical Old Fort Niagara. With a cozy …
Main Street Pizzeria (@_mainstreetpizza) · Youngstown, NY
1.4K+ followers · 142 posts · Youngstown’s Pizzeria (est. 2001) (716) 745-1130.
Reviews
Kristen Acome
Got a really good fish fry delivered but it was missing tartar sauce. Just wish they’d have mentioned that so I could have decided whether to still order or not. Nice staff. Yummy food. Quick delivery too.
… moreRōbi Ventures (Rōbi Ventures)
This is a place that shouldn’t be missed if your in the area visiting. Don’t let the fact that it’s on the other side of a gas station steer you away. The food is delicious. The guys were super nice that helped us with our orders. We ordered a Calzone and a Stromboli and each of us had leftovers for another meal each.
… moreMelanie Hudson
Got a cheese slice and drink for just $3!!! What a crazy deal! Pizza was really good and still can’t believe how cheap it was. Stopped by on a Sunday during lunch and service was very quick. Definitely coming back!
… moreRobert Ruiz
I absolutely love the steak subs, i get one a week. They use good quality sandwich steak, also quality sub rolls. I work in a restaurant as a grill cook so im very picky about my food. I will continue to look forward to my weekly sub. I highly recommend this local gem.
… moreGreg H.
In the vast ocean of Western New York pizzerias, Main Street Pizzeria stands as a lighthouse for those of us questing for that perfect slice. The secret to their standout pizza? It begins with the crust – golden, with just the right crunch to softness ratio, it’s a foundation strong enough to bear the weight of any topping yet delicate enough to meld seamlessly into every bite. The staff at Main Street Pizzeria are not just employees; they are custodians of quality, ensuring every visit is as welcoming as it is satisfying. Add to this mix their commitment to quality ingredients, and you have a recipe for success. Whether it’s the vibrant sauce, the perfectly melted cheese, or the fresh, flavorful toppings, Main Street Pizzeria knows that quality is not just an ingredient but the main ingredient. From the moment you step in, it’s clear: this isn’t just another pizza place. It’s a community staple where every slice is crafted with care, and every visit leaves you planning the next. If you’re in search of a great pizza, look no further. Main Street Pizzeria doesn’t just make pizza; they make memories, one slice at a time.
… moreJud N
It’s the only pizza shop in Youngstown New York they have a large variety of different foods I’ve never gotten anything bad from there I eat there all the time or get food from there all the time.
… moreFrank DeChellis
We ended up here because we were early for a memorial service and it was the only place we found after driving for 10 minutes. The guys there were friendly and efficient. Menu was extensive. The place had two tables and it had an old American takeout look, if that’s a thing. The view of the Niagara River is very nice. The most important part is the food was awesome! We had some slices and a small greek salad with chicken. The greek salad was enough for 3 people and the cheese and pepperoni on the pizza were high quality. It’s not far from the Queenston-Lewiston bridge and this place is definitely worth checking out. I know we don’t cross much anymore, but if you do, go have lunch there.
… moreColin O’Brien
Family gets a large pepperoni here every Sunday. Pizza’s always good, guys working there are friendly, and the pickup is quick and easy.
… moreRachel Bernardi
We come from Ohio to see Niagara falls and surroundings many times through the year….and this is a spot that we have to stop at. Every. Single. Time.
I actually was looking for a bathroom when we found it. (Of which they don’t have public restroom, so dont go there for that.)
But anywho…. After I almost wet myself… We walked the rest of the way to old fort Niagara and we needed a drink…..
And BAM there it was. Pizza by the slice. Great pizza, all kinds to choose from…. Perfect spot
So now it has become a spot that we have to go to…. Whether we head north or not, we still have to drive the 20 min from Niagara and grab a few slices .
Stop on by and grab a slice, they must be popular. Each time we go there, they are steady.
… moreI actually was looking for a bathroom when we found it. (Of which they don’t have public restroom, so dont go there for that.)
But anywho…. After I almost wet myself… We walked the rest of the way to old fort Niagara and we needed a drink…..
And BAM there it was. Pizza by the slice. Great pizza, all kinds to choose from…. Perfect spot
So now it has become a spot that we have to go to…. Whether we head north or not, we still have to drive the 20 min from Niagara and grab a few slices .
Stop on by and grab a slice, they must be popular. Each time we go there, they are steady.
Taylor Smith
Excellent pizza from a small shop just outside the fort. We came through on a Sunday afternoon and it was pretty quiet. The owner was very helpful and patient as we worked through what to order for our family with kids. We took the pizza across the street to the park and had a nice picnic, and it was top notch. Couldn’t ask for better for a Sunday afternoon drive north of Niagara.
… more