Matthew Staninger
The online ordering was simple. Salad was fresh, flavorful, and crispy. The bread sticks have a great texture and were well-seasoned. I thought their pizza sauce paired very well as a dip. The pizza was also very good! I was a little skeptical at $26 for a 16″ 3 topping, but I’m happy to say it was well worth the price. Hey Now will be added as a regular pizza option!
… moreRegina Ayat
Was pleasantly surprised! This place keeps it interesting. Tasty choices, a few unusual pies, w/o getting too out there & old favorite standbys keeps everyone in my family happy.
I love the local focus with the art & family vibe. I think they have occasional music & other events. From talking to the owner it seems like they’d like to do more in the future which would be great in this kinda sleepy place we call home. Also great to have a decent delivery option right in the center of Beech Grove.
I wish I had a spot like this to hang out at when I was a teenager. Classic pizzaria vibe w/ just enough of a modern touch. Decent sized patio for summer hangs. Really happy to have a pizza place in the old Ball Park location, seems as if the new owners are family friends of the old owners which is a nice way to keep it local too.
… moreIsaac Daniel
One of my favorite pizza spots in Indy because of their fresh hand-tossed pizzas. My family and I can’t get enough of them. We love their breadsticks and everything about this local pizza place. The team now knows me by name because I order so much and I love chitchatting with them while they make my pizza. Great place to dine-in or get for carryout. They deliver too!
… moreGobigorangeut1
Got a half cheese half pep hand tossed and a hand tossed Robbie girl. Usually not huge on chicken on a pizza but the chicken was the thin sliced kind so it was good. The Robbie girl is like a Cajun meets Italian type of pizza and was really good. The star of the show was the breadsticks though, some of my favorite around Indy. Definitely will try again
… moreJosh Miller
Amazing pizza. Amazing ingredients. Great dough and cheese pulls. The staff is phenomenal.
Do not sleep on the Robbie Girl or Carnivores Unite. Both elite specialty pizzas.
Can’t wait to keep coming back.
… moreRachel Ann
I wanted to leave a review from before when I visited the restaurant with my daughter and her uncle for the first time. The hot honey pizza was delicious, I wanted to eat the whole pizza by myself lol definitely worth the cost and as my brother said, “The taste is very similar to Me-N-Ed’s in California.” The crust was thick and fluffy, the sauce was spot on and the pepperoni slices had a nice char and not greasy at all. It didn’t leave a funky taste in my mouth like Papa John’s would. I definitely want to visit again! The owner was also friendly and let my daughter have the spiderman coloring book that she found great joy from. Highly recommend! 🙂
… moreDan Sweeney
Ties/beats Ale Emporium for my favorite pizza in town. Friendly owner, free arcade game cabinet, beer available. We got the Home Run (supreme) and barely finished half of it
… moreKendra Ferrero
Best Hidden gems in Beechgrove! Great food, Great service great location nice clean atmosphere!! 5- STARS
… moreSarah Pastrick
I have become obsessed with this pizza!! It is traditional nostalgic pizza loaded with toppings and the best breadsticks I think I have ever had!!! 10/10 would recommend.
… moreVanessa Pettyjohn
Pizza here is the bomb. PERIOD. Also the vibe here is so aesthetic. I stumbled across this shop while taking my godsiblings out for trick or treating. Haven’t gone to another pizza parlour since.
… more