torie quismundo
If I am ever in this area again I’m stopping for the oatmeal pie and caramel marshmallow. Oh my! We walk into the smell of perfection and the greeting from a kind young lady. She gave us information on the products and helped us select the best sugar and chocolate for us. The best, though, was the molasses cookies. Good golly! We Got 6. They boxed everything up and made it special. My son said the cookies were awesome. They explained their shipping policies for the holidays and helped us register to win a basket for Christmas in July. I’m not sure if it was the manager or owner but she came out and talked to us. I can’t remember her name but she must have eaten a lot of product because she was sweet as sugar too. She was small and mighty with a sweet punch to really make us feel Welcomed. Thanks for all the guidance. We loved everything!
… moreCourage DeLeon
If you are unaware, this is one of the most amazing sweet shops on the Eastern seaboard.
You walk in, and are greeted by the overwhelming smell of buttery, sugary goodness.
It’s the smell of everything being made by hand in front of you, it’s the smell of magic and quality, it is a smell that is sorely needed when you need that extra bit of loving.
… moreAlex Moore
If you are visiting Lititz, you have to stop here! It smells amazing as soon as you walk in, and we have loved everything that we’ve tried. Recently, we ordered a birthday cake and it was perfect! It was the most amazing pumpkin spice cake, and looked beautiful as well. We had a family member that couldn’t eat the cake but tried one of the macarons on top, and she said they were the best she’s ever tasted. Thank you, Chela!!
… moreKikki Bottums
If your in the area, you must stop in . I saw the marshmallows in the window and wow! I actually sell handmade carmellows at my place of business and these put mine to shame . The caramel that is wrapped around the marshmallow is to die for and if you try this you will never want to eat a store bought marshmallow again. I brought several back for coworkers and they all agreed with me . I should say, what make it back to work! I also grabbed a blueberry out bar for my breakfast and that was delicious also . I wish I had bought some other items from there so I could give a better review, but I’m pretty sure by the taste of those two items nothing in there would disappoint ! Even there bag was pretty !
… moreInês Barny
My boyfriend was in Lititz for work during his birthday which meant I wasn’t able to be with him in his special day, but I still wanted to send him cake. I contacted chela to make and deliver his favourite cake and she didn’t just do an excellent job but also delivered it on her day off! Thank you so much once again!
… moreKatie Vogler
Adorable bakery in Lititz, PA. Within walking distance to a lot of shops. We bought the oatmeal cream pie & shoofly cream pie both were delicious!!
… moreWendy Mauger
Sweet Legacy has been a favorite of ours for years. First when Matt and Amy owned it and now under the ownership of Chela. Before we retired, we lived in Lititz and I worked in Lititz so I was a regular. Their caramels are the absolute best and I love the cashew turtles. I also am so thankful they have gluten free options. We now live over 200 miles away but whenever possible we get back in. I missed my chance this holiday season but hopefully when we come down the next time!!
… moreJoan Butts Laila
I was greeted by the owner and a coworker. Both made me feel like I was bothering them. I felt unwelcomed. The caramels and fudge did not compare to the quality or flavor or texture of the previous owner’s products. He treated me very very well. I will never return to Sweet Legacy and I certainly will never recommend it to anyone, especially after her unprofessional reply. I am sorry for my unkind review. I really didn’t think much of my declined credit cards. I was trying to keep the situation light. I’m sure I’m not your only customer who gets declined! I should have used my debit card in the first place instead of inconveniencing you.
… moreDottie Weigel
The owner was great! They didn’t have something we wanted, so she made it for us! The cookie sandwiches are amazing!
… moreEnglish Bully
Such a sweet shop! I never miss an opportunity to pick up some butter toffee pecans!! Sooo goood!!! Friendly service, too!!
… more