Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Hours
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Montemaggiore Italian Restaurant | Elma NY – Facebook
Love and the smell of Italian food is in the air Valentine’s Day reservations are open! Call now for a reservation for any size party (716)714-5325❤️ Valentines …
Menu – Montemaggiore Italian
NEW YORK STYLE PIZZA. SMALL 12″ – 6 SLICES LARGE 16″ – 8 SLICES. Whole Pie … Copyright © 2025 Montemaggiore Italian Restaurant – All Rights Reserved.
Montemaggiore Italian
Come experience Italian food the way it’s meant to be—simple, honest, and made with love. Montemaggiore Italian Restaurant. 6150 Seneca St, Elma, NY, USA.
Reviews
Mark Dierolf
We got take out pizzas. One NY style crust, one Sicilian. Both very good. They use fried onions when u ask for onions. Not a fan of that.. Also, cup and char pepperoni would be much better in my opinion. But hey, I’m a Buffalo guy and we like cup and char pepperoni.
Overall, great food.
… moreOverall, great food.
Megan Van Remmen
If you like SUPER sweet red sauce, you may like this place. I went there for the first time several weeks ago. I went with a large party on a night that was already very busy for the holidays, so I don’t know if it is fair to critique the wait staff and kitchen. Our servers were friendly and seemed like they were trying their best to accommodate us, but I think the sheer volume of customers made it hard for staff to keep up.
I thought the food that did NOT have red sauce was good – appetizers were hot and crispy, our party said the chicken piccata was good, meatballs were huge and very flavorful. I’m sorry but I really could not stand the red sauce, it was overwhelmingly sweet and one-note. I did not care to finish my dish (eggplant rollatini), which sadly would have been very good if it wasn’t drowned in sugar. I know this place is known for the sauce, so maybe we just caught them on a bad day. I’m willing to try again.
… moreI thought the food that did NOT have red sauce was good – appetizers were hot and crispy, our party said the chicken piccata was good, meatballs were huge and very flavorful. I’m sorry but I really could not stand the red sauce, it was overwhelmingly sweet and one-note. I did not care to finish my dish (eggplant rollatini), which sadly would have been very good if it wasn’t drowned in sugar. I know this place is known for the sauce, so maybe we just caught them on a bad day. I’m willing to try again.
Katie Schafer
We come to this restaurant once every other month or so and came in tonight to celebrate a family birthday. They knocked it out of the park, just like every other time we come in but tonight was above and beyond. Jenna is seriously one of the sweetest and best servers we have ever encountered. Atmosphere 10, food 10 and service is always a 10! Will always be a family favorite ❤️
… moreJohn Joseph
I have almost nothing but good things to say about this restaurant. Great service, clean, cozy atmosphere, and good, reasonably-priced food. My one caveat is that the red sauce is much too sweet for my taste. It’s like… tomato sherbet or something. Many people love it and they’re proud of it. I do wish they’d offer a red sauce option on the opposite end of the spectrum – something that favors savory zest over sweetness.
… moreMary Krencik
Thought the food and service were excellent and very reasonable prices, with good sized portions! Tried both of the chefs specialties (chicken Parm platter {chicken with lasagna and stuffed shells} and the lasagna & stuffed shells platter. Just needs a little mood music in the background 🙂
EDIT: they now have music playing :-). Also tried the chicken fingers and the Sicilan pizza, pics added.
… moreEDIT: they now have music playing :-). Also tried the chicken fingers and the Sicilan pizza, pics added.
Catherine Johengen
Had to wait about 10 minutes for a table which tells me this little Elma secret is out! Excellent food and service. We sat by the fireplace which was nice on a very cold night.
… moreMichael Bonica
Stopped here after another local restaurant didn’t have room, so we decided to try this. What a gem! The atmosphere was great, the waitress was so personable, the food was amazing. Since our first visit about 2 months ago we have been back numerous times, and I am ordering catering for my work for the holidays. This is a sweeter sauce, but it is fantastic. The cannoli’s are the best I ever had, and have stopped multiple times just to pick some up on the way home! Great place!!
… moreRenee Engels
We went there for lunch… I had the lunch sized portion of the chicken Parmesan and it was absolutely delicious. Their sauce is so good, and it came with a small loaf of Italian bread. My friend had the julienne salad which was huge and looked wonderful. I thought the atmosphere was clean and nice. Service was great. Price is very reasonable. I have no complaints at all and I am so glad it is close to home as we will certainly go there again.
… moreDean May
Great atmosphere, friendly service, and amazing food. The sauce is a sweeter red sauce and is incredible, best I’ve ever had! The meatballs were probably the best I’ve ever had, too! Love it here.
… moreJulie Sullivan
My family visited your wonderful restaurant for probably the fifth time last night. My husband, two kids, and I absolutely love your food and really everything about your restaurant. We have told many of our friends and family to try your restaurant (which they have!) and they feel the same way as we do! Keep doing what you all are doing- amazing job! (PS- we have gotten take out, too and it’s just as amazing as eating in. )
… more