Laszlo Mohacsi
Benny’s is A Classic! Hole in the Wall! Serving Great Classic Dishes! Pizzas. Hot and cold sandwiches! Full meals! And Burgers! Love stopping in when I’m near! Say Hello to Benny when you stop in!
… moreAbdul-Karim
Tired of eating the same old Fast Food. Try Abe’s deliciously made Beef brisket.
Sure to be a Summer time favorite
… moreSylvia Wilson
We enjoyed the scrumptious Poutine and philly cheese steak rolls. The food was fresh and piping hot. The brisket melted in our mouths.
What a reasonably priced meal. Love the staff and the food is great.
… moreZach Ertrachter
Not sure why it changed
Used to be a 5 star in my opinion. Menu was cut in half, prices went up, no longer give a side of chips with sandwiches.
I ordered a sandwich with roast beef and it came instead with a chopped burger patty.
Salad was very meh
… moreRich Ciancanelli
Giving this a 3 was being generous. Its literally attached to a baseball field bathroom. Burnt extra crispy pizza slices. It’s ok if your just looking to grab and go but one of the worst slices of pizza you will buy
… moreLee Weal
Meh. Burgers are large but dry because they’re overcooked. Onion rings, fries are adequate. Pizza just OK. It’s fine for quick, fast food on the go, but don’t expect much.
… moreMoe Syed
Some of the most genuine guys working here. Chris has a great passion and you can taste it in the food. Everything was delicious and ingredients were quality. Very nice hole in the wall place to grab a bite.
… moreNick B
Benny’s use to have some of the best food, and especially pizza, around.
Since the new owners took over, the pizza might as well be a frozen store bought pie.
It’s terrible, the taste is gone, the texture is awkward, its just not very good.
Its a shame.
… moreKaren Rose
Variety, affordable, delicious every time. Whatever you are craving Benny probably has it on the menu. Great staff, friendly owners. I’ve been eating here since 1987! Poughkeepsie’s hidden gem. No indoor seating so I eat on the picnic tables in good weather, or take it to go, and they deliver. My all-time favorites are the Philly cheesesteak, fried clams, delicious thin crust Pizza, tuna melt, and the fish dinners.
… moreJoseph Desole
This place is great!! It will always be Benny’s to me, but some things in life unfortunately come to an end. The menu has changed a bit, for the better I may add, but everything is so fresh and delish, with no expense spared. Highly recommended!
… more