Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Annabel Pizza in Sussex nj – Facebook
Annabel Pizza in Sussex nj, Sussex. 112 likes · 1 talking about this · 10 were here. Italian Restaurant.
Annabel Pizza, 70 E Main St, Sussex, NJ 07461, US – MapQuest
Annabel Pizza is a small Italian restaurant located in Sussex County, known for its delicious pizza and pasta dishes. While the ambiance is straightforward, …
Annabel Pizza Menu (Updated 2026) – Wheree
Italian Restaurants, Pizza Restaurants. 70 E Main St #72, Sussex, NJ 07461, United States. +1 9738-751-886 · Suggest an edit. At Annabel Pizza, a delightful …
Reviews
Amanda
So good and everyone in the family loves it. The pizza taste so good, the mozzarella sticks are gooey and have flavor but not over seasoned. The garlic knots are a instant family favorite. Really enjoyed it thank you!!
… moreJenny Higgins
Have had pizza here a number of times, always tasty. Tonight we tried the arroz con pollo….WOW!! So delicious, I’ll be ordering this weekly!!
Always friendly service as well.
… moreAlways friendly service as well.
Sal Ruocco
Their pizza used to be decent but as if recently it was pretty bad. I ordered a margherita pie and they used thick slices of tomato with near zero basil, everything fell of the pizza before you could even bite it. The buffalo chicken pie was okay, but no where near worth the cost. There’s definitely better pizza in the area.
… moreMike Majewski
Food is okay. But just payed $44 for a half plain half bacon pie, with an order of wings. Not worth the price for sure, go to sussex inn, paesanos or pizza station
… moreDavid Deutsch
Absolutely fye. Very kind customer service, extremely fresh and crispy pies.
… moreMike R
Stopped in tonight and had plain pizza as I was craving pizza and remembered Annabel’s was up the road. Decided to give them a try as it has been many many years since I tried their food. I rate them 2 stars only because the pizza was not greasy. The pizza was so plain tasting no flavor at all. Tasted like I was eating dough and cheese. The sauce had no taste and if I did not see the sauce I would have thought there was no sauce on the pizza. The crust was chewy.
… morePaul Ustic
Food is as good as it looks I guess but I’m blown away that I got charged 2 dollars for a 99cent can of arizona
… moreKrishna Desai
Review: Annabelle’s Pizza
I recently visited Annabelle’s Pizza, and unfortunately, it was a disappointing experience. The pizza was underwhelming, lacking flavor and freshness. The crust was chewy and bland, and the toppings didn’t add much to the overall taste.
To make matters worse, the garlic knots were stale, leaving a dry texture that made them hard to enjoy. The dipping sauce tasted like generic canned tomato sauce, lacking the rich, homemade flavor I was hoping for.
Overall, I was left unsatisfied and won’t be returning. There are better pizza places out there that deliver on quality and taste.
… moreI recently visited Annabelle’s Pizza, and unfortunately, it was a disappointing experience. The pizza was underwhelming, lacking flavor and freshness. The crust was chewy and bland, and the toppings didn’t add much to the overall taste.
To make matters worse, the garlic knots were stale, leaving a dry texture that made them hard to enjoy. The dipping sauce tasted like generic canned tomato sauce, lacking the rich, homemade flavor I was hoping for.
Overall, I was left unsatisfied and won’t be returning. There are better pizza places out there that deliver on quality and taste.
Papa Bear
I’ve been a long time customer of this place because they have a variety of food on their menu especially for Sussex County. I always pick up my food as to not bother them but just today I called and they said they had a limited service area for delivery and that for them to deliver to me which is only an eight minute drive, they said that I would have to order a minimum of two items from the menu for them to deliver. Like I said I’m a long time customer and I will never buy from them again. Poor customer service with no consideration for their customers. Btw when i say one item I mean an entree.
… moreSix Vee
I’m a Brooklyn /Staten Island transplant. I grew up having great pizza, and this place has damn good pizza. Also don’t sleep on their quesadillas!!!!! I miss a lot of types of food, but thanks to Annabelles, pizza is not one of them!
… more