Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
We are a family owned pizza shop located in South Amherst and are proud to be the oldest pizza place in Amherst run by its original owners. Our pizza is crafted from a family recipe, hand-tossed and topped with fresh, whole ingredients. Our dough and sauce are made fresh, every day. Customer satisfaction and creating a quality, consistent product is our top priorities! Try our vegan or gluten-free pies Spread love.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 481 West St, Amherst, MA 01002
Phone: (413) 256-6100
Website: https://www.sibiespizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sibies Pizza in Amherst, MA Pizza Delivery, Take out, and Catering
Sibie’s Pizza. 481 West St. Amherst, MA 01002. (413) 256-6100. Pick up | Delivery | Catering. A family pizza recipe, hand-tossed and topped with fresh, whole …
Sibie’s Pizza, 481 West St, Amherst, MA 01002, US – MapQuest
Own this business? Claim it. See a problem? Let us know. United States ›Massachusetts ›Amherst ›Sibie’s Pizza. Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026 …
Menus for Sibies Pizza – Amherst – SinglePlatform
Sibies Pizza. Call Menu Info. 481 West St. Amherst, MA 01002 … Salads. Pizza by the Slice, Whole Pie, Specialty Pizzas, Sibie’s Subs, Wraps, Sibie’s Specialty …
Product
Reviews
Ken Kleinman
Great New York style pizza– this from a born and bred New Yorker. Plenty of toppings to choose from. The folks who work there are very friendly. There are a couple of outside places to sit, but nowhere inside.
… morePrima Munoz
This is truly a hidden gem such a great spot my kids and I enjoy the pizza here and also they are very giving to the community for the ebt shut down hands down best pizza spot
… moreValerie Killebrew
This is a family run business by a local family. The owner George and his daughter is there every day making everything from the best ingredients. A lot of what they have is also local! GREAT vegan and vegetarian options as well! Try the spinach and whole wheat crust!
… moreJayce J
The nicest people with the greatest service and great quality. Sibie’s sustained me through my four years of college and I continue to order from them regularly years after graduation. Tons of toppings and great choices for dietary restrictions. Truly the best.
… moreSamar Misra
Love the vegan pizza and tofu nuggets here. Florentine is amazing style. Adam and Erin are remarkable in hospitality and service. Glad I came here and will spread the word.
… moreFlavia Musinsky
Sibie’s is our favorite pizza in the valley! Such amazing variety of toppings, everything homeade, and great service too! Also love that there are also other foods besides judt pizza, if we’re in the mood for something else. Can’t wait to try the spinach crust next time!
… moreTylor Gosselin
Our family of 6 is vegan and the options are incredible and delicious! The pizza is delicious and the price points are really great for party size vegan specialty pizzas. The vegan ranch is to die for and I would pay for the recipe it’s sooo good. Sad they’re closed today (Sunday) cause I woke up craving it. Definitely check it out!
… moreHarrison Raycroft
I have been going here a few times a month for the past couple years and I can definitely say it’s a great spot. Good portions, good quality, and as far as take out prices go I actually think it’s really reasonable. I get a large sub, large fry, and a drink most of the time and it comes out to about $15. Also they have great customer service. Highly recommend this spot it’s a kind of a hidden gem in the area.
… moreGregory Herman
My family and I have movie and pizza night Friday of every week and we ALWAYS get Sibies. We’ve tried all the pizzas in the area and Sibies is by far the best. They seem to care most about the quality of all the ingredients in their pies and cook them perfectly.
… moreJoseph Lyman
This place doesn’t just have good pizza or the best sausage grinder in Amherst. It has the nicest people which technically makes the food taste better.
… more