Brett Perkins
Casey’s has always had very good pizza, We were Very happy now that Goddard has one, Visited 1/15/26 around 6pm to get the pizza I ordered online, Place was very clean, I was greeted when I walked in the door by a young lady mopping the floor. The kitchen was well staffed with friendly people. The rotating hot case was fully stocked. I did not have to wait long to get my pizzas, they were Hot, fresh and very good. All in all, a very “Casey’s” experience
… moreSteve Parsons
I’m not convinced they make pizza at this location. I’ve been here twice and nothing. They said the staff decided to shut it down early. It was 7:30pm and their website says the kitchen is open till 10pm. Also 1 out of all the slushie machines were working. Do better…
… moreSaige Fields
The food is amazing! The wait time sometimes does get annoying BUT I understand there’s so many differen other food products to make, I do appreciate everyone’s time and patience’s and I respect rush hr a lot I know how hectic it can get.and again the food is Amazing
… moreShirley Millard
We picked up 3 pizzas from Casey’s on Christmas Day & we were super happy with the service & the pizza. Cheyanne took our order, she was both friendly & helpful. I’m sure working on Christmas was hard as we all like to spend it with family & friends – but you wouldn’t have known it by her! She was kind & patient with us as we had a lot of questions since we hadn’t had their pizza for several years. We will come back! Thank you Cheyanne! Merry Christmas!
… moreHana Williams
Husband drove all the way up there in the snow. For them not to have the sauce for the pizza we ordered. Said we’d just take the one pizza then and they wouldn’t honor the single topping being 50% off. So we didn’t get it. Husbands went up there in the middle of the snow store for absolutely no reason. I’d like management to reach out. Mind you this is then end of night. They weren’t going to be able to sell the pizza we ordered. Why not honor the discount?
… morePolly Foust
I “thought” I completed my pizza order on the app. Went to pick it up and it had not gone thru…TOTALLY MY FAULT! The staff was incredibly nice and got me fixed up quickly!
… moreB
We went in for the Free icee Friday for rewards members and they were out of small icee cups and lids. I notified the cashier to let her know they were out. I used the small clear iced coffee cups nearby, thinking they were the same cup. The discount didn’t come off, and the manager tried telling me I needed to make a purchase. She wasn’t very friendly and reluctantly gave them free this time.
… moreMandi Combs
Why shut down gas pumps even if main store is closed…. Edit: I try to only use Casey’s gas station for the rewards which I love that program, and every one I’ve been to even if main building is closed the gas pumps are still on..
… moreDan H
They do not refill the hot breakfast after the morning rush. If you don’t beat the construction workers, it’s only old leftovers available. I was just there at 7am, and there was one piece of breakfast pizza available. This is not a one off, but my consistent experience.
… moreR C
Was impressed first time,with pizza supreme,lady was the cook.week later I there was 2 guys pizza was so disappointing I threw it away and went to dillions got a red Barron and add cheese and veggies.watch who’s cooking piz .it makes a difference,there.
… more