Suzie
This is the second time I’ve went to Ferlito’s Pizzeria. The first time I ordered fettuccine alfredo it was wonderful. I had a side of chicken breast it was a great addition to the pasta but also tasted wonderful on its own. The second time I went I got chicken piccata and rigatoni and meat sauce. I enjoyed the meat sauce and rigatoni. The Chicken Piccata was absolutely the best Chicken Piccata I’ve ever had in my life. I’m not sure if the chef is classically trained, but this dish is better than you would get at a five star restaurant. I highly recommend this restaurant I can’t wait to try the pizza.
… moreLexy Diehl
Tried them for the first time and overall, it was a solid experience! Ordered a well-done cheese pizza and the 3-cheese cheesy bread. The cheesy bread was amazing—super melty and flavorful. The pizza itself was decent, but it didn’t really seem well-done, which I think would have made it better. Definitely willing to give them another try with a different kind of pizza. Staff was friendly, and online ordering was super easy, which is always a plus!
… moreRyan Mager
Definitely up and coming probably would rate the pizza 5 stars if they offered flavored crust, really excited to try normal style pizza as good as their Chicago style is its not for me! Nothing on them for that! Pizza was cooked exceptionally and had a fair amount of everything on it. I have no doubt their hand tossed round is amazing. Salad wasn’t bad for 5$ either!
… moreVijion 2020
Easy Online Ordering – A+
Fast Delivery – A+
Friendly Service – A+
To me, pizza delivery has TWO phases. Day 1 and Day 2.
Day 1 – We ordered (2) large pizzas and (1) large wings with Ranch. Everything arrived 10 min early, piping hot and crispy. The wings were fried nicely, they were crispy in the outside, and the meat was tender and juicy.
The Chicago Style pepperoni was an A-. An A+ would be a UNO’s, Malnatis or Giordanos. The cheese was excellent, the sauce was slightly sweet, and the dough was crunchy on the bite and soft and chewy on the inside. Excellent !
The 2nd pizza was the White – C-. Asthetically, the pizza looked amazing, but the flavor was lacking. It was bland and boring. The crust was still very good, but it was lacking. Will not order again.
Alright, Day 2: I love cold pizza and airfried day-old pizza. Usually, the sauce gets sweeter, too. I love it ! Either way, everything was really yummy on day 2. The Chicago Style was AWESOME, and the White pizza with a bit of salt was better than day 1. The wings were good too on day 2.
I will definitely be ordering again. And recommending to the neighbors.
… moreJ S
Tried Ferlito’s for the first time and honestly, it’s not worth the hype. I wish I could give negative stars — it was that bad. I’m usually someone who loves making recommendations, but I’ll absolutely be sharing how disappointing this experience was. I love supporting local restaurants but I can’t in good conscience recommend this place.
We ordered the BOGO special: an 8-corner, a round pizza, and cheese bread. We were told 30 minutes, but it took an hour. There was no acknowledgment of the delay, no apology, and no effort to make it right.
I requested light sauce and instead received an excessive amount. The 8-corner was undercooked and raw in the middle — we had to throw it out because we weren’t willing to risk getting sick. I also wasn’t willing to wait another hour for a replacement and drive back there. At that point, it was clear there was a lack of care regarding both wait times and quality control. The pizza was extremely thick, which likely contributed to it not being fully baked — it clearly needed more time in the oven.
The round pizza wasn’t much better. The crust was dry, overly flour-dusted, and chewy — almost like sandpaper scraping your mouth.
This was genuinely some of the worst pizza I’ve had, and I don’t understand how Ferlito’s has such a positive reputation. It’s disappointing.
Don’t waste your money there are far better pizza places in the Shores. Also, the coupons don’t even list a web code to use for online ordering or feature them on their website. It’s 2026 — time to update the system. I literally could have taken the money I paid and just thrown it in the garbage cause that’s where the pizza is going.
… moreNikki B
This was the first order I placed since the restaurant closed and just this carry out place opened up. I was really excited to be getting a pasta that I had known and ordered before and had always enjoyed tremendously. I ordered angel hair pasta in palomino sauce, topped with baked mozzarella cheese. What I got was almost a completely dry angel hair pasta barely topped with palomino sauce (this was always tossed in a good amount of sauce previously) and then cheese baked on top of that. As a result, the dish was really dry and almost flavorless; I had to throw most of it out because there was zero sauce on 90% if it; it was just plain angel hair noodles and for the price I paid, that was more than disappointing. I’m sad to say I don’t think I’ll be back if this is how they’ll be doing the pasta.
… moreDennis Hansinger
Great pizza and 3 cheese bread! These guys’ sauce is pretty different too, on the sweeter side which is hard to find around town. I’ve been missing that flavor since LaRosa’s in Dayton.
They have a weird delivery system which defaults to Uber Eats or alike, so you’ll receive weird cancellation and acceptance messages. The store was on it though and called me shortly after to confirm my order. Will order again!
… moreJeannie Brousseau
The chicken Sicilian on garlic angle hair pasta was superb. The cheese raviolis and meatballs were perfect. Loved the food. The atmosphere was more of a take out vibe- different from their old family restaurant that was nice to dine in. However still excellent food and reasonably priced. We will order again.
… morePamela highstreet
My family and I just love this place! We started a tradition almost two years ago- where we get together every Tuesday for pizza Tuesdays. At this point- we have tried every local place and have even traveled to some places. Once we tried this place- we haven’t left! For the past three Tuesdays strong- this is all my family wants. The pizza is delicious, as is the pastas, fries, and bread! Also- the salads are amazing. It might go from pizza Tuesdays to Ferlito’s Tuesdays!
… moreMargie Linette Tennison
Happy New Years Eve! We were so lucky to try their Chicago Style Pizza and Cheese Bread before they closed. They did not disappoint, and we will definitely be back. We can’t wait
… more