Social Profile: 
… View more
Hours
| Friday | 8 AM–1 AM |
| Saturday | 8 AM–1 AM |
| Sunday | 8 AM–1 AM |
| Monday | 8 AM–1 AM |
| Tuesday | 8 AM–1 AM |
| Wednesday | 8 AM–1 AM |
| Thursday | 8 AM–1 AM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 101 Prescott Ave, Elmira Heights, NY 14903
Phone: (607) 442-0444
Website: https://www.facebook.com/pickspub
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pick’s Pub | Elmira Heights NY – Facebook
Details. . 100% recommend (38 Reviews). . 101 Prescott Ave., Elmira Heights, NY, United States, 14903 ; Links. . pickspub.net ; Contact info. . (607) 442-0444.
Pick’s Pub
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other …
Pick’s Pub – 101 Prescott Ave, Elmira, NY, 14903 – MapQuest
Pick’s Pub is a local establishment in Elmira, NY, offering a diverse menu that caters to breakfast, lunch, and dinner diners.
Reviews
Ron Randall
Wife & I love trying new spots and this place was on this place was on the list of must try.
It was lunchtime New Years eve, the place was extremely busy and parking was tight. We went in found one empty table to grab, both of us been very surprised when one of the gals came so quickly to take take our orders. We both tried the cheeseburgers, fries and chips, one medium the other was ordered medium rare. Some of the patrons started celebrating early so they made it louder than expected. The floor appeared clean with no debris. Table silverware & condiments all clean. (I hate picking up a ketchup bottle and it making my hands sticky) the burgers arrived and just amazing, the ground meat was delicious and cooked perfect the pictures describe what you get. The fries delicious cooked with just a light crisp on the outside. We highly recommend this place, other plates looked amazing as well from what seen others being served.
EDIT: we have stopped twice on Friday for the fish fry, first time was awesomeness not too heavy on the batter which we both prefer, second time was not as good a heavy batter which is not as enjoyable so we are up in the air on the fish fry here. Everything was delicious but the heavy batter not to our liking. The fish was awesome as was the Mac & cheese, the fries totally delicious. We will have to try again and tell waitress light on the batter see how it plays.
… moreIt was lunchtime New Years eve, the place was extremely busy and parking was tight. We went in found one empty table to grab, both of us been very surprised when one of the gals came so quickly to take take our orders. We both tried the cheeseburgers, fries and chips, one medium the other was ordered medium rare. Some of the patrons started celebrating early so they made it louder than expected. The floor appeared clean with no debris. Table silverware & condiments all clean. (I hate picking up a ketchup bottle and it making my hands sticky) the burgers arrived and just amazing, the ground meat was delicious and cooked perfect the pictures describe what you get. The fries delicious cooked with just a light crisp on the outside. We highly recommend this place, other plates looked amazing as well from what seen others being served.
EDIT: we have stopped twice on Friday for the fish fry, first time was awesomeness not too heavy on the batter which we both prefer, second time was not as good a heavy batter which is not as enjoyable so we are up in the air on the fish fry here. Everything was delicious but the heavy batter not to our liking. The fish was awesome as was the Mac & cheese, the fries totally delicious. We will have to try again and tell waitress light on the batter see how it plays.
tag
Last night, my family and I came to dine at your establishment specifically because my sister, who is from out of town, enjoys your fish fries. This was my fifth time at your restaurant and prior to this visit I’ve always had a pleasant experience. While waiting for our meals, my daughter and I went up to the bar to order a beer. My daughter, who is 24, did not have her ID. She’s a bartender and another local bar, so we understand that this was a failure on her part. She should have gone back out to the car to retrieve her ID, but two out of four of us slipped on the ice upon entering the front door, and she didn’t want to risk it. Oh, by the way, we did bring this up to the waitress, and an hour later when we left, no salt had been spread. Enter and exit at your own risk, I guess. Anyway, when my daughter was denied her beer, I said that then I would like to order one. The waitress went over to the owner and explained the situation to him (good on her for following protocols), and he practically shouted at us, “No ID, no alcohol. This is a bar. Have a great night” in a VERY unwelcoming manner. As previously stated, we are aware of NYS liquor laws and would never do anything to risk a bar’s liquor license and the livelihood of the people who work there. Had you said something like, “You know I can’t serve you without an ID,” we would have explained that we were not even going to drink the beer. We just wanted to see how the bottom-filling beer machine worked because we found it fascinating. That’s it. Pour and dump. Yes, we could have Googled and looked at a video but figured since we were right there, we would see it in person. You could have made an extra seven bucks, but no. You chose to be snarky and embarrass customers who had already ordered their meal. Had it not been for my extended family being with me, I would have left. I have been going to restaurants for 6 decades and never had been treated that rudely.
Also, you had a direct line of sight to the table where we were sitting. Had my daughter drank any beer, you would have been able to see it.
Is this review going to affect your bottom line? No. But I do hope it makes you think about how you treat people. Kindness goes a long way. Do better.
… moreAlso, you had a direct line of sight to the table where we were sitting. Had my daughter drank any beer, you would have been able to see it.
Is this review going to affect your bottom line? No. But I do hope it makes you think about how you treat people. Kindness goes a long way. Do better.
Forever Metal
We really like coming here often. The owner and his staff seem to really value his customers. Our first impression of their chicken wings wasn’t really to our liking but we didn’t say anything to give them a chance in making things right that first time. Instead, I decided to give them a second chance on my lunch for to try their fish fry. I am really glad I did since everything was great, even their tartar sauce and cocktail sauce. They give you plenty of either and their Mac & cheese is very cheesey and everything tastes like quality. Then I had to have my wife try their fish fry the next week even after I was there earlier that day for a fish fry at lunch. Twice in one day, plus I tried their club sandwich which was both hearty and tasty. Then we returned the next week with friends and even had the fish fry with Mac & Cheese and it wasn’t on a Friday. They are the only ones offering the combo of both every single day of the week. Wow!
… moreMark Edge
This old time treasure of a bar, is now revitalized and turned into a nice pub in the heights. Service is always excellent with all staff that are very friendly and smiling upon arrival. The food is very good, and I have tried several things on the menu.
… moreAmy Montondo
Food and service was very good. Our server checked on us regularly. We went on Saturday and had their prime rib special. They have some craft beers and we didn’t have a problem getting a table. We will definitely be back.
… moreChloe W.H.
I absolutely loved this very chill atmosphere. They knownlimited mixed drinks but the beer was a very wide selection. The food was well cooked and presentation was perfect. My husband and I plan on coming here again.
… moreMike M
My first time here and although they were jam packed busy, it was awesome!
I had hot wings, extra crispy. And they were perfect!
Very nice staff of ladies that check on ya.
Nice atmosphere, definitely not a dive bar. Nice place!
… moreI had hot wings, extra crispy. And they were perfect!
Very nice staff of ladies that check on ya.
Nice atmosphere, definitely not a dive bar. Nice place!
Ryan Benedict
Pizza was put in the box fresh out of the oven and all the cheese slid off by the time we got home… 2 min drive. Owner refused to give a refund over the phone or make another pizza, and was extremely insulting. I will give him the benefit of the doubt and say he just had a bad day. Service was awful and will never be ordering from this location again. Take a look at the picture to see just how yummy this pie was!
… moreLISA B
Reubens, Cheesesteak, Crispy Chisken Wrap. All fantastic. Didn’t care for the sweet potato fries. The onion rings were the best!!
… moreDaBowlinBoi
Pick’s has incredible wings and even better prices. I’ve never had a bad experience, regardless of if the place is empty or slammed. The staff is very friendly as well. Overall it’s just a great little spot; the only thing that could improve the place is less Bills more Eagles.
… more