Address and Contact Information
Address: 25 E Main St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
Phone: (516) 922-0434
Website: https://www.facebook.com/pages/Ninos-Pizza/115582815135279
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Nino’s Pizza in Oyster Bay- Anyone Know if They Opened … – Reddit
I used to love their pizza since I was a kid and lost contact with them some years ago. They even gave me their recipe for vodka sauce.
Nino’s Pizza (@ninos.pizza) • Instagram photos and videos
199 followers · 21 following · 23 posts · @ninos.pizza: “Ninos Pizza / Oyster Bay NY . . . . . Enjoy a slice…fresh.”
Nino’s Pizza – CLOSED, 25 E Main St, Unit 2, Oyster Bay, NY 11771 …
Nino’s Pizza, located in Oyster Bay, NY, offers a variety of pizza and Italian cuisine, ensuring a delightful dining experience for customers.
Reviews
Rob Novack
Come here for the best of the basics, incredible fresh, soft garlic knots and go for their classic pizza. The buffalo chicken pizza and wings were ok, so I’d stick with plain, pepperoni, sausage etc. for some great tasting pizza.
… moreMargaret Pulgarin
Great Pizza, warm and welcoming small pizza joint. Grandama slice yummy and cheesy, pepperoni and sausage was very good and buffalo chicken was amazing. Two tumbs up
… moreTheresa E Sweeney
Extremely well-prepared, traditional pizzeria recipes. Absolutely delicious heroes. Nino is a lovely, generous, excellent cook. The prices are genuinely fair, and the postage-stamp-sized tables comfortable and cozy. Cannot say enough good things about this restaurant!
… moreLisa Liu Guitar
Sat down and ordered an onion and pepper pie. The owner was so warm and friendly, I felt like I was in his living room! And the pizza was incredible! A true New York pie! If you want to experience an authentic NY slice, put this on the list.
… moreP Riz
I am 61 and young. I have been going to Nino’s since I was 14.
There is no Siciliano restaurant anywhere like theirs. The pizza is great!! The sausage roll is incredible, but what people don’t know is that they make the absolute best cannoli anywhere, better than any bakery on LI.
There made fresh when you order. Melt in your mouth.
They are the real deal.
No body beats them.♥️
… moreThere is no Siciliano restaurant anywhere like theirs. The pizza is great!! The sausage roll is incredible, but what people don’t know is that they make the absolute best cannoli anywhere, better than any bakery on LI.
There made fresh when you order. Melt in your mouth.
They are the real deal.
No body beats them.♥️
LizzyG Gonzalez
In Oyster Bay for a quick visit and stumbled across this tiny pizza shop!! Pizza was AMAZING!! Reminded me of the classic pizzerias of Brooklyn. We tried plain, Margherit, and a white slice. They were all delish. We will definitely drive down there again just for pizza!
… moreEduardo Gigante
Ordered large neopolitan pizza. It came with at least 2 pounds too many of mozzarella cheese with NO SAUCE. I shouldn’t have to specifically request tomato sauce on a pizza. If you actually like pizza, don’t order from here. The owners are welcome to come get what’s left of the pizza. We could only stand to eat 3 slices.
… moreS Limones
Ok let me start by saying the pizza tasted really good. The crust was thin and crispy, yum! However, the place is SO tiny, the man behind the counter was rude AND I saw him lick ricotta cheese off his hand, after he was done putting it on the white slices. I guess he had extra cheese and figured he would eat it. Did not wash his hands after licking off the cheese or handling cash. Thank goodness the oven temp likely kills the germs…..
… moreErin Law
Best pizza in oyster bay even if its a hole in the wall. Great zeppoles … get them fresh around 2pm ! The owners are brothers from Sicily. They can seem a bit gruff but get to know them.
… moreBur G.
Perhaps the best pizza place in all of New York. Very old school brings back the nostalilgic feel of a pizza place growing up. The 3 bros Nino, Mimo and Sal are awesome. Been coming here since I was younger and hands down, IMO, best pizza and prices are extremely reasonable.
… more