Tobee Clear
If u like thin crispy crust n crispy wings Jays is the place! Just enough sauce n cheese its perfect NY style pizza in North Rockland!
… moreArooj N (Roo)
Jay’s Pizzeria is hands down one of the best local gems around. The pizza is out of this world, fresh, flavorful, and always consistent. What makes it even better is the owner, Jay, who is incredibly hands on. You can tell he cares about every single order, from the kitchen to delivery, making sure everything is just right.
The delivery is impressively fast, like blink and your pizza is here fast. And if you are lucky enough to know the secret menu, the thin crust with vodka sauce is the move. It is not listed, but trust me, it is the best thing you can order. Perfectly crisp, saucy, and addictively good.
If you want pizza made with love and speed, Jay’s is the spot.
… moreSteve Howard
Finally tried jays for lunch. The store is clean and nicely lit. I had a calzone that was over stuffed and completely awesome. Really enough for 2 or 3. Pizza slice was large and very tasty. Counter person was not really personable but the food was great
… moreBrenda Elias
Parking available on small strip mall near Post Office and other stores. Place is clean and the 2 men were welcoming. Not much foot traffic. They do have an app to order and orders can be paid with Apple Pay, etc. my son who loves pizza really enjoyed it. I liked their lemon pepper crispy wings. You can really taste the lemon which I like. Might be my new ordering spot.
… moreMarc Shoemaker
Stopped in for lunch today and we had pizza and lasagna. both were very good and really liked all the cheese on the lasagna. Salads were very good and fresh.
… moreLava Antar
Trying to have a relaxing Friday night and order pizza. This is how the cheese pizza looked like the crust was hardly Chewable. The cheese was saggy in a disgusting way . A you see in the picture. I wish I could upload a video. i had to throw the pie in the garbage because there is no way this pizza was freshly made.
… moreLylesberg berg
For pizza in the area, this is the place. We had a Sicilian pie, half pepperoni (see pic). 12 major size slices! As we sat there, 20+ college kids (I’m guessing college) walked in. From the pictures online, I figured yeah let’s try this place Jay’s. Seeing those kids confirmed we were in the right place. When the pizza hit the table, I was feeling extra good about this choice. Side note: the guy pumped out 6-8 pies for those kids who walked in, and he did it quick. And they all looked great! Have only good things to say about this place. They were accommodating (we have a 2 year old who loves good pizza) and friendly. Come by here and definitely sit in the place and order a fresh pie. I guess the only down side was the place wasn’t air conditioned…but it was also 85 degrees out. In any case, go to Jay’s!
… moreAmanda Dolce
This is such a great small-town spot. The pizza is always fresh and flavorful, and the garlic knots are a must. The staff is friendly and welcoming; it feels like they know everyone who walks in. Whether it’s pizza night with the family or a quick bite, they never disappoint!
… moreAKJ
Great service & food! Hot Spanish food added. So so Good! Highly recommend. Very Convenient for the area
… moreBrittanie O’Dell
I haven’t had Jay’s in years as I was comfortable with a different location. Tonight I tried delivery from Jay’s and I’m so grateful I did. My family and I LOVED the pizza, chef’s salad and the pepperoni pizza roll. Everything was delivered hot and fresh…and quickly. The app was easy to navigate and the pricing was very fair. Jay’s will definitely be our go-to place moving forward!
… more