Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
The word paisano in Italian means a close friend or neighbor. At Paisano’s Pizzeria, we seek to bring together friends and neighbors around a good meal. Let us do the cooking for you. We are proud of our roots that go all the way back to “old school” Brooklyn, where all New York style pizza comes from. We use the same recipes our grandparents shared with us. Our desire was to bring the traditional “old school” authentic pizza and entrees across the river to New Jersey, for all to enjoy. Paisano’s Pizzeria in Randolph, NJ is a family owned and operated Italian restaurant offering classic Italian cuisine and traditional Italian dishes. We offer dine in or take out service, as well as corporate delivery. Bring the whole family by
Hours
| Wednesday | 10 AM–9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–9:30 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 138 Center Grove Rd, Randolph, NJ 07869
Phone: (973) 396-8778
Website: https://www.paisanospizzanj.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: paisanospizzanj.com
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Paisano’s Pizzeria | Randolph, NJ | Pizza | Randolph, NJ | Italian …
An authentic Italian restaurant and pizzeria located in the heart of Randolph, NJ. we off a variety of gourmet pizzas, pasta, hot an cold subs, appetizers, …
Paisano’s Pizzeria – 138 Center Grove Rd, Randolph, NJ 07869 – Slice
… Randolph, NJ! Paisano’s Pizzeria is a … CateringSalads CateringSandwich Platters CateringPasta CateringChicken CateringOur Specialties Catering.
Paisanospizzerianj (@paisanospizzanj) · Randolph, NJ – Instagram
the best pizza in town for the whole family of Pizza restaurant catering menu 973 396 8778 973 396 8779 · Destacada · Paisanos · Destacada …
Reviews
Jennifer Aguilar
The best pizzeria in the entire county, without a doubt! My brother recommended this pizzeria. I’d had bad experiences with other pizzerias, but my kids were craving pizza. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and two sodas, and besides being reasonably priced, the pizza was PERFECT! Cooked to perfection, the edges didn’t curl, and it fit perfectly in the box. The portion of cheese was just right. We absolutely loved this place. The staff is super nice and friendly, and the place is very clean. Definitely a 10/10 establishment.
… moreJefferson Aguilar
100% recommended! My friends and I went to do laundry at the laundromat next to the pizzeria and took the opportunity to grab some slices. The place was spotless and top-notch. We even saw the guy who served us sweeping the front. We loved the service and the pizza. We ordered the famous Grandma and three other slices. The pizza was cooked to perfection. This place has definitely become my favorite local pizzeria.
… moreIsmael Thompson
Two days ago I went to this place because it was close to Weis Market. I ordered four pizzas for 6 pm. Although I think the girl who served me didn’t understand me, the pizza maker, who was very kind, was able to resolve the issue. The pizza was 10/10; my family and I loved it. We will definitely be back!
… moreRashmi Shahoo
We had the pleasure of catering with Mr Orlen owner of Paisano’s Pizzeria & Catering for the Randolph home tournament, serving 800+ people adults & kids from all over Nj and they absolutely delivered above and beyond!
The Chicken Marsala was exceptional, full of flavor and perfectly cooked and the gravy was out of the world.. The eggplant parmesan was a huge hit—rich, delicious, and beautifully prepared. The baked vegetables were fresh and seasoned to perfection, and the pizza was truly top-notch.
The gravy/sauce was out of this world, and you could taste the quality in every dish. On top of the amazing food, the owner went above and beyond by offering generous discounts, giving us truly unbeatable pricing for the town. It made a huge difference and was greatly appreciated.
Feeding a crowd this size is no small task, but the professionalism, flavor, and flawless service made the entire event run smoothly.
Highly recommended! We can’t wait to work with them again!!
Must try best Pizza, Chicken Marsala , Eggplant Parmesan small or big event truly the best !!! – On behalf of of RHS debate club we are really thankful to the owner for supporting this event and making us the best food !!
… moreThe Chicken Marsala was exceptional, full of flavor and perfectly cooked and the gravy was out of the world.. The eggplant parmesan was a huge hit—rich, delicious, and beautifully prepared. The baked vegetables were fresh and seasoned to perfection, and the pizza was truly top-notch.
The gravy/sauce was out of this world, and you could taste the quality in every dish. On top of the amazing food, the owner went above and beyond by offering generous discounts, giving us truly unbeatable pricing for the town. It made a huge difference and was greatly appreciated.
Feeding a crowd this size is no small task, but the professionalism, flavor, and flawless service made the entire event run smoothly.
Highly recommended! We can’t wait to work with them again!!
Must try best Pizza, Chicken Marsala , Eggplant Parmesan small or big event truly the best !!! – On behalf of of RHS debate club we are really thankful to the owner for supporting this event and making us the best food !!
Chuck Mound
This Pizza had a lot of potential..Very Good Sauce, Very Good Cheese with the crust at Ok. Ordered a Well done Margarita Pie, but could have used more time in the oven to get a little more crisp. This is first visit to this Pizzeria and I was happy with the first order. Speaking of which, you should think about that box promotion to 10 Pizzas Purchases versus 15 that you offer now. I would have to spend $300 before I get a Free Pizza basically. Anyway, I will be back, the place is new, clean and is on the right track with the Pizza. Did not recommend a signature Pizza on the Phone, just started rattling off the menu. I just went with my favorite and hoped for the best.
… moreL. A.
Talk about a hidden gem, located right next to the Randolph Weis is in my opinion, one of the best under the radar pizzarias in Morris County. When you see a brick oven, that’s usually a great sign, which was certainly the case here. Their sauce is sweet and herbaceous and their crust is thin, crispy, but also airy, a trademark of a proper brick oven pie which they certainly deliver. Highly recommend this place.
… moreBig Knowledge- Allah
Unreal. Maybe they’re stock piling resources for something bad about to happen. About 2 months ago I went there and got some eggplant in Alfredo sauce & it was great. About 4 slices of eggplant in a good sauce for about $10. Fast forward TONIGHT. I ordered a $17 meal & asked for that eggplant to be included with a side of sauce. I wish I could show u how there was literally maybe 4 snips of eggplant & my Alfredo sauce came in one of those containers u get a side of ranch sauce for your salad. Ok, whatever, I won’t be back. But how does that turn my meal into a $28 meal? I did get broccoli but if that was the case, give me more eggplant than a bunch of broccoli. Feeling disrespected.
Update smh…
I went back only because my girl works in plaza for a simple turkey & cheese (american & provolone with lettuce onion& tomato . & This is what I got. Minus the american smh. This place is the absolute WORST. I’m done
… moreUpdate smh…
I went back only because my girl works in plaza for a simple turkey & cheese (american & provolone with lettuce onion& tomato . & This is what I got. Minus the american smh. This place is the absolute WORST. I’m done
RED-81
Stopped in for a early dinner on Saturday the pizza was amazing the service was very friendly and the atmosphere was very comfortable. Highly recommend if your in the Randolph area stop in for some great pizza!!!! Chances of returning 100%
… moreDana Pineiro
Paisano’s gave us a great deal when we ordered 50 pizzas for a school event. Orlen was a pleasure to work with and we look forward to continuing a partnership with Paisano’s for future school events!
… moreSreenadh
The food is decent but not great
The staff is friendly
But the tables arent cleaned after each customer
Edit: the owner replied to this review saying that the tables are cleaned even though i posted pictures showing that they werent when we went in
… moreThe staff is friendly
But the tables arent cleaned after each customer
Edit: the owner replied to this review saying that the tables are cleaned even though i posted pictures showing that they werent when we went in