Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 40 S Main St, New City, NY 10956
Phone: (845) 499-2929
Website: http://www.cakedupcafe.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Caked Up Cafe
Caked Up is a family owned and operated bakery located in New City, New York. Since opening its doors over 10 years ago, Caked Up has garnered a cult …
Caked Up | New City NY – Facebook
Happy #StPatricksDay ☘️ Themed #cupcakes , cookies, cakesicles and cake pops available today, stop by early for the best selection! #cakedupcafe # …
Caked Up Cafe: Order Online
8×8 Classic crumb cake with a pound of Caked Up’s signature ground coffee! $32.95. 8×8 … New City, NY 10956. +100 miles. Store info. View menu.
Reviews
Row
We pass by the town every few months and never miss a stop at this bakery. They offer 3 gluten free options, which I have tried and really love— macarons, rainbow cake, and rainbow cheesecake. You can order some gluten free cupcakes/cakes a day or so in advance. I only ever need one and just ask if they have any extras. Their stuff is always so cute and delicious.
… moreEmily Blades
I ordered gender reveal cupcakes from Caked Up and was not disappointed! The cupcakes were ordered as a game to reveal the gender, so I needed a specific amount of pink filled cupcakes and blue filled cupcakes, as well as a vegan cupcake for my mom too (majority needed to be filled with the true gender)! They followed my specific instructions 100%, even down to leaving the order slip out of the package to not give anything away! I am SO thrilled and impressed with this bakery and couldn’t be more thankful that they made my gender reveal so much fun and special. And the cupcakes were delicious! Thank you Caked Up!!!! I am so excited for my little girl
… morefabilicious22
The cake looked super cute from the outside! But the cake itself was dry the frosting was overly sweet… litterally no one wanted to take cake home which is a first for me! If all you care about is looks then I would say go for this place.
… moreBetty Vasquez
We drove up 1.5hrs from Brooklyn after seeing them featured on TV yesterday. It’s a beautiful local bakery with the most amazing treats. Cakes and cupcakes are displayed beautifully The staff is so friendly, helpful and provided great service. Shout out to the owner thanks for a wonderful 1st experience.
… moreS “SKJ” J
I ordered customer cakes two years straight and wanted to say how great it is. I don’t know many places that do as good a job as Caked up getting all the details right. They are easy to deal with and Denise especially is great because she’ll sketch the design and sent it to you first. And it’s not just the design, the most recent cake we got also tastes really good.
… moreDk
The cake was cute and all instructions were followed, but it was dry and hard to cut. No one who was served a slice actually ate the cake….i’ve had decent items here before but this was the first time I ordered a cake. I can’t tell if this was an isolated incident. We kind of knew there was an issue once we tried to cut it with a knife and it wouldn’t go through easily. The cake wasn’t cold it just lacked moisture. It almost seemed stale. It was a 6 inch cookies and cream cake. Maybe they need to put a sticker on the cakes to make sure they are rotated out and no cake accidentally lingers longer than usual.
… moreJennifer H
I found my new cake spot! I just moved up here from NYC and it’s been a struggle going to the city for my cakes. I can finally say I’ve found my cake spot. They taste amazing, designs are neat and professional and they have them ready on time. The prices aren’t bad either. I’ve had two cakes done in two months, both delicious and people keep asking where I got them from.
… moreGina
We used Caked Up Cafe for my daughter’s baby shower. We had a Bear theme & they did an amazing job! Vanilla cake with a raspberry creme inside. The cake pops & cupcakes were equally delicious! Our guests were blown away with the elegance & creativity of the presentation. I highly recommend Caked Up Cafe!
… moreNicholas Payne
We were recommended to Caked Up Cafe by our wedding venue Views at Mt Fuji after having a bad experience with a prior vendor. I can say that we are so thankful that we decided to make the switch and that everything was perfect! We worked with Denise and from the very beginning we could tell that everything was going to be great. The cake looked amazing and was so delicious. We would definitely recommend them for any wedding and we just want to say thank you!
… moreNicole
The cake made for my baby shower came out amazing! And tasted so good!. Everyone loved it. It was everything I asked for and more.when ordered I struggled to figured out the design and the staff worked with me so patiently and were so kind, highly recommend !! Thank you so much!
… more