Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Order Circles and Squares Pizza Co – Newark, OH Menu Delivery …
Get delivery or takeout from Circles and Squares Pizza Co at 81 Calburn St in Newark. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Circles & Squares Pizza Co. – Explore Licking County
81 Calburn Street, Newark, OH 43055. Circles & Squares Pizza Co. is a small family-owned pizzeria making Delicious New York and Detroit style pizza. They are …
Circles & Squares Pizza Co. is closing its Newark location while …
Heather Rene pretty sure the business im.speakimg about has been in the same building for close to 30 years… oh you didnt know that…!?!?!
Reviews
Tiffany Plewes
I have had the pleasure of having the pizza on two different occasions. 1st time we ordered it was the New York pizza. I was excited when I opened the box and seen the HUGE pieces. After tasting it, I was totally in love with the crust! Crust is a big deal to me and this one was thin, but had the most softest chewiest texture to me. I give the crust a 10/10. The sauce, cheese, and toppings were perfectly proportioned. The next time we tried the Detroit pizza and was able to sample a piece of the macaroni pizza they were testing out. The macaroni pizza was super good. I am a huge macaroni lover and was very pleased. If anything I would change it would be to be more saucy…but I am just a girl that likes saucy so it could be just me…but the flavor was on point! The Detroit pizza was very good as well..thick crust was very nice soft and chewy and nice crust around the edges. Perfectly done. I will definitely order from here again and hope to try the cheese bread next as that is one of my favorite items to order when getting pizza.
… moreEd Willey
Got the NY style pizza and it was burnt I mean black in bottom and very little to no sauce at all. Tried the Detroit and asked for extra pizza sauce , could barley find any sauce and the crust was burnt including some of the peps and to make it even grosser for some reason they put hot honey on it yuck. Very disappointing to spend $50 for 2 pizzas that’s getting thrown away ugh. Live too far away to even go back. I always ask for extra sauce on a first time try as to me that is a tall tell of how good the pizza is, this was a miss, and Detroit even though it was burnt still was very doughy. Was really hoping this new place would be the bomb.
… moreJennifer McCormick
It was our first time ordering and the staff was friendly and very helpful . We ordered a 16″ Pan Circle Nona with Pepperoni , sausage and mushroom . Very delicious and we loved it
… moreBrandy Kelley
We got 2 pizzas, NY style & Detroit style. Amazing!!!! Best hands down pizza around!!! Dessert?!? Omgoodness! The Chocolate Dipped Cannolis & Lemon Berry Marscapone, are to die for!!!!! Yes it’s a bit pricey but we don’t mind paying that for the quality we got!!
The girl even carried it out & put it in my back seat!!! Great customer service!!
**attached just 2 pics a managed to get, my hubby did make a post on FB & tagged them in it**
… moreThe girl even carried it out & put it in my back seat!!! Great customer service!!
**attached just 2 pics a managed to get, my hubby did make a post on FB & tagged them in it**
Brian P
Tried this place for the first time. The pizza is good and the NY style is properly cut into giant pie slices (5 stars just for that). I loved the crust, and my only comment would be that I would like just a little more sauce.
… moreJ G
So I give this like a 4 outta 10. A Large 16″ pepperoni is $23 as compared to others in the area that are $15 – $18. Its just so thin and there isn’t much to it or much flavor. I prefer Sbarro pizza over this.
… moreBryan Keller
Circles & Squares Pizza Co in Newark. Kept our order simple. Not sure if I liked the NY or Detroit better. Would order both again for sure. The Detroit crust was thick and airy with that perfect crisp around rhe edge / ingredients taste high quality and the sauce is delicious and garlic comes forward in the flavor profile. NY crust is thin and delicious great bite through went with pepperoni mushroom and extra cheese which is my wife and I”s go to standard pizza order. The cheese is delicious and the flavors were awesome, everything was in perfect ratios and easy to eat and not messy. 100% will be regular customers going forward.
… moreTyler
Anybody that says this place is good, clearly doesn’t know what good is. Straight children’s palate! Pizza was way overpriced. $36 for a deep dish. The flavor? I’d rather eat a Totinos microwave pizza over this again. Only thing I liked about it was the crispy edges. Other than that, the thing wasn’t cooked long enough. Yes, I know, it’s a deep dish. I know how to cook and know what proper deep dish should be like. This wasn’t it! Crenos Quick fire pizza was way better and I only paid $11 for a 11″ pizza with a many toppings as I wanted.
… moreTracy
Some of the best tasting Detroit style pizza I’ve had in a while. The crust looks thick but it isn’t it’s light and the bottom has flavor. The sauce is also pretty good. 10/10 recommend
… moreBrad Bennett
Fantastic Pie! You will need a full size car or truck to pick up the 20″ NY, it just makes it through the door and it needs its own seat. For me, the crust is likely the best part, and the rest does not disappoint.
… more