Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 912 S Main St, Cheshire, CT 06410
Phone: (203) 250-1102
Website: http://www.anthonyspizzeriadeli.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Anthony’s Pizzeria Deli | Pizza Restaurants in Connecticut, USA
Family owned pizzeria and deli located in Cheshire and Wallingford, Connecticut.
Anthony’s Pizzeria and Deli – Cheshire CT – Facebook
Great food is even better with a great team ❤️ We’re proud to serve our community with fresh pizzas, subs, and salads made with care. Thank you for supporting …
Anthony’s Pizzeria & Deli Delivery Menu | 912 S Main St Cheshire
Order delivery or pickup from Anthony’s Pizzeria & Deli in Cheshire! View Anthony’s Pizzeria & Deli’s March 2026 deals and menus.
Reviews
MICHAEL DEFILIO
This is the second time I’ve had a terrible experience at Anthony’s, and I won’t be giving them a third chance.
The first time I visited, I stood in line for several minutes without a single employee acknowledging my presence—or the presence of the other customers waiting around me. What made it worse was watching someone walk in after us and immediately receive service and attention while those of us who had been waiting were completely ignored. It was frustrating, embarrassing, and honestly baffling.
Despite that experience, I decided to give Anthony’s another opportunity by trying their delivery service. Big mistake. The food arrived 30 minutes later than the original estimated time and was ice cold. There’s nothing worse than opening a pizza box only to find something that feels like it’s been sitting out for hours.
I reached out to Anthony’s to share my concerns. The only response I received was a simple “I’m sorry.” No offer to make it right. No effort to redo the order or send out a fresh, hot pizza. I wasn’t even asking for a refund—just basic customer service and some accountability.
This business clearly does not value its customers. Between being ignored in person and receiving cold, late food with zero follow-up, it’s obvious customer service is not a priority here. Be prepared to be treated poorly. Save your money and support an establishment that actually respects and takes care of its customers.
… moreThe first time I visited, I stood in line for several minutes without a single employee acknowledging my presence—or the presence of the other customers waiting around me. What made it worse was watching someone walk in after us and immediately receive service and attention while those of us who had been waiting were completely ignored. It was frustrating, embarrassing, and honestly baffling.
Despite that experience, I decided to give Anthony’s another opportunity by trying their delivery service. Big mistake. The food arrived 30 minutes later than the original estimated time and was ice cold. There’s nothing worse than opening a pizza box only to find something that feels like it’s been sitting out for hours.
I reached out to Anthony’s to share my concerns. The only response I received was a simple “I’m sorry.” No offer to make it right. No effort to redo the order or send out a fresh, hot pizza. I wasn’t even asking for a refund—just basic customer service and some accountability.
This business clearly does not value its customers. Between being ignored in person and receiving cold, late food with zero follow-up, it’s obvious customer service is not a priority here. Be prepared to be treated poorly. Save your money and support an establishment that actually respects and takes care of its customers.
Mike Bradley
Went today for the first time, the pizza was absolutely delicious! Thin and crispy, how a traditional New Haven style pie should be. I’ll definitely be back in the future!
… moreJames Fox
Stopped in Antony’s Pizzeria & Deli this afternoon, what a great place for great food and the most friendly service. Ordered the West Grill Chicken sandwich, absolutely one of the best chicken sandwiches I have ever had, starting with the fresh baked bread , grilled chicken, avocado slices, gruyere cheese, bacon, tomato and aioli. DELI CIOUS……. I am guilty of driving past this wonderful eatery too many times, so glad today was different… give it a shot, you won’t be disappointed.
… moreMichael S.
It’s not like me to post a bad review. However this experience was so bad I just couldn’t help myself. Ordered via phone, showed up on time to pick up and waited 20 mins for the food. It’s a Friday, no big deal.
Upon getting home the pizza was cold. Not slightly warm, not lukewarm. It was stone cold.
Not a problem we thought , we will eat the Mr. Potato Extreme Shoestrings and Arancini we also ordered. Unfortunately no luck with these either. The “Shoestrings” were cheap frozen non shoestring fries out of a bag. No beer cheese to be seen and 5 bits of bacon. I’ve had better fries at the International airport in Guadalajara, MX. Ok, maybe the Arancini will save this miserable experience. NOPE! These were gross and underwhelming too. Not to mention, not as advertised on the menu.
These “restaurants” to use that term very loosely here need to realize people have many choices for food. Do yourself a favor everyone, don’t make this place yours.
Disgusting fry picture attached.
… moreUpon getting home the pizza was cold. Not slightly warm, not lukewarm. It was stone cold.
Not a problem we thought , we will eat the Mr. Potato Extreme Shoestrings and Arancini we also ordered. Unfortunately no luck with these either. The “Shoestrings” were cheap frozen non shoestring fries out of a bag. No beer cheese to be seen and 5 bits of bacon. I’ve had better fries at the International airport in Guadalajara, MX. Ok, maybe the Arancini will save this miserable experience. NOPE! These were gross and underwhelming too. Not to mention, not as advertised on the menu.
These “restaurants” to use that term very loosely here need to realize people have many choices for food. Do yourself a favor everyone, don’t make this place yours.
Disgusting fry picture attached.
Jesus Cabrera
Braised short rib sandwich was something I’ve never had before. Honestly I wanted to order another one, that’s how good it was. Highly recommend passing by and getting this sandwich.
… moreDan “El Kaboom WS” Piper
We ordered the shoe string fries with cheese and bacon. Got seasoned normal fries with cheese and no bacon.
Stuffed bread was as expected.
… moreStuffed bread was as expected.
Justin R
Been a long time since I’ve had this place probably since it opened and don’t remember being to much of a fan. But tried a cutlet today and it was good and I’m picky about my cutlets lol. as well as they use in house bread that’s very good. Definitely good to remember there are good options close by
… moreRussell
Bread is fresh and homemade! Grinders are always on point! Staff is great. Will be back again!
… moreMatthew H
I ordered a large bowl of Anthony’s House Cobb salad. Food was great but i found tiny fungus on the flower stem that touch to my salad. And few broken egg shell too.
… moreCathy Scappini
I ordered the meatball parm sub today. It was so delicious!! The bread tasted like it was homemade! I also picked up peanut butter cookies there, that were so yummy!! I will be going back again!!
… more