Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 251 W Lee Hwy Suite 231, Warrenton, VA 20186
Phone: (540) 935-2266
Website: https://goodfellasva.hungerrush.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Good Fellas Pizza – Warrenton, VA – 251 Lee Hwy – Hours, Menu …
Order Hours About. 10:00 AM-10:00 PM; Shop address is 251 Lee Hwy, Warrenton, VA 20186251 Lee Hwy, Warrenton, VA 20186; (540) 935-2266.
Goodfellas Pizza Online Ordering: OrderType
NY, NC, ND, OH, OK, OR, PA, PR, RI, SC, SD, TN, TX, UT, VT, VA, WA, WV, WI, WY. State. or. Zip. Gate Code. Use My Location. Find a Store. Have an account, or …
Good Fellas Pizza – 251 Lee Hwy, Warrenton, VA 20186 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Warrenton, VA! Good Fellas Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy …
Reviews
Derek Malner
The timely service for pickup orders, generous serving size, and freshness of ingredients granted a five star. We ordered several items for pickup to accommodate a family gathering. Food was ready for pickup 20 minutes after online purchase on a Sunday night. The items we purchased included the XL pizza and wings deal, steak stromboli, pepperoni calzone, cheesesteak sub, meatball marinara sub, and cheeseburger. Goodfellas in Warrenton gave us double the amount of boneless wings we purchased in their special pizza and wings deal, which is nice. The subs and cheeseburger were filling and came with fries. My wife and I sampled most of the items. The thin crust pizza and cheesesteak sub were our favorites. My wife also liked the steak stromboli stating the ingredients were fresh. The meatball marinara sub was okay. It was a bit dry and we should have selected more ingredients to add to it. The cheeseburger was satisfying. Surprisingly the pepperoni calzone wasn’t a big hit. Some family commented the calzone was too greasy. Overall, the pizza, steak strombolli and cheesesteak sub were hits in our fam! Also, important to note the staff at the register and in kitchen were friendly when I picked up.
… moreعلي العامري
:
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
The restaurant is absolutely delicious, and the service is wonderfully warm and welcoming. The staff are friendly and attentive, and the overall atmosphere is very pleasant. I highly recommend visiting!
… more⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
The restaurant is absolutely delicious, and the service is wonderfully warm and welcoming. The staff are friendly and attentive, and the overall atmosphere is very pleasant. I highly recommend visiting!
emely manrrero
Really great food, workers were awesome and cashier was really helpful and nice and waiting time was not a problem at all and service was really great and i totally recommend the sicilian pizza it is the BEST!
… moreMichael Switzer
Update: Ok. So my family and I have ordered twice since our first order which was average. The past 2 times have been awesome! The pizza has been amazing and we really love the Indian paneer pizzas. The margarita pizza is also delicious. They have been quick, polite, and the food is fresh. Good fellas is becoming my favorite local pizza spot! Definitely recommend you give them a try.
******************************************
Original review/order……………
Ordered 2 pizzas, a cheese steak, and humus.
– Pan pizza was ok, crust wasn’t the best. Sauce was good, topping were fresh.
– Regular cheese pizza was good, regular crust is preferred.
– Cheese steak was ok. Pretty basic and comparable to most pizza/sub joints.
– Humus was good.
Overall a 2.5 star experience. We will give Good Fellas another try, but it is not our favorite pizza place.
… more******************************************
Original review/order……………
Ordered 2 pizzas, a cheese steak, and humus.
– Pan pizza was ok, crust wasn’t the best. Sauce was good, topping were fresh.
– Regular cheese pizza was good, regular crust is preferred.
– Cheese steak was ok. Pretty basic and comparable to most pizza/sub joints.
– Humus was good.
Overall a 2.5 star experience. We will give Good Fellas another try, but it is not our favorite pizza place.
dana h
the pizza here is really really good but if i’m paying $3 more for extra onions that means i want extra onions and not the normal amount of onions, thanks
… moreDaniel Miller
I’m always skeptical of “Best of” titles as Good Fellas was awarded this past year for the best pizza in Warrenton. Took me a bit to work up the courage to move away from Joe and Vinnies and Spitonys, but I’m glad I tried them out. We had three large pizzas and a gluten-free pizza. All of them were solid, but my absolute favorite was the tandoori pizza. It was spectacular! It’s one of those pizzas that I’ll be craving again in a week.
Update: We decided to try other dishes other than pizza and although the Philadelphia cheesesteak is okay, it’s by no means a Philadelphia cheesesteak. The meatball sub is about as good as Subway’s. In other words, not worth buying. Beyond pizza, I have to say that it’s a little bit disappointing.
… moreUpdate: We decided to try other dishes other than pizza and although the Philadelphia cheesesteak is okay, it’s by no means a Philadelphia cheesesteak. The meatball sub is about as good as Subway’s. In other words, not worth buying. Beyond pizza, I have to say that it’s a little bit disappointing.
Aaron Priest
Dad was a Master Chef. And while I didn’t make it my career I’ve been cooking since I was 5. I prefer smaller local type places to eat and this place was excellent. Appetizers were perfect and the Sicilian pizza I ordered was phenomenal. Best pizza I’ve had in several years. Staff was great too. Totally recommend this place.
… moreMona Thota
I love their pizzas. I wish the place had little more light and color. But other than that the quality and the service is excellent!!!
… moreDerrick Solomon
It’s a take-out pizza spot but does have seating for about 12-16. So three stars on atmosphere should be viewed as neutral. Service was excellent, friendly, and speedy. We had the Greek pizza and I highly recommend it. Skimpy on the “gyro” meat but the small strips were plump, moist, tender, with a decent flavor. The veggies were bright and fresh. The crust was excellent and the sauce was good and held up well because the pizza was very wet, in a good way, due to the fresh tomatoes. Look, I’m a NYC kid so this pie isn’t comparable nor should it be. For local pizza this is currently my go-to spot. But……. bring your own napkins and your own cup. The single ply, super thin, napkins suck. They are awful and scream cheap, low-class. I get the low cost is attractive and all but we required so many that the savings went out the window. And the beverage cups, same as the napkins. Cheap. So small that I had take my knife and nearly cut them in half. At $3 you feel taken but the getting up 4-5 times to get us soda while we ate 1/2 of a pie was disruptive. I guess no ice was an option. Finally, we ordered a take-out Philly cheese steak pie. It was fine, but I would never order it again. All in all I highly recommend giving them a try. We will be back to explore other menu items!
… morezippity dooda
I conveniently timed my feedstore run with lunch. The crust and the marinara are the make or break for a pizza, calzone, Stromboli. Good Fellas Warrenton’s choice of ingredients and finesse— created a perfect combination of flavor and texture. Portions are enough to share, though I was grateful I didn’t have to share my dessert! Chocolate Mousse Cake— mmm made me chew slower out of pleasure! I am not a chef or a baker so I may get terms wrong (I’m just a foodie)— it seemed to have like a thin layer of chocolate… like a ganache maybe, a dense cake that wasn’t heavy (how is that even possible?!) with a very light and fluffy chocolate mousse between the layers. OMG. I will be back. The menu is extensive— I recommend checking it out before hand. I saw several other meals and desserts I look forward to trying, next visit.
… more