Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 107 NY-303, Valley Cottage, NY 10989
Phone: (845) 268-8797
Website: https://thepiemanpizza.com/?utm_source=google
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Best Pizza in Valley Cottage, NY | The Pieman Pizza | Pizza near me
Our cozy family restaurant and bar serve up Italian comfort food that keeps customers coming back. Whether you’re dining in, picking up, or getting delivery …
The Pieman Pizza Online Menu | Best Pizza in Valley Cottage
CHICKEN FRANCAISE. PARMIGIANA ENTREE. $21.00. Your choice of Thin Italian Seasoned Chicken Cutlet or Fried Eggplant smothered in …
The Pieman Pizza | Valley Cottage NY – Facebook
The Pieman Pizza, Valley Cottage. 1139 likes · 27 talking about this · 977 were here. Pizza place.
Reviews
Andrzej Daszkiewicz
I’ve seen the logo outside, checked the reviews and I really thought i am gonna like the place, but unfortunately I can’t recommend the place. Maybe to go sit down for a beer, but for pizza, NO. 20 dollars for a small 10 inch skinny margaritas that didn’t even fill me up, is just robbery. Plus the flavor was like meh.. ive been to way better places
… moresam wedelich
Our regular pizza spot in Rockland. Everything is SUPER delish, with lots of locally sourced specialty toppings and the BEST GF crust within driving distance.
… moreMel
I used to go to this place as a kid. Decided to give it a chance as an adult:
Overall, loved the atmosphere- music felt very millennial or at least that’s what the jukebox was playing? Regardless, I appreciated it as I am a millennial.
The meatballs were tender, the sauce was fresh and didn’t give me heart burn which it’s rare red sauce doesn’t give me heartburn. Will definitely be ordering the meatballs again
The garlic knots were made from the dough of zeppolis which was interesting. The garlic butter was so yummy! Really phenomenal garlic butter mixture.
The 10” pizza margarita leaves something to be desired. Maybe more cheese??
Got two cocktails- the passion fruit cocktail was about 11 bucks and it was very strong. I couldn’t handle it !
… moreOverall, loved the atmosphere- music felt very millennial or at least that’s what the jukebox was playing? Regardless, I appreciated it as I am a millennial.
The meatballs were tender, the sauce was fresh and didn’t give me heart burn which it’s rare red sauce doesn’t give me heartburn. Will definitely be ordering the meatballs again
The garlic knots were made from the dough of zeppolis which was interesting. The garlic butter was so yummy! Really phenomenal garlic butter mixture.
The 10” pizza margarita leaves something to be desired. Maybe more cheese??
Got two cocktails- the passion fruit cocktail was about 11 bucks and it was very strong. I couldn’t handle it !
Vic Landry
Service was awful, over priced for a tiny undesirable pizza. Come on we live in NY maybe try upgrading to actual “brick-oven” typical Dive bar energy not what me and the family expected for a night out!
… moreAl Schleicher
Over $50 for luke warm 10” pie and order of wings. One & done…much better options out there. Was my pie hot when DoorDash picked it up or was it that DoorDash took 30+ minutes for 3 miles and unlike other pizza places delivery didn’t use a thermal bag to keep it hot? Either way Very disappointing!!
… moreFrank Rizzo
Pretty much the worst pizza I’ve ever had in my life, the service was so slow it was nonexistent, everyone was confused I ordered two small 10 inch pizzas one with sausage one plain. After about 40 minutes the sausage pie came out all of the sausage was clumped on one side. After about 25 minutes when the second pizza never came out I approached the bartender and asked where the other pizza was and I was told there was a mistake and they only ordered one so they ordered me a 10 inch plain pizza. I thought that would be out pretty quickly after about another 25 or 30 minutes a server came out with a margarita pizza, I said I didn’t order a margarita pizza they brought it back into the kitchen and then they brought it back out to the table again. Finally after much discussion in another 10 or 15 minutes the regular pizza finally came out at that point I was so fed up it was ridiculous. The bill was also incorrect as I was charged for a margarita pizza that I never ordered and I did not eat, I just paid the bill left a small tip and left I will never return and neither will any of my friends. So sad it used to be so good and now I think it compares with Papa John’s or less. Also they have valet parking which is ridiculous it’s a pizzeria and a dive bar . Jesus what are these people thinking, I’d like to say I wish them good luck but I don’t think they will be there too long if they keep on the path that they are on
… moreSharanya Chandrasekhar
The pizza here is absolutely fantastic! The crust was delicious. The toppings were fresh, flavorful, and balanced. I’ll definitely be coming back for more!
… moreNestor Portillo
Amazing place to enjoy some good food and craft beer! The pie is Korean white hot, the chicken tossed in goho sauce is tasty, garlic knots are another level! But don’t listen to me just go and try it, you won’t regret it!!
… moreMod
Love the pizza, thin yummy crispy crust, best garlic knots and great waitress. Dessert was delicious too, a big warm soft cookie with ice cream.
… moreMikko Peltoniemi
I like the new incarnation of this place. I had the sausage and pickled hot peppers pizza and a pepperoni pizza and wings with the GoHo sauce.
The pizza is different style than usually in the area, this is more bar pie, or Chicago thin crust style pizza. But very flavorful, especially the sausage.
… moreThe pizza is different style than usually in the area, this is more bar pie, or Chicago thin crust style pizza. But very flavorful, especially the sausage.