Julie Noyes
I ordered a two-tier cake from Eat More Cake for my mother’s surprise 70th birthday party, and they did a wonderful job. The cake featured multiple flavors, beautiful colors, and floral details exactly as I requested. It was absolutely delicious—every layer, filling, and flavor was a hit. I received so many compliments from guests throughout the party.
The prices were also extremely reasonable for the size and level of detail, especially compared to what I’m used to in the Boston area. Most importantly, my mother was so impressed and truly blown away by her cake, which made the moment even more special.
I would definitely recommend Eat More Cake to anyone looking for a beautiful, elevated cake for their celebration.
… moreAshley Engelbrecht
I was incredibly pleased with the outcome of the graduation cake that I ordered! I had provided a picture of what we wanted the cake to look like and they practically matched it! And, of course, it was delicious!
Service got 4 stars only because most of our communications happened through email and I didn’t get a confirmation after asking to increase my cupcake order by 1-dozen and I didn’t receive an estimate or invoice prior to showing up to pick-up and pay; which made me a little anxious.
The atmosphere is clean and crisp. The individual who attended to me upon pick-up was incredibly pleasant and helpful.
… moreChristina Wright-Ivanova
We ordered a custom Dinosaur cake for my son’s 4th Birthday party and it was so beautiful and tasty! Definitely the best b-day cake we ordered ever…
… moreSarah Tracy
I purchased 2 cupcakes and 6 macaroons. The cupcake were good just not my preference on the frosting, I prefer a sweeter frosting. I was disappointed in the macaroons. The flavors seemed good, but they were hard as a rock and crumbled apart. I purchased 4 as a gift and I was happy I ate one first. I would have been embarrassed to give those to someone. I don’t live in Keene and was already home so I could not go back. They should have never been sold. This may have been a one time thing. After paying $28.00 I was pretty disappointed. Overall the reviews look like they make beautiful cakes, probably great for custom orders.
… moremary bird
Good quality cupcakes. 6 cupcakes and a big piece of cinnamon bun with frosting. Yum.
… moreKatie Haley-Kersting
Visited Eat More Cake in August 2024 during a themed weekend in town.
The decorations were great with a photo area which was great to post to social media. Everyone was so nice and kind. We got a dozen cupcakes and some other items for birthday gifts. Great quality items, unique decorations, wonderful flavors and would definitely recommend and visit again.
… moreCarrie Sevene
Eat More Cake provided 2 dozen beautiful cupcakes for a special work occasion recently. Not only did they look good, they tasted wonderful. The new location is so cute and welcoming. A bonus here is there are also local items from other vendors you can purchase. I even have come back 2x – once with my daughter to grab a sweet treat and then wanted to get a birthday treat for a friend.
… moreSarina Vose Meade
Our favorite place to go for goodies! Amy has amazing classic flavors as well as amazing new flavors and combinations to try. She brings my kids crazy ideas to life for birthdays, and parties. And has bern able to work with any allergy. We love Eat More Cake!!!
… moreWalter Martin
Seems like they’re good for custom cakes or whatever but If you want to just walk in here to buy a few cupcakes forget about it. They charge like $20 for 1 below average cinnamon roll and have the nerve to ask for a tip. There are plenty of other decent places to buy baked goods in the area this is definitely not one of them. I don’t mind paying insane prices I just expect the quality and the taste to be actually good
… moreAmorina Lee
I’ve been here more than a few times. The staff is always friendly and they always have a wonderful assortment of goodies. I always get some cupcakes, but they also have macaroons, 1/2 Pound cookies, Gelato, cinnamon buns and make cakes! Today, I got 4 unique cupcakes. Strawberry Shortcake, Lemon, Irish Cream, and Chocolate Caramel. I did start eating before I remembered to take a pick because they are delicious! The buttercream is creamy and delicious, the cakes are moist and fluffy, the decorations are so cute, and the flavors are delicious. I highly recommend checking out Eat More Cake right on Main Street in Keene. I also got 2 Chocolate bars, I spent less than $30 for 2 Chocolate bars and 4 cupcakes, amazing deal!
… more