Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Welcome to Y-Not Pizza, a staple of New Palestine, IN, since 2004. Dedicated to serving great food with exceptional service, we offer a wide menu featuring sandwiches, appetizers, and, of course, pizza. Our journey began with the goal of providing a friendly and affordable dining option for our local community. As we continue to grow, we’re thrilled to serve New Palestine and the neighboring areas. We warmly invite you to visit us today and enjoy a range of delicious offerings, from pizza and wings to nachos, fries, stromboli, burgers, and beyond!
Hours
| Monday | 2:30–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 2:30–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 2:30–10 PM |
| Thursday | 2:30–10 PM |
| Friday | 2:30 PM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 45 E Main St, New Palestine, IN 46163
Phone: (317) 861-5225
Website: https://ynotpizzanp.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Y-Not Pizza & Lounge – New Palestine, IN
Y-Not Pizza & Lounge has been a hometown favorite in New Palestine, Indiana since 2004—but the heart behind the restaurant goes back even further.
Y-Not Pizza & Lounge | New Palestine IN – Facebook
Y-Not Pizza & Lounge, New Palestine. 1379 likes · 16 talking about this · 2517 were here. Great Hometown Pizza restaraunt and BAR.
Y-Not Pizza & Lounge | Pizza Restaurant in New Palestine, IN
Y-Not Pizza & Lounge offers delicious pizzas and a relaxed lounge atmosphere at 45 E Main St, New Palestine, IN. Enjoy great flavors and a welcoming …
Last Updates
Reviews
Victoria Coulombe
GARBAGE $45 IN THE TRASH FOR 2 PIZZAS THAT TASTED HORRIBLE NO ONE WOULD EAT THEM! The crust was awful the bottom was hard as a rock while the top was chewy and it had the worst taste, almost like a chemical taste and it lingers. There was hardly any cheese or pepperoni and while there was more sausage crumbles than anything else there still wasn’t much of that either.
I used to love eating pizza here but its been awhile since I’ve had it and its obviously gone way down hill. Little Cesar’s Pizza is a better, way better and cheaper than this garbage.
Im a little sad because this used to be a favorite place to go to now I’ll never go here again.
Idk what happened if there’s someone newish in charge or what but whoever it is, you ruined the place.
… moreI used to love eating pizza here but its been awhile since I’ve had it and its obviously gone way down hill. Little Cesar’s Pizza is a better, way better and cheaper than this garbage.
Im a little sad because this used to be a favorite place to go to now I’ll never go here again.
Idk what happened if there’s someone newish in charge or what but whoever it is, you ruined the place.
Not Today
First time visit to this pizza joint.
We received coupons in the mail.
We decided to use the “Y-Not” deal coupon- large 1 top/ breadsticks/ 2 liter $20. I called in, told them the coupon I had, gave them the order ( half pepp& half mushroom). They gave me a total- $21 and change, pick up in 20 min.
When my husband walked out to the truck, he only had a pizza and the coupon. I showed him where it said we were supposed to get the breadsticks and 2 liter.
I called in to the store, asked why we didn’t receive the others, and they said we added toppings. But they would get the breadsticks and 2 liter.
He (very) reluctantly walked back in, and came out but had to pay an additional $3.60/ $3.80 something. They didn’t give a receipt.
So because we had half and half toppings, it was that additional charge.
I was NOT happy, but whatever.
Got home and tasted it.
VERY chewy (pre-made) crust. Hard to chew. I mean- my jaws were getting sore so I just ate the toppings after a few pieces. The breadsticks were hot, but dry- even with the cold cheddar cheese.
Overall- would NOT recommend this at ALL! Will NOT be back.
… moreWe received coupons in the mail.
We decided to use the “Y-Not” deal coupon- large 1 top/ breadsticks/ 2 liter $20. I called in, told them the coupon I had, gave them the order ( half pepp& half mushroom). They gave me a total- $21 and change, pick up in 20 min.
When my husband walked out to the truck, he only had a pizza and the coupon. I showed him where it said we were supposed to get the breadsticks and 2 liter.
I called in to the store, asked why we didn’t receive the others, and they said we added toppings. But they would get the breadsticks and 2 liter.
He (very) reluctantly walked back in, and came out but had to pay an additional $3.60/ $3.80 something. They didn’t give a receipt.
So because we had half and half toppings, it was that additional charge.
I was NOT happy, but whatever.
Got home and tasted it.
VERY chewy (pre-made) crust. Hard to chew. I mean- my jaws were getting sore so I just ate the toppings after a few pieces. The breadsticks were hot, but dry- even with the cold cheddar cheese.
Overall- would NOT recommend this at ALL! Will NOT be back.
Meleiah Kennedy
Large pulled pork nacho is pretty much worse than a literal slap in the face lol
… moreCasey Foley
Food was absolutely disgusting. Chicken wings were undercooked, burnt fries, burnt meatballs, missing orders, no communication between employees…trying to charge me twice.
… moreEon.001
Can’t get a simple pizza order right and waited 30 mins to call and tell us they didn’t have our order details. We told them again and when we got our pizza it was burned to a crisp and poorly made. Chicken bacon ranch? I’d say burned bacon ranch.
… moreKyle Corley
Stopped in randomly one night. Seemed like a great establishment. Bar tender was very polite and running her ass off for everyone. There was live karaoke. One patron was singing quite a bit. He was an older gentleman wearing a nice suit. He was pretty good. I’d like to hear more. The younger guy hosting the karaoke was on top of his game and very professional. Im not sure if he works off tips but I hope he made a dollar or two. Ill probably go back
… moreRoss A
First time there. The pizza is worth another trip, but they got my name wrong on my phone in order. The girl corrected it, but another guy behind the counter accused me of already picking up a pizza. When he was corrected by a female coworker, he didn’t apologize and just walked away. Bad vibes.
… moreMegan Ennis
The pepperoni rolls are the best! I get them weekly. Yummy. Tony, the owner, is a doll. He is kind, gentle and loves his pizza joint.
They need to be open earlier in the day pretty please!
… moreThey need to be open earlier in the day pretty please!
Jamie
Ok generally the pizzas are great thats why we return. And I gave it a 2 star because the staff are friendly and accommodating.
However today was not up to par. I ordered 2 LG pizza’s and bread sticks. I ordered the crust hand tossed which I believe is 2.00 more unfortunately the crust was not done so sad. I dont understand how you can get crust so thin not cooked all the way. We finished cooking it in our oven we we got home. Not going to be the same but what can you do.?
… moreHowever today was not up to par. I ordered 2 LG pizza’s and bread sticks. I ordered the crust hand tossed which I believe is 2.00 more unfortunately the crust was not done so sad. I dont understand how you can get crust so thin not cooked all the way. We finished cooking it in our oven we we got home. Not going to be the same but what can you do.?
Seth R
Man the pizza is amazing the service though always sucks. And the building itself is like falling apart in places.
My real gripe is with the rude older woman who works in the kitchen and the fact that they charge an extra percentile to process card payments. I tried to suggest other payment processors and she got huffy with me like I had insulted her. Idk I’ll order carryout here but I’ll wait for other people to cash me out.
… moreMy real gripe is with the rude older woman who works in the kitchen and the fact that they charge an extra percentile to process card payments. I tried to suggest other payment processors and she got huffy with me like I had insulted her. Idk I’ll order carryout here but I’ll wait for other people to cash me out.